- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Lieutenant Governor, Chief Minister and Council of Ministers
Say who appoints the Lieutenant Governor and the Chief Minister, what the Council of Ministers does and how the two relate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Delhi has two centres of executive power: the Lieutenant Governor, who represents the Union, and the Chief Minister with the Council of Ministers, who are chosen through the Assembly. Exams ask who appoints whom and who advises whom. This lesson sets out the basics.
The Lieutenant Governor
The Lieutenant Governor is the head of the Delhi executive and the Administrator of the Union Territory. He or she is appointed by the President of India and holds office during the President's pleasure. The Lieutenant Governor is not elected by the people of Delhi, and is not the same as a state Governor, although the two posts look similar.
The Chief Minister and Council of Ministers
Under Article 239AA, there is a Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister to aid and advise the Lieutenant Governor in matters on which the Assembly can make laws. The Chief Minister is appointed by the President. The other ministers are appointed by the President on the advice of the Chief Minister. All ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President.
In practice, the leader of the party or alliance that has the support of the Assembly becomes Chief Minister. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. This means that if the Assembly loses confidence in the government, the whole council must go, not just one minister.
| Post | Who appoints | Elected by the people? |
|---|---|---|
| Lieutenant Governor | The President | No |
| Chief Minister | The President (usually the leader who commands the Assembly's support) | Becomes a member of the Assembly through election |
| Other ministers | The President, on the advice of the Chief Minister | Normally members of the Assembly |
From election to government
- People vote For members of the Legislative Assembly
- Support in Assembly A leader who commands majority support
- Chief Minister appointed By the President
- Ministers appointed On the Chief Minister's advice
- Answerable to the Assembly Collective responsibility
What 'aid and advise' means
The Council of Ministers aids and advises the Lieutenant Governor. Article 239AA also provides for the case where the Lieutenant Governor and the ministers differ. In such a case the Lieutenant Governor refers the matter to the President and acts according to the President's decision. Where the matter is urgent, the Lieutenant Governor may take such action as is needed. Exactly how these provisions work in practice has been the subject of legal argument, so for anything beyond this outline, check the current legal position.
Worked example 1: who appoints the Chief Minister?
Question: 'Who appoints the Chief Minister of Delhi?' Working: under Article 239AA the Chief Minister is appointed by the President. In a state it is the Governor. Answer: the President.
Worked example 2: collective responsibility
Question: 'To which body is the Delhi Council of Ministers collectively responsible?' Working: the council is responsible to the elected house, not to the Lieutenant Governor. Answer: the Legislative Assembly.
Worked example 3: spot the wrong statement
Statement: 'The Lieutenant Governor of Delhi is elected by the voters of Delhi.' Working: the Lieutenant Governor is appointed by the President. The statement is wrong.
Common mistakes
Students often write Governor for Delhi, but a Governor belongs to a state. Another mistake is to think the voters choose the Lieutenant Governor, or that the Chief Minister takes oath from the Chief Justice of India. Keep the link simple: the President appoints, the Assembly holds the ministers to account. Also notice the difference between being appointed and being supported. A Chief Minister is appointed formally, but is in practice the person who can show support in the Assembly. Finally, remember that these rules sit inside a wider legal debate on the exact balance of power between the Lieutenant Governor and the elected government, so never state more than the Article itself says.
Lieutenant Governor and Chief Minister are both appointed by the President. The Council of Ministers aids and advises, and answers to the Assembly.
Key takeaways: the Lieutenant Governor is appointed by the President. The Chief Minister is also appointed by the President, other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice. The Council of Ministers aids and advises and is collectively responsible to the Assembly. Where the Lieutenant Governor and ministers differ, the President decides.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi?
- The voters of Delhi
- The Chief Minister
- The President of India
- The Speaker of the Assembly
Show answer
Answer: C. The Administrator, designated Lieutenant Governor, is appointed by the President.
-
2. The Council of Ministers in Delhi is headed by the:
- Chief Minister
- Lieutenant Governor
- Speaker
- Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 239AA provides for a Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister.
-
3. To whom is the Delhi Council of Ministers collectively responsible?
- The Supreme Court
- The Municipal Corporation
- The Election Commission
- The Legislative Assembly
Show answer
Answer: D. Collective responsibility is to the elected house, the Legislative Assembly.
-
4. Other ministers in Delhi are appointed by the President on the advice of the:
- Lieutenant Governor alone
- Chief Minister
- Chief Secretary
- Speaker
Show answer
Answer: B. The President appoints other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice.
-
5. If the Lieutenant Governor and ministers differ on a matter, Article 239AA says the matter is referred to the:
- Speaker
- High Court
- President
- Prime Minister's Office
Show answer
Answer: C. The Lieutenant Governor refers the matter to the President and acts on the President's decision.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.