- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Who makes which law: Assembly, Parliament and the three excluded subjects
Decide quickly whether the Assembly or Parliament can make a law on a given subject for Delhi.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The split of law-making power in Delhi gives rise to many exam questions: 'Can the Assembly legislate on X?' The method below turns each such question into a four-step check that takes under a minute.
The four-step check
- Step 1: Is the subject in the Union List (defence, currency, foreign affairs and so on)? If yes, only Parliament can legislate.
- Step 2: Is it police, public order or land? If yes, the Delhi Assembly cannot legislate.
- Step 3: Is it in the State List or Concurrent List, and applicable to Union Territories? If yes, the Assembly can legislate.
- Step 4: Even then, Parliament can legislate for Delhi on any matter, and its law prevails over a conflicting Delhi law, except where a Delhi law was reserved for the President and received his assent.
Four steps to decide
- Union List? Parliament only
- Police, public order, land? Not the Assembly
- State or Concurrent List? Assembly may legislate
- Conflict with Parliament? Parliament's law generally prevails
| Subject | Assembly? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Defence of India | No | Union List |
| Police | No | One of the three excluded subjects |
| Public order | No | One of the three excluded subjects |
| Land | No | One of the three excluded subjects |
| A Concurrent List matter applicable to Union Territories | Yes | Article 239AA permits it |
| A State List matter other than the three | Yes | Article 239AA permits it, as it applies to Union Territories |
The traps
Trap 1: 'The Assembly may not legislate on law and order, so it may not legislate at all on the police-related things.' The excluded entries are specific. Matters that are in the State or Concurrent Lists and not among the three can be legislated on. Trap 2: 'Parliament cannot legislate for Delhi because it has an Assembly.' Wrong; Parliament keeps power over Delhi. Trap 3: 'Land means anything to do with buildings.' Do not stretch the entry. If a question gets into the fine points of an entry, the answer is to check the current legal position, as courts have interpreted these matters.
Memory aids
- PPL: Police, Public order, Land are excluded.
- Order of checking: Union List first, then PPL, then State and Concurrent Lists.
- The Assembly makes laws, Parliament may override.
Worked example 1: defence
Question: 'Can the Delhi Assembly legislate on defence?' Working: Step 1, defence is in the Union List, so only Parliament. Answer: No.
Worked example 2: a Concurrent List subject
Question: 'Can the Assembly legislate on a Concurrent List subject that applies to Union Territories?' Working: Step 3, Article 239AA allows it. Answer: Yes.
Worked example 3: conflict
Question: 'An Assembly law conflicts with an earlier Act of Parliament on a Concurrent List matter and was not reserved for the President. Which prevails?' Working: Step 4, Parliament's law prevails in the usual case. Answer: the law of Parliament.
Exam-style drills
Drill 1: 'Which of these can the Delhi Assembly NOT legislate on: (a) a Concurrent List subject, (b) police, (c) a State List subject outside PPL?' Working: police is excluded, so (b). Drill 2: 'Which body can legislate on Delhi for any matter?' Working: Parliament. A neat speed method: ask first 'is it on the Union List?' and then 'is it PPL?' If both answers are no, the Assembly can generally act. Do not try to recall the entry numbers during an exam unless you are sure of them; the three names are enough. Where a question turns on the meaning of an entry, such as what counts as land, the answer is to check the current legal position, since courts interpret such terms.
Union List: Parliament only. PPL: not the Assembly. State or Concurrent: Assembly. Parliament can override.
Key takeaways: use the four-step check. Remember PPL. Parliament can legislate for Delhi on any matter. Do not stretch the three excluded entries; where they are disputed, check the current legal position.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these can only Parliament legislate on for Delhi?
- A Concurrent List matter applicable to Union Territories
- A State List matter outside PPL
- Defence of India
- Any matter the Speaker selects
Show answer
Answer: C. Defence is in the Union List.
-
2. Which is one of the three subjects excluded from the Assembly?
- Local government
- Public order
- Public health
- Education
Show answer
Answer: B. The excluded State List subjects are police, public order and land.
-
3. The memory aid PPL stands for:
- Police, Public order, Land
- Parliament, President, Law
- Power, Planning, Law
- Policy, Panchayat, Land
Show answer
Answer: A. PPL is a memory aid for the three excluded subjects.
-
4. If a Delhi law conflicts with an Act of Parliament and was not reserved for the President, generally:
- The Delhi law prevails
- Both are void
- The Lieutenant Governor decides
- Parliament's law prevails
Show answer
Answer: D. Parliament's law prevails in the usual case.
-
5. Can Parliament make laws for Delhi on matters on which the Assembly can legislate?
- Yes
- No, never
- Only with the Assembly's permission
- Only on Concurrent List
Show answer
Answer: A. Parliament can legislate for Delhi on any matter.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.