- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Comprehension practice 3: an argumentative passage
Read a passage that argues a point and answer questions on the writer's view, evidence and tone.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
An argumentative passage tries to persuade. Look for the claim, the reasons and the writer's attitude. Questions often ask which statement the writer would agree with.
Method for argumentative passages
- Find the claim: what does the writer want you to believe?
- List the reasons given.
- Note counter-arguments the writer admits or rejects.
- Identify the tone.
Worked example
Passage: Some argue that students should never use calculators because they weaken mental skills. This is too sweeping. A calculator saves time on long calculations and lets the learner concentrate on understanding the problem. The sensible rule is to practise basic sums by hand first and then use the tool for lengthy work.
Claim: calculators should be used sensibly, after basic skills are learned. Question: What would the writer most likely agree with? Answer: that calculators are useful if basic skills are practised first. The writer rejects the extreme view ('too sweeping') but accepts part of the argument.
Find the claim, then the reasons, then the attitude.
Key takeaways
- Find the claim and reasons.
- Notice counter-views.
- Tone shows attitude.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the lesson's calculator passage, what is the writer's claim?
- Calculators should be banned from schools because they weaken mental skills
- Calculators should be used sensibly after basic sums are practised by hand
- Calculators are always better than mental sums, even for basic work
- Calculators are useless and should never be used by any student
Show answer
Answer: B. The writer ends: 'practise basic sums by hand first and then use the tool for lengthy work' - a sensible middle position.
-
2. The writer calls the 'never use calculators' view 'too sweeping'. This means the writer thinks the view is:
- Very clever
- Related to cleaning
- Too broad and extreme
- Completely correct
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Sweeping' describes a statement that covers too much. The writer thinks 'never' goes too far.
-
3. In the lesson's calculator passage, which statement would the writer most likely agree with?
- Students should never practise sums by hand
- Calculators always harm learning
- Mental skills are of no use
- A calculator can save time on long calculations
Show answer
Answer: D. The writer says a calculator 'saves time on long calculations'. The other options are extreme positions the writer does not hold.
-
4. What is the tone of the calculator passage?
- Balanced and practical
- Angry and complaining
- Sarcastic and mocking
- Fearful and worried
Show answer
Answer: A. The writer accepts part of the opposing view, rejects the extreme part and gives a sensible rule - a balanced, practical tone.
-
5. In the lesson's method for argumentative passages, what is the FIRST thing to find?
- The tone - how the writer feels about it
- The counter-arguments - views opposed to the writer
- The claim - what the writer wants you to believe
- The hardest word - the one you do not know
Show answer
Answer: C. The order given is: find the claim, list the reasons, note counter-arguments, then identify the tone.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.