Revision notes

Chapter 4 The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Justice, law and the judiciary

The three organs of government

  • Legislature
    • Makes laws
  • Executive
    • Implements laws
  • Judiciary
    • Settles disputes
    • Checks that laws and actions follow the Constitution
    • Independent of the other two

Two aspects of justice

  • Substantive justice
    • Looks at the final result
    • Asks: is the decision fair and reasonable?
    • Example: the right person compensated
  • Procedural justice
    • Looks at the process
    • Every side gets a full hearing
    • Innocent until proved guilty

Presumption of innocence: every accused person is treated as innocent until proved guilty, and must be heard before a decision is taken.

Key terms
TermMeaning
LawA general rule made by government, with consequences for breaking it
JudiciaryThe independent organ that settles disputes according to law
Substantive justiceFairness of the outcome
Procedural justiceFairness of the process; full hearing for all

Key takeaways: The Constitution promises social, economic and political justice. Laws aim at justice, but unjust laws - such as the Criminal Tribes Act and Vernacular Press Act in India, Jim Crow laws in the US and apartheid laws in South Africa - had to be repealed. Justice needs both a fair outcome (substantive) and a fair process (procedural). The independent judiciary checks that laws and government actions follow the Constitution.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Supreme Court of India

The hierarchy of courts in India (from top)

  1. Supreme Court Apex court of the whole country, New Delhi.
  2. High Courts Highest courts at the State level.
  3. Subordinate Courts District-level courts closest to the people.
Appeals generally move upward, from a lower court to a higher one.

The Supreme Court of India, established under Article 124 on 26 January 1950, is the highest court in the country and the final interpreter of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court at a glance
FeatureSupreme Court
Provided for byArticle 124
Came into existence26 January 1950
SeatNew Delhi
HeadChief Justice of India
Appointed byThe President of India
Retirement age65 years
Mottoyato dharmastato jayah

Key takeaways: India has a unified hierarchy - Supreme Court, High Courts, subordinate courts. The Supreme Court, set up under Article 124 on 26 January 1950 in New Delhi, is the final interpreter of the Constitution. Its judges, headed by the Chief Justice of India, are appointed by the President, must meet set qualifications, and retire at 65. Its motto means 'Where there is dharma, there is victory.'

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Powers of the Supreme Court: writs, PILs and jurisdiction

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
JurisdictionArticle(s)What it covers
Original (exclusive)131Disputes between the Centre and a State; Centre and a State against another State; between States (e.g. river water)
Appellate132, 133, 134, 134AAppeals from High Courts when certified as involving the Constitution or a substantial question of law; certain criminal cases including death sentences; appeals from tribunals such as the NGT and NCLAT
Advisory143Opinion to the President on a question of public importance, heard by a bench of at least five judges
Special Leave to Appeal136Discretion to hear an appeal from any court or tribunal on a question of general public importance or to do justice

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

  • Writ
    • Article 32
    • Enforces Fundamental Rights
    • Includes PIL
  • Original
    • Article 131
    • Centre-State and inter-State disputes
  • Appellate
    • Articles 132-134A
    • Appeals from High Courts and tribunals
  • Advisory
    • Article 143
    • Opinion to the President
  • Special leave
    • Article 136
    • Discretionary appeals

Original jurisdiction means a case starts in that court itself; appellate jurisdiction means the court hears an appeal against a lower court's decision.

Key takeaways: The Supreme Court enforces Fundamental Rights through writs (Article 32; High Courts use Article 226), and PIL lets public-interest issues reach it, starting with Kapila Hingorani's case on under-trial prisoners. It has original (131), appellate (132-134A), advisory (143) and special leave (136) jurisdiction. Its law binds all courts (141), it can do complete justice (142), and all authorities must aid it (144).

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

High Courts, subordinate courts and tribunals

Supreme Court and High Court judges

  • Supreme Court
    • Appointed by the President
    • High Court judge 5 yrs / advocate 10 yrs / distinguished jurist
    • Retire at 65
    • Writs under Article 32
  • High Court
    • Appointed by the President after consultation
    • Judicial office or advocate 10 yrs
    • Retire at 62
    • Writs under Article 226; superintendence under 227
Some specialised tribunals
TribunalDecides
Consumer fora (commissions)Consumer disputes
Central Administrative TribunalService matters of government employees
National Green TribunalEnvironmental issues
National Company Law TribunalCompany disputes, including insolvency
Armed Forces TribunalDisputes related to the armed forces
Appellate Tribunal for ElectricityElectricity disputes

A tribunal is a quasi-judicial body that decides only one kind of dispute - such as consumer, environmental or service matters - so that cases are handled by specialists.

Key takeaways: High Courts (Article 214) are the top State courts; their judges are appointed by the President after consultation, need ten years' judicial or advocate experience, and retire at 62; they hear writs (226) and supervise lower courts (227). Subordinate courts, with district judges appointed by the Governor (233), are closest to the people. Tribunals settle specialised disputes. New 2023 laws replaced the IPC, CrPC and Evidence Act.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Digital courts and alternate dispute resolution

Ways to settle disputes outside regular courts
MethodWho decides?Is the result binding?Law
ArbitrationAn independent arbitrator or panel (a retired judge, lawyer or expert) decides after hearing both sides fairlyYes - final, binding and enforceable by a courtArbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
MediationNo one decides; a neutral mediator helps the parties reach their own settlementOnly if the parties agree to a settlementMediation Act, 2023
Lok AdalatA people's court helps settle disputes amicably, pending in court or even before going to courtSettles cases by agreementLegal Services Authorities Act, 1987
Gram NyayalayaMobile village-level courts using a simple procedureYes - they are courtsGram Nyayalayas Act, 2008

Arbitration and mediation

  • Arbitration
    • Arbitrator hears both sides
    • Arbitrator makes the decision
    • Decision is final and binding
    • Enforceable by a court
  • Mediation
    • Neutral mediator assists
    • Mediator cannot decide or impose a view
    • Parties reach their own settlement
    • Most common form of ADR

A mediator helps the parties agree but has no power to decide; an arbitrator hears both parties and gives a decision that is final and legally binding.

From grievance to justice: the options

  1. A dispute arises Between persons, businesses or with government.
  2. Try settlement Negotiation, mediation or a Lok Adalat.
  3. If needed, decide Arbitration, a tribunal or a court.
  4. Appeal if unfair Higher courts up to the Supreme Court.

Key takeaways: Digital initiatives - online case details, e-filing, hybrid hearings, live streaming, translated judgements, the National Judicial Data Grid and the Virtual Justice Clock - make courts more open. Arbitration gives a binding decision; mediation helps parties agree; Lok Adalats settle cases amicably; Gram Nyayalayas are simple village courts. Citizens strengthen justice by raising public concerns.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery