- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Assertion-reason and statement questions on climate change
Apply a fixed method to assertion-reason and multiple-statement questions on greenhouse gases, feedbacks, sea level, mitigation and agreements, with the usual traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statement-based questions on climate change reward careful reading. A mostly correct sentence may hide a wrong detail, and an assertion may be true while its reason is not the explanation. Use the routine below, and keep in mind the facts that appear most often.
Routine
- Judge the assertion alone.
- Judge the reason alone.
- If both are true, ask whether the reason explains the assertion.
- For statement groups, mark each as true or false before looking at the options.
- Beware of absolute words such as 'only', 'always' and 'never'.
Facts that are tested often
| Topic | Correct | Common wrong version |
|---|---|---|
| Floating sea ice | Melting does not noticeably raise sea level | Melting raises sea level a lot |
| Land ice | Melting raises sea level | No effect |
| Water vapour | A feedback: more with warmth, amplifies warming | A direct main cause of the rise in CO₂ |
| Methane | Higher warming potential than CO₂ over 100 years, shorter lifetime | Longer lifetime than CO₂ |
| Adaptation | Reduces harm from changes, e.g. sea walls | Cuts emissions |
| Mitigation | Cuts emissions or boosts sinks, e.g. solar power | Prepares for floods |
Judge each part. If both parts of an assertion-reason pair are true, test whether the reason explains the assertion.
Worked examples
Example 1. Assertion: melting of Arctic sea ice speeds up warming. Reason: dark open water absorbs more sunlight than ice. Both are true, and the reason explains the assertion (the ice-albedo feedback). Answer: A.
Example 2. Assertion: melting of floating sea ice raises sea level substantially. Reason: ice is less dense than water. The assertion is false, since floating ice already displaces its own weight of water. The reason is a true fact but does not support the assertion. Answer: D (assertion false, reason true).
Example 3. Assertion: methane has a higher global warming potential than carbon dioxide over 100 years. Reason: methane stays in the air longer than carbon dioxide. The assertion is true. The reason is false: methane has a much shorter lifetime. Answer: C (assertion true, reason false).
Example 4. Assertion: ozone depletion is the main cause of global warming. Reason: CFCs destroy ozone. The assertion is false, because greenhouse gases are the main cause. The reason is true as a fact. Answer: D.
Example 5 (statements). (1) Afforestation is a mitigation measure. (2) Building sea walls is a mitigation measure. (3) Carbon sinks absorb carbon dioxide. Statements 1 and 3 are true, because planting trees adds a sink and sinks take up CO₂. Statement 2 is false, because sea walls are adaptation. The correct choice is 1 and 3 only.
Example 6 (the word only). 'Carbon dioxide is the only greenhouse gas.' This is false, because methane, nitrous oxide, water vapour and others also trap heat. 'Carbon dioxide is the greenhouse gas whose rise most affects long-term warming' is a defensible statement. One careful word changes the truth of a sentence.
Example 7 (matching cause and measure). Which fits better with the problem of sea-level rise on a coast: mangrove planting or switching to solar power? Both can help in the long run, but mangroves are an adaptation that reduces damage from waves and storm surges, while solar power is mitigation. The question wording decides which is wanted.
Common traps
- Treating a true reason as a correct explanation just because it is true.
- Assuming that every effect of global warming comes from the ozone hole.
- Confusing mitigation (cutting causes) with adaptation (reducing harm).
- Reading 'only' or 'all' without checking the exceptions.
Key takeaways
Test each part alone, then the link. Know the standard facts in the table. Treat absolute words with suspicion.
Check your understanding
-
1. Assertion: melting Arctic sea ice can speed up further warming. Reason: dark open water absorbs more sunlight than ice does. Which is correct?
- Both true, and the reason explains the assertion
- Both true, but the reason does not explain it
- Assertion true, but the reason is false
- Assertion false, but the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Loss of ice exposes darker water, which absorbs more energy and amplifies warming. Both statements are true and linked.
-
2. Assertion: methane has a shorter lifetime than carbon dioxide. Reason: methane is destroyed by chemical reactions in the air. Which is correct?
- Both true, but the reason does not explain it
- Both true, and the reason explains the assertion
- Assertion false, but the reason is true
- Assertion true, but the reason is false
Show answer
Answer: B. Methane lasts about a decade in the air because chemical reactions remove it, which explains its short lifetime.
-
3. Which of the following is a mitigation measure?
- Raising the height of sea walls
- Planting forest to take up CO₂
- Building new flood shelters
- Changing crop dates only
Show answer
Answer: B. Planting forests creates a carbon sink and lowers atmospheric CO₂. The other options reduce harm, so they are adaptation.
-
4. Statements: (1) Melting land ice raises sea level. (2) Melting floating ice raises sea level greatly. (3) Warming water expands. Which group is correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
- 1 and 3 only
Show answer
Answer: D. Land ice adds water and warm water expands, so 1 and 3 are true. Floating ice already displaces its own weight, so 2 is false.
-
5. Assertion: the ozone hole is the main cause of global warming. Reason: CFCs destroy ozone. Which is correct?
- Both true, and the reason explains it
- Assertion true, but the reason is false
- Assertion false, but the reason is true
- Both the assertion and reason are false
Show answer
Answer: C. Global warming is mainly due to greenhouse gases. CFCs do destroy ozone, so the reason is true but does not make the assertion correct.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.