• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Naming the value or principle at stake: exam-style questions on civil service values and the Nolan principles

Practise identifying which civil service value or Nolan principle a piece of conduct shows or breaks, using clue words and an elimination routine for options that look alike.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A common question type describes a short piece of conduct and asks which value or principle it shows or breaks. Two or three options usually look reasonable. This lesson gives a clue table, an elimination routine and practice with the pairs that are closest to each other.

Clue words that point to a value

Clue words
If the case is about…Think first of…
Favour to a person, relative, caste or localityImpartiality
Favour to a political party, or campaigningNon-partisanship
Deciding on data, evidence, meritObjectivity
Effort beyond what the rule demandsDedication to public service
Understanding someone's feelings or positionEmpathy
Acting to relieve sufferingCompassion
Respecting a different belief or way of lifeTolerance
Gifts, obligations, private gainIntegrity (Nolan's integrity principle)
Withholding or sharing informationOpenness
Answering for decisions, accepting scrutinyAccountability
Personal example that sets the standard for othersLeadership

The elimination routine

  1. Underline the action in the case, not the background story.
  2. Ask who benefits or is harmed: a person, a party, the public, the officer?
  3. Ask what kind of failing or virtue it is: about information, decisions, feelings or obligations?
  4. Eliminate options that describe the motive of a different person in the story.
  5. If two options remain, pick the one that is necessary to describe the act; the other is usually a by-product.

Worked example 1: impartiality or objectivity?

Case: A selection board gives higher interview marks to candidates from the chairman's home district, though their written scores are similar to others'. Step 1, the action: higher marks to one district. Step 2, who benefits: a group of persons defined by locality. Step 3, kind: favour to persons. Step 4, both objectivity and impartiality seem broken. Step 5, which is necessary? The defining wrong is favouring a group; the lack of objectivity follows from it. Answer: impartiality. If the case had said the board ignored the written scores and marked everyone alike on 'gut feeling', objectivity would be the answer.

Worked example 2: openness or honesty?

Case: Asked by a journalist, a public health officer says there has been 'no outbreak', though she knows of twelve confirmed cases. Step 1, the action: a false statement. Step 2, kind: not merely withholding information but asserting something untrue. Step 3, options openness and honesty: declining to comment without a lawful reason would breach openness; saying something false breaches honesty. Answer: honesty, with openness also affected. The difference between staying silent and lying is the key.

Rule to remember: silence is an openness question; a falsehood is an honesty question. A favour to a person is impartiality, a favour to a party is non-partisanship, and ignoring evidence is objectivity.

Leadership and selflessness in practice

Leadership in Nolan's sense is not about being a strong boss. It means displaying the principles in one's own behaviour, promoting them and challenging poor conduct in others. A senior officer who quietly tolerates subordinates taking 'speed money' breaches leadership even if she takes nothing herself. Selflessness is breached whenever a decision is shaped by the official's own interest instead of the public interest, for example choosing the site of a new office because it is near one's own home.

Key takeaways: read the action, then ask who benefits and what kind of failing it is; persons point to impartiality, parties to non-partisanship, evidence to objectivity; silence is openness, falsehood is honesty; leadership means setting and enforcing the standard, not merely holding rank.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An officer chooses the site for a new office because it is near his own house, though a more central site was available. The Nolan principle chiefly breached is:

    1. Openness
    2. Leadership
    3. Selflessness
    4. Accountability
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The decision was shaped by his own convenience rather than the public interest, which is a breach of selflessness.

  2. 2. A district head knows her staff take small payments to speed up files and does nothing, though she takes nothing herself. Which principle does she breach?

    1. Openness
    2. Objectivity
    3. Selflessness
    4. Leadership
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Leadership requires promoting the principles and challenging poor conduct in others. Tolerating her staff's corruption breaches it even though she is personally clean.

  3. 3. Refusing, without any lawful reason, to tell a citizen the criteria used to select beneficiaries breaches mainly:

    1. Honesty
    2. Selflessness
    3. Non-partisanship
    4. Openness
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Withholding information without a clear and lawful reason is an openness failure. No false statement was made, so honesty is not the main issue.

  4. 4. A panel scores every candidate on 'overall impression' without looking at the written test results. The value mainly missing is:

    1. Impartiality, because it favours one group
    2. Non-partisanship
    3. Compassion
    4. Objectivity
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Everyone is treated alike, so no group is favoured, but the decision ignores the available evidence. That is a failure of objectivity.

  5. 5. During an election, an officer posts on social media praising one party's manifesto. This mainly breaches:

    1. Non-partisanship
    2. Empathy with the voters
    3. Objectivity in analysis
    4. Compassion for citizens
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Publicly taking a political side while in service breaches non-partisanship, which requires civil servants to stay politically neutral in their official role.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery