- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Ozone depletion versus global warming: clearing up the confusion
Separate the causes, locations, effects and agreements for ozone depletion and the enhanced greenhouse effect, a classic area of exam traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many students mix up the ozone hole and global warming. Examiners know this and set questions that depend on it. The two problems are different in cause, in place, in effect and in the way the world has tried to solve them. This lesson sets them side by side.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Ozone depletion | Global warming |
|---|---|---|
| Main cause | Chemicals such as CFCs and halons that release chlorine and bromine | Greenhouse gases such as CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O |
| Where | The stratosphere, high above the ground | The troposphere, the lowest layer, and the surface |
| What happens | Less ozone, so more ultraviolet-B reaches the ground | More heat is trapped, so temperature rises |
| Main effects | Skin cancer, eye cataracts, damage to crops and plankton | Warming, sea-level rise, changes in rainfall |
| Main agreement | Montreal Protocol | UN climate agreements such as the Paris Agreement |
How ozone is destroyed
Sunlight breaks CFC molecules high in the stratosphere and frees chlorine atoms. A chlorine atom takes an oxygen atom from an ozone molecule: Cl + O₃ → ClO + O₂. Then ClO reacts with a free oxygen atom: ClO + O → Cl + O₂. The chlorine atom is released again, so it works as a catalyst and can destroy ozone molecules over and over. Ozone loss is greatest over Antarctica in spring, where very cold polar clouds help the reactions.
Overlaps and links
- Some CFCs are also strong greenhouse gases, so ending their use helped the climate as well as the ozone layer.
- Replacement chemicals called HFCs do not harm ozone, but they are strong greenhouse gases, and a later amendment to the Montreal Protocol deals with them.
- Ground-level (tropospheric) ozone is a pollutant and a greenhouse gas, unlike the protective ozone high above.
- Ultraviolet radiation does not cause global warming, since it is not the heat radiation that greenhouse gases trap.
Ozone hole = stratosphere, CFCs, ultraviolet, Montreal Protocol. Global warming = troposphere, greenhouse gases, heat, climate agreements.
Worked examples
Example 1. Classify each statement. (a) Skin cancer cases rise because more ultraviolet reaches the ground: ozone depletion. (b) Glaciers retreat because the air is warmer: global warming. (c) CFCs from old refrigerators damage the stratosphere: ozone depletion. (d) Methane from rice fields traps heat: global warming.
Example 2. A student writes that 'the ozone hole lets the Sun's heat in, which causes global warming'. What is wrong? The ozone hole lets in more ultraviolet-B, which damages living tissue, but it is not the cause of the warming of the climate. Warming is caused by greenhouse gases that absorb heat radiated by the Earth. The two problems have different causes.
Example 3. One chlorine atom goes through the two-step cycle 50 times. How many ozone molecules does it help destroy? One in each Cl + O₃ step, so 50. In reality a single atom can destroy many thousands before it is removed, which is why small amounts of CFCs cause large losses.
Example 4. Name a measure that helps both problems. Ending the use of CFCs, because many of them are potent greenhouse gases as well as ozone-destroyers. Another is making refrigeration more efficient, which saves energy and avoids leakage of gases.
Common traps
- Placing the ozone layer in the troposphere; it is in the stratosphere.
- Saying the ozone hole is a real hole; it is a region of very low ozone.
- Saying that CO₂ destroys ozone; it does not.
- Mixing up the Montreal Protocol (ozone) with climate agreements.
Key takeaways
Keep the causes, layers, effects and treaties separate, and notice where the two problems touch, such as CFCs and HFCs.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which gases are mainly responsible for ozone depletion?
- Chlorofluorocarbons
- Natural methane gas
- Excess carbon dioxide
- Atmospheric water vapour
Show answer
Answer: A. CFCs release chlorine in the stratosphere, which destroys ozone. Carbon dioxide and methane are greenhouse gases but do not destroy ozone.
-
2. In which layer of the atmosphere is the protective ozone layer found?
- Troposphere
- Stratosphere
- Mesosphere
- Thermosphere
Show answer
Answer: B. The ozone layer lies in the stratosphere, above the troposphere where we live.
-
3. Increased ultraviolet-B radiation at the surface is a result of
- Ozone depletion
- Methane emissions
- Ocean acidification
- Higher carbon dioxide only
Show answer
Answer: A. Less stratospheric ozone allows more ultraviolet-B to reach the ground.
-
4. The Montreal Protocol is mainly about
- Reducing greenhouse gases from vehicles
- Protecting wetlands
- Phasing out ozone-depleting substances
- Protecting migratory birds
Show answer
Answer: C. The Montreal Protocol phased out ozone-depleting chemicals such as CFCs.
-
5. Why can a chlorine atom destroy many ozone molecules?
- It acts as a catalyst, reused each time
- It is completely used up in one step
- It is a greenhouse gas in the air
- It combines with ozone to form chlorine
Show answer
Answer: A. Chlorine takes part in the cycle but is released again, so it can repeat the reactions many times.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.