- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Legislative Assembly and what it can and cannot decide
Describe the Delhi Legislative Assembly and name the three State List subjects that are outside its law-making power.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The Legislative Assembly is the house elected by the people of Delhi. It makes laws for Delhi, but not on every subject. Knowing what it can and cannot do is among the most-tested points about Delhi's government.
The Assembly
The Assembly has 70 seats, filled by direct election from territorial constituencies. Some seats are reserved for Scheduled Castes. Its normal term is five years, unless it is dissolved earlier. The members choose a Speaker to preside. Delhi has one house only, an Assembly; it has no Legislative Council.
Elections to the Assembly were revived in 1993 after the 69th Amendment, as you saw in the History of Delhi course.
The three lists
The Constitution divides law-making subjects into three lists. The Union List is for Parliament only. The State List is for state legislatures. The Concurrent List is shared. Article 239AA says that the Delhi Assembly may make laws on subjects in the State List and Concurrent List, so far as those subjects apply to Union Territories, but with three exceptions in the State List.
| Subject | Can the Delhi Assembly make laws on it? |
|---|---|
| Public order | No, kept outside |
| Police | No, kept outside |
| Land | No, kept outside |
| Other State List subjects, such as many matters of local government and public health | Yes, as they apply to Union Territories |
| Concurrent List subjects | Yes, as they apply to Union Territories |
| Union List subjects | No, only Parliament |
Who legislates on what for Delhi?
-
Delhi Assembly
- Most State List subjects
- Concurrent List subjects
- Not public order, police or land
-
Parliament
- Union List subjects
- Can make laws on any matter for Delhi
- Its law prevails over a conflicting Delhi law, unless the Delhi law has the President's assent
Parliament keeps the power to make laws for Delhi on any subject. If a law of the Assembly conflicts with a law of Parliament, the usual rule applies that Parliament's law prevails, except in the special case where the Delhi law was reserved for the President and received his assent. For detail on such cases, check the current legal position.
Memory aid
Remember the three excluded subjects as PPL: Police, Public order, Land. Then everything else on the State and Concurrent Lists is open to the Assembly, subject to the Constitution.
Worked example 1: can the Assembly legislate?
Question: 'Can the Delhi Assembly pass a law on the police of Delhi?' Working: police is one of the three excluded subjects. Answer: No.
Worked example 2: how many members?
Question: 'Delhi's Assembly has 70 seats. If a party needs a simple majority, what is the smallest number of seats it needs when all seats are filled?' Working: half of 70 is 35, so more than 35 is needed. 36 is the smallest whole number above 35. Answer: 36 seats.
Worked example 3: which house?
Question: 'Does Delhi have a Legislative Council?' Working: Delhi has a single-house legislature, the Assembly. Answer: No.
Common mistakes
A common error is to think the Assembly is a full state legislature. It is not. Another is to say that the Assembly has no power over police and also none over anything else; in fact it may legislate on many State List and Concurrent List subjects. A third error is to forget the Union List: only Parliament can legislate on defence, currency and similar subjects, for every part of India including Delhi. When a question asks what the Assembly cannot do, first check whether the subject is one of PPL. If it is, the answer is no. If it is not, check whether it belongs to the Union List. If it does not, the Assembly can usually act, within the limits of the Constitution and the Acts that apply.
PPL: Police, Public order, Land stay outside the Delhi Assembly. Seventy seats, five years, one house.
Key takeaways: the Assembly has 70 elected members, a five-year term and a Speaker. It can legislate on State and Concurrent List subjects as they apply to Union Territories, except police, public order and land. Parliament can legislate for Delhi on any subject.
Check your understanding
-
1. How many seats does the Delhi Legislative Assembly have?
- 70
- 60
- 90
- 40
Show answer
Answer: A. The Delhi Assembly has 70 elected seats.
-
2. Which is NOT within the Delhi Assembly's law-making power?
- Concurrent List subjects
- Some State List subjects
- Police
- A matter applicable to Union Territories on the Concurrent List
Show answer
Answer: C. Police, public order and land are the three State List subjects excluded.
-
3. The three excluded subjects are:
- Education, health and roads
- Police, public order and land
- Banking, defence and railways
- Water, fisheries and forests
Show answer
Answer: B. Remember PPL: Police, Public order, Land.
-
4. What is the normal term of the Delhi Assembly?
- Three years
- Six years
- Four years
- Five years
Show answer
Answer: D. The Assembly continues for five years unless dissolved earlier.
-
5. Does Delhi have a Legislative Council?
- No, it has only the Assembly
- Yes, with a Council of 40
- Yes, but only advisory
- Yes, appointed by the Lieutenant Governor
Show answer
Answer: A. Delhi's legislature has one house, the Legislative Assembly.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.