• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Choosing the best course of action: evaluating options and avoiding the common traps

Evaluate case-study options against legality, public interest, stakeholders, proportionality and sustainability, and recognise traps such as resigning, blind obedience, passing the buck or acting outside the law.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most case studies end with a request to list the options available, evaluate each and state the course you would adopt. Examiners reward a method, not a slogan. This lesson gives a five-filter test for options, a list of the traps that keep appearing, and two cases solved in full.

The five filters

  1. Legality: is the option within the law, rules and lawful orders?
  2. Public interest: does it serve the people the office exists for, especially the vulnerable?
  3. Stakeholders: who gains, who loses, and are the losses justified?
  4. Proportionality: does the response match the size of the problem, neither too little nor too much?
  5. Sustainability: does it fix the cause or only today's symptom, and can it be defended later on the record?

An option that fails the legality filter is out, however attractive. Among the lawful options, prefer the one that best serves the public interest with the least avoidable harm, and that you can explain in writing.

The traps

Trap options in case studies
Trap optionWhy it fails
ResignAbandons the duty and the people affected; disproportionate to most problems
Follow orders blindlyA clearly unlawful order does not remove personal responsibility
Refuse rudely or confront in publicDamages working relations and often the outcome; firmness can be polite
Pass the buck to someone elseAvoids responsibility; the problem continues
Act outside the law for a good endFails the legality filter and sets a dangerous precedent
Do nothing and waitLets harm continue; usually a breach of duty
Go to the media firstSkips lawful channels; may breach conduct rules

Worked example 1: the oral order

Case: Jaspreet, a sub-divisional officer, is told orally by a senior to issue an occupancy permit for a mall that lacks fire-safety clearance, 'because the inauguration date is fixed'. Options: (a) issue it as told; (b) refuse and resign; (c) seek the order in writing, note on the file that fire clearance is pending, and issue the permit only after clearance while offering to speed up the fire inspection; (d) leak the matter to the press. Evaluation: (a) fails legality and the public interest, since shoppers face a fire risk. (b) is disproportionate and leaves the file to someone more pliable. (d) skips lawful channels. (c) passes all five filters: it is lawful, protects the public, respects the senior by offering a solution, is proportionate and leaves a record. Answer: (c).

Worked example 2: compassion and rules

Case: Lakshmi, a ward officer, finds that a migrant family without local documents cannot enrol their children in the government school before the term begins. Options: (a) refuse, since documents are missing; (b) enrol them by entering a false address; (c) enrol them provisionally under any lawful provision for children without documents, help the family get papers and inform the education officer; (d) tell the family to try another district. Evaluation: (a) is lawful but fails the public interest and compassion, as the children lose a year. (b) fails legality. (d) passes the buck. (c) is lawful, serves the children and fixes the cause by getting the papers. Answer: (c). Note the pattern: the best option is usually a combination of immediate relief and a lasting fix, inside the law.

Rule to remember: first strike out every option that breaks the law; among the rest, choose the one that best serves the public with the least harm, fixes the cause and can be defended in writing.

Key takeaways: test options for legality, public interest, stakeholders, proportionality and sustainability; resigning, blind obedience, buck-passing, illegal shortcuts, waiting and running to the media are recurring traps; the strongest course often combines immediate relief, a lasting fix and a written record.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which filter is applied first, because an option that fails it is ruled out however attractive?

    1. Popularity with the media
    2. Speed
    3. Legality
    4. Approval of colleagues
    Show answer

    Answer: C. An unlawful option cannot be chosen by a public servant, whatever its other merits, so legality is the first filter.

  2. 2. A senior orally orders you to clear a file that breaks the rules. The best response is usually to:

    1. Politely point out the rule, ask for the order in writing and record your view on the file
    2. Clear the file at once, since the senior is responsible for the order and will answer for it later
    3. Resign immediately rather than be part of an unlawful decision, and say nothing to anyone else
    4. Report the senior to the media before anyone else in the department has been told about the order
    Show answer

    Answer: A. This keeps you within the law, respects the senior and creates a record. Blind compliance, resignation and a media leak are all trap options.

  3. 3. Why does 'follow orders blindly' fail as a course of action?

    1. Because officers must never follow orders from their seniors, even when the order is lawful and clear
    2. Because orders given to officers are always unlawful in nature, so every order must be refused at once
    3. Because it is slower than refusing and discussing every order, which would make offices work faster
    4. Because carrying out a clearly unlawful order does not remove the officer's own responsibility
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Lawful orders must be followed, but an officer remains answerable for carrying out a clearly unlawful one. Obedience is not a defence for an illegal act.

  4. 4. In case studies, the strongest option is often one that:

    1. Reaches the goal quickly by bypassing the rules that cause delay and by recording the reasons afterwards
    2. Combines immediate relief, a lasting fix and a written record, all within the law
    3. Shifts the decision to another office to avoid blame and to keep the officer's own record clean
    4. Waits until every stakeholder agrees before it acts at all, whatever the cost of the delay to citizens
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Relief plus a lasting fix serves the people affected now and later, and a written record makes the decision defensible. The other options are traps: illegality, buck-passing and delay.

  5. 5. Entering a false address to enrol a child in school fails mainly the filter of:

    1. Legality
    2. Public interest
    3. Compassion
    4. Stakeholder benefit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The intention is kind and the child benefits, but the method is illegal, so it fails the first filter. A lawful route must be found instead.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery