- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Where ozone-depleting substances were used and what replaced them
Connect ozone-depleting chemicals to everyday uses such as refrigerators, foams, sprays and fire fighting, and learn how their substitutes differ in safety for ozone and climate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Ozone-depleting chemicals did not arrive by accident. They were once valued products, used in homes, shops, farms and factories. Knowing where each was used helps you remember the list, and knowing what replaced them helps you answer questions on the Montreal Protocol and on why a substitute can still cause a different problem.
Why they were so popular
Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) are gases or easily vaporised liquids that do not burn, are not poisonous in ordinary use, and do not react with metals or other materials. For making things cold, pushing out sprays and making foam, these qualities were ideal. The same stability that made them safe to handle also let them survive the journey up to the stratosphere, where sunlight breaks them apart and releases chlorine.
Uses of the main ozone-depleting substances
| Substance | Former use | What attacks ozone |
|---|---|---|
| CFCs | Refrigerators and air conditioners, aerosol sprays, foam plastics | Chlorine |
| Halons | Fire extinguishers for equipment that water would damage | Bromine |
| Carbon tetrachloride | Cleaning solvent and in making other chemicals | Chlorine |
| Methyl chloroform | Cleaning of metal parts and electronics | Chlorine |
| Methyl bromide | Fumigant to kill pests in soil and stored grain | Bromine |
| HCFCs | Replacement refrigerants and foam blowing agents | Chlorine (but much less) |
What replaced them
The substitutes came in stages. HCFCs were an early choice because they break down partly in the lower atmosphere and so harm ozone far less than CFCs, but they still contain chlorine. They were therefore treated as a temporary step. The next group, HFCs (hydrofluorocarbons), contain no chlorine or bromine, so they do not harm the ozone layer. However, HFCs are strong greenhouse gases, so they add to global warming. For this reason later agreements also control them.
Other substitutes include natural refrigerants such as ammonia, carbon dioxide and hydrocarbons like propane, which do not damage ozone, and which have a much lower effect on climate than HFCs. Hydrocarbons are flammable, so equipment using them must be designed with care. For pest control, methods such as heat treatment, careful storage and other fumigants replaced methyl bromide.
| Group | Contains chlorine or bromine? | Harm to ozone | Warming effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| CFCs | Yes, chlorine | High | High |
| HCFCs | Yes, chlorine | Low | Moderate to high |
| HFCs | No | None | Often high |
| Natural refrigerants | No | None | Very low |
Worked examples
Example 1. An old refrigerator's coolant is labelled as a CFC. A repairer wants to replace it with a coolant that does not harm ozone at all. Which groups qualify? Working: ozone harm needs chlorine or bromine in the molecule. HCFCs contain chlorine, so they are not completely safe. HFCs and natural refrigerants contain neither element, so they do not harm ozone. The answer is HFCs or natural refrigerants.
Example 2. A student says 'HFCs solve all the problems because they are safe for ozone.' Evaluate. Working: HFCs have zero effect on ozone, which is true, but many are powerful greenhouse gases. A leak adds to global warming. So HFCs solve the ozone problem but not the climate problem, and the statement is only half right.
Example 3. Match each use to its substance: (a) fumigating stored grain, (b) fire extinguishers in a computer room. Working: (a) methyl bromide was used as a fumigant, so (a) matches methyl bromide. (b) halons were used for fire fighting where water would damage equipment, so (b) matches halons. Both contain bromine, which makes them especially harmful to ozone.
CFCs: cooling, foam and sprays. Halons: fire fighting. Methyl bromide: fumigation. HFCs spare ozone but warm the climate.
Key takeaways: CFCs, halons, carbon tetrachloride, methyl chloroform, methyl bromide and HCFCs were all widely used before they were controlled. Chlorine and bromine are the elements that harm ozone. HCFCs were a temporary step, HFCs have no ozone effect but warm the climate, and natural refrigerants avoid both problems when used safely.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which ozone-depleting substance was mainly used in fire extinguishers?
- CFCs
- Methyl chloroform
- HFCs
- Halons
Show answer
Answer: D. Halons contain bromine and were used to fight fires where water would damage equipment.
-
2. Methyl bromide was used mainly as a:
- Refrigerant in homes
- Fumigant against pests
- Spray can propellant
- Paint-removing solvent
Show answer
Answer: B. Methyl bromide was a soil and grain fumigant. It contains bromine, which destroys ozone.
-
3. Which group of substitutes contains no chlorine and no bromine?
- HFCs
- CFCs
- HCFCs
- Halons
Show answer
Answer: A. HFCs have hydrogen, fluorine and carbon only, so they do not harm the ozone layer. CFCs and HCFCs contain chlorine, and halons contain bromine.
-
4. Why were HCFCs considered only a temporary replacement for CFCs?
- They are very poisonous gases
- They cannot cool anything well
- They still contain chlorine
- They are far too heavy to use
Show answer
Answer: C. HCFCs harm ozone much less than CFCs but still contain chlorine, so they were planned to be phased out too.
-
5. A refrigerant has zero ozone depletion but is a strong greenhouse gas. Which group does it most likely belong to?
- CFCs
- Halons
- Carbon tetrachloride
- HFCs
Show answer
Answer: D. HFCs contain no chlorine or bromine, so they spare ozone, but many are strong greenhouse gases.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.