- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Comprehension practice 9: why wrong options tempt you
Learn the four reasons a wrong option looks right, too strong, half true, off topic and reversed, and use them to eliminate options quickly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Comprehension options are not random. A wrong option is usually written to look right for a particular reason. If you know the reasons, you can eliminate options by name, saving time and avoiding traps. This lesson names four types, applies them to a passage and shows you how a careful reader decides.
Four reasons a wrong option tempts you
| Trap | What it looks like | How to catch it |
|---|---|---|
| Too strong | Uses always, never, all, only, completely | The passage rarely says things so strongly |
| Half true | Part of the option matches, part does not | Check every part of the option |
| Off topic | True in real life, but not in the passage | Find the supporting sentence |
| Reversed | Says the opposite of what the passage says | Check who did what, or which came first |
The passage
*Some schools require students to wear a uniform; others do not. Supporters of uniforms say that they reduce the pressure to compete in clothes, so that students need not feel ashamed of simple clothing. They add that a uniform saves parents the daily worry about what to buy. Critics reply that uniforms limit self-expression and can be costly for families who must buy them every year. The best arrangement may be a simple, low-cost uniform, supplied or made easily available, with some freedom for students to choose colours or accessories on special days.*
Worked example: naming the trap in each option
Question: According to the passage, supporters say uniforms: (A) make all students equal in every way (B) reduce pressure to compete in clothes (C) are always cheaper than ordinary clothes (D) were chosen by students themselves.
- (A) is too strong. The passage says uniforms reduce pressure, not that they make students equal in every way.
- (B) matches the sentence 'reduce the pressure to compete in clothes'. This is the answer.
- (C) is too strong and off topic. The passage never says uniforms are always cheaper; it says they save parents a daily worry.
- (D) is off topic. Nothing is said about students choosing uniforms.
A second example
Question: The critics think that uniforms: (A) save parents from daily worry (B) can be costly and limit self-expression (C) should be banned everywhere. Working: (A) is reversed: it is the supporters, not the critics, who say this. (C) is too strong: the passage never says uniforms should be banned everywhere. (B) matches. Answer: (B).
A third example: half true
Question: The writer's suggestion is: (A) a simple, low-cost uniform with some freedom (B) a costly uniform with no freedom (C) no uniform, but strict dress rules. Working: The passage recommends the first option. A tempting wrong option such as 'a simple, low-cost uniform with no freedom at all' would be half true, since it matches the first part but changes the second. Answer: (A).
Name the trap: too strong, half true, off topic or reversed. An option you can name is an option you can reject.
A routine for the exam
- Read the question and predict an answer before you look at the options.
- Match each option with its supporting sentence, or name its trap.
- If two options remain, read both again and look for the small word that makes one of them too strong.
- Do not spend more than a minute on one question.
Key takeaways
- There are four common reasons for a wrong option.
- Extreme words are danger signs.
- Half-true options need a full check.
- Always find the supporting sentence.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the passage, which group says uniforms save parents daily worry?
- Students
- Critics of uniforms
- Supporters of uniforms
- Teachers
Show answer
Answer: C. The sentence about saving parents the daily worry belongs to the supporters. Giving it to the critics would be a reversed option.
-
2. The word 'costly' in the passage is used to describe:
- uniforms bought every year
- clothes worn on special days
- parents' daily worry
- simple clothing
Show answer
Answer: A. The critics say uniforms can be costly for families who must buy them every year.
-
3. Which option is TOO STRONG?
- Uniforms reduce pressure to compete
- Uniforms may limit self-expression
- Some schools do not require uniforms
- Uniforms always cost less than other clothes
Show answer
Answer: D. The word 'always' goes beyond the passage, which never compares costs in this way.
-
4. The writer's own view is that:
- every school should ban uniforms of any kind
- a low-cost uniform with some freedom may be best
- uniforms should be the same in every school
- students must never be allowed to choose anything
Show answer
Answer: B. The passage says 'the best arrangement may be a simple, low-cost uniform ... with some freedom'. The word 'may' also shows the view is offered tentatively.
-
5. Which trap is an option that says the opposite of the passage?
- Off topic
- Half true
- Reversed
- Too strong
Show answer
Answer: C. A reversed option states the opposite, for example giving the critics' view to the supporters.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.