- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Powers of the Supreme Court: writs, PILs and jurisdiction
Explain the Supreme Court's writ, original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction, Special Leave Petitions and Public Interest Litigation, with the Articles that provide for them and landmark PIL examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain writ jurisdiction (Articles 32 and 226) and how Public Interest Litigation began.
- Distinguish between the original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
- Explain Special Leave Petitions and the binding force of Supreme Court decisions (Articles 136, 141, 142, 144).
'Jurisdiction' means the authority of a court to hear and decide a particular kind of case. The Supreme Court has several kinds, each provided for by an Article of the Constitution.
Writ jurisdiction: protecting Fundamental Rights
The Constitution's Part III guarantees Fundamental Rights, such as equality, liberty, the right to life, freedom of speech and freedom of religion. To enforce them, a citizen may file a writ petition directly in the Supreme Court under Article 32, where the issue has all-India importance, or in a High Court under Article 226, for violations within that State.
Public Interest Litigation (PIL)
PIL is an innovation of the Supreme Court, filed under Articles 32 and 226, that lets issues of public concern be raised in court and gives meaning to the Right to Life (Article 21). The first reported PIL came from a lawyer, Kapila Hingorani, who read that some under-trial prisoners in Bihar had spent longer in jail than their sentence would have been even if found guilty. On her petition, the Court ordered their release and issued guidelines for releasing almost 40,000 under-trial prisoners across India.
- M. C. Mehta v. Union of India: environmental issues such as cleaning the Ganga and protecting the Taj Mahal.
- Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997): the Court laid down guidelines against sexual harassment at the workplace; Parliament later passed a law on it in 2013.
Worked example 1: who can approach the court?
A student reads that a factory is polluting a river used by many villages. Can someone not personally harmed go to court? Step 1: Ordinarily, a case is filed by the person affected. Step 2: Through PIL, a person may raise an issue of public concern on behalf of others. Step 3: The right to life includes a healthy environment. Answer: yes - a PIL can be filed in a High Court or the Supreme Court, as in M. C. Mehta's environmental cases.
Other kinds of jurisdiction
| Jurisdiction | Article(s) | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Original (exclusive) | 131 | Disputes between the Centre and a State; Centre and a State against another State; between States (e.g. river water) |
| Appellate | 132, 133, 134, 134A | Appeals from High Courts when certified as involving the Constitution or a substantial question of law; certain criminal cases including death sentences; appeals from tribunals such as the NGT and NCLAT |
| Advisory | 143 | Opinion to the President on a question of public importance, heard by a bench of at least five judges |
| Special Leave to Appeal | 136 | Discretion to hear an appeal from any court or tribunal on a question of general public importance or to do justice |
Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
-
Writ
- Article 32
- Enforces Fundamental Rights
- Includes PIL
-
Original
- Article 131
- Centre-State and inter-State disputes
-
Appellate
- Articles 132-134A
- Appeals from High Courts and tribunals
-
Advisory
- Article 143
- Opinion to the President
-
Special leave
- Article 136
- Discretionary appeals
The final word
The law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts in India (Article 141). The Court may pass any order needed to do complete justice (Article 142), and all civil and judicial authorities must act in aid of the Supreme Court (Article 144).
Original jurisdiction means a case starts in that court itself; appellate jurisdiction means the court hears an appeal against a lower court's decision.
Worked example 2: identifying the jurisdiction
Match each case to a jurisdiction. (a) Two States disagree over sharing a river's water - this starts directly in the Supreme Court: original (Article 131). (b) A person appeals against a High Court judgment certified as raising a constitutional question - appellate (Articles 132-134A). (c) The President asks the Court's opinion on a question of public importance - advisory (Article 143). (d) A citizen says her freedom of speech was violated across India - writ (Article 32).
Key takeaways: The Supreme Court enforces Fundamental Rights through writs (Article 32; High Courts use Article 226), and PIL lets public-interest issues reach it, starting with Kapila Hingorani's case on under-trial prisoners. It has original (131), appellate (132-134A), advisory (143) and special leave (136) jurisdiction. Its law binds all courts (141), it can do complete justice (142), and all authorities must aid it (144).
Check your understanding
-
1. Under which Article can a citizen go directly to the Supreme Court to enforce Fundamental Rights?
- Article 226
- Article 131
- Article 32
- Article 143
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 32 allows a writ petition directly before the Supreme Court; Article 226 is the equivalent route in a High Court.
-
2. The first reported PIL, filed by Kapila Hingorani, concerned:
- Under-trial prisoners held in jail longer than their possible sentence
- Pollution of the Ganga
- Workplace harassment
- River water sharing
Show answer
Answer: A. Her petition led to the release of such under-trial prisoners in Bihar and guidelines for releasing almost 40,000 across India.
-
3. A dispute between two States over river water would come under which jurisdiction of the Supreme Court?
- Advisory
- Appellate
- Writ
- Original
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 131 gives the Supreme Court exclusive original jurisdiction over disputes between the Centre and States and between States, such as river water disputes.
-
4. Under Article 143, the Supreme Court may give its opinion to:
- the Prime Minister
- the President of India
- any citizen
- a State Governor
Show answer
Answer: B. Advisory jurisdiction lets the President seek the Court's opinion on a question of law or fact of public importance, heard by a bench of at least five judges.
-
5. Which Article makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts in India?
- Article 141
- Article 136
- Article 144
- Article 124
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 141 makes Supreme Court law binding on all courts; Article 136 concerns special leave, 144 requires authorities to aid the Court, and 124 establishes it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.