- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Lieutenant Governor and the Council of Ministers: appointments and relations
Fix who appoints whom, to whom each is answerable, and the rule when they disagree.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson is about the executive. Exam questions tend to be matching and 'who appoints' items, plus a few that test the rule for disagreement between the Lieutenant Governor and ministers. Learn the table and the memory chain below.
| Office | Appointed by | Answerable to / advised by |
|---|---|---|
| Lieutenant Governor | The President | The President |
| Chief Minister | The President | Assembly (support) |
| Other ministers | The President, on the Chief Minister's advice | Assembly (collectively) |
| Council of Ministers | As above | Aids and advises the Lieutenant Governor on matters where the Assembly can legislate |
Delhi executive
-
President of India
- Appoints the Lieutenant Governor
- Appoints the Chief Minister
- Appoints other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice
-
Legislative Assembly
- Council of Ministers collectively responsible to it
- Support decides who can be Chief Minister
Rule for disagreement
If the Lieutenant Governor and the ministers differ on a matter, the Lieutenant Governor refers it to the President and acts on the President's decision. In a matter that is urgent, the Lieutenant Governor may take immediate action that appears necessary, and the Article provides that this does not wait for the reference. Questions asking how far the Lieutenant Governor must follow the ministers' advice have been argued in court. For anything more than the outline above, say that the position must be checked in the current legal position.
Common traps
- 'The Lieutenant Governor is chosen by the Chief Minister.' Wrong; the President appoints.
- 'The Council of Ministers is responsible to the Lieutenant Governor alone.' Wrong; it is collectively responsible to the Assembly.
- 'The Lieutenant Governor has no role in Delhi's executive.' Do not go this far; the Article gives the Lieutenant Governor a defined role, and its exact working has been argued, so state only what Article 239AA says.
- 'Ministers hold office for five years.' Wrong; they hold office during the pleasure of the President, and the council answers to the Assembly.
Memory chain
P-C-M: the President appoints the Chief Minister, and the Chief Minister advises on the Ministers. Then A-A: the council Aids and advises, and answers to the Assembly.
Worked example 1: appointment
Question: 'Who appoints other ministers in Delhi?' Working: the President appoints them on the advice of the Chief Minister. Answer: the President, on the Chief Minister's advice.
Worked example 2: disagreement
Question: 'What is the first step if the Lieutenant Governor and ministers differ?' Working: the Article says the Lieutenant Governor refers the matter to the President. Answer: reference to the President.
Worked example 3: spot the error
Statement: 'The Lieutenant Governor is elected by the Assembly.' Working: the President appoints. Answer: the statement is wrong.
Exam-style drills
Drill 1: 'The Council of Ministers of Delhi aids and advises: (a) the Speaker, (b) the Lieutenant Governor, (c) the Chief Justice.' Working: the Article says it aids and advises the Lieutenant Governor, so (b). Drill 2: 'Which two offices are both appointed by the President: Lieutenant Governor, Speaker, Chief Minister?' Working: the Speaker is chosen by the members of the Assembly, so the pair is Lieutenant Governor and Chief Minister. Speed method: write P for appointed by the President and A for chosen by the Assembly next to each office, then answer from your notes.
One more caution: do not confuse appointment with removal or with accountability. The President appoints, but the ministers must keep the support of the Assembly to function; that is the meaning of collective responsibility. If one minister resigns, the council does not fall. If the Assembly loses confidence in the council as a whole, the whole council is affected. Questions that test this idea often use the word collectively, so underline it in your notes.
PCM: President appoints, Chief Minister advises on Ministers. AA: Aids and advises; answerable to Assembly.
Key takeaways: the President appoints the Lieutenant Governor, Chief Minister and other ministers (on the Chief Minister's advice). The council is collectively responsible to the Assembly. In disagreement, refer to the President. Beyond this outline, check the current legal position.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Chief Minister of Delhi?
- The Lieutenant Governor alone
- The President
- The Speaker
- The voters directly
Show answer
Answer: B. Under Article 239AA the President appoints the Chief Minister.
-
2. The Delhi Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the:
- Municipal Corporation
- Delhi Police
- High Court
- Legislative Assembly
Show answer
Answer: D. Collective responsibility is to the elected Assembly.
-
3. What happens when the Lieutenant Governor and ministers differ?
- The matter is referred to the President
- It goes to the Speaker
- The Chief Minister decides
- The High Court decides at once
Show answer
Answer: A. The Article provides for reference to the President.
-
4. Other ministers in Delhi are appointed on whose advice?
- Speaker's
- Chief Secretary's
- Chief Minister's
- Commissioner of Police's
Show answer
Answer: C. The President acts on the Chief Minister's advice.
-
5. Which statement is wrong?
- The Lieutenant Governor is elected by the Assembly
- The Lieutenant Governor is appointed by the President
- Ministers hold office during the President's pleasure
- The council aids and advises
Show answer
Answer: A. The Lieutenant Governor is appointed, not elected.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.