- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Naming the value or principle at stake: exam-style questions on civil service values and the Nolan principles
Practise identifying which civil service value or Nolan principle a piece of conduct shows or breaks, using clue words and an elimination routine for options that look alike.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A common question type describes a short piece of conduct and asks which value or principle it shows or breaks. Two or three options usually look reasonable. This lesson gives a clue table, an elimination routine and practice with the pairs that are closest to each other.
Clue words that point to a value
| If the case is about… | Think first of… |
|---|---|
| Favour to a person, relative, caste or locality | Impartiality |
| Favour to a political party, or campaigning | Non-partisanship |
| Deciding on data, evidence, merit | Objectivity |
| Effort beyond what the rule demands | Dedication to public service |
| Understanding someone's feelings or position | Empathy |
| Acting to relieve suffering | Compassion |
| Respecting a different belief or way of life | Tolerance |
| Gifts, obligations, private gain | Integrity (Nolan's integrity principle) |
| Withholding or sharing information | Openness |
| Answering for decisions, accepting scrutiny | Accountability |
| Personal example that sets the standard for others | Leadership |
The elimination routine
- Underline the action in the case, not the background story.
- Ask who benefits or is harmed: a person, a party, the public, the officer?
- Ask what kind of failing or virtue it is: about information, decisions, feelings or obligations?
- Eliminate options that describe the motive of a different person in the story.
- If two options remain, pick the one that is necessary to describe the act; the other is usually a by-product.
Worked example 1: impartiality or objectivity?
Case: A selection board gives higher interview marks to candidates from the chairman's home district, though their written scores are similar to others'. Step 1, the action: higher marks to one district. Step 2, who benefits: a group of persons defined by locality. Step 3, kind: favour to persons. Step 4, both objectivity and impartiality seem broken. Step 5, which is necessary? The defining wrong is favouring a group; the lack of objectivity follows from it. Answer: impartiality. If the case had said the board ignored the written scores and marked everyone alike on 'gut feeling', objectivity would be the answer.
Worked example 2: openness or honesty?
Case: Asked by a journalist, a public health officer says there has been 'no outbreak', though she knows of twelve confirmed cases. Step 1, the action: a false statement. Step 2, kind: not merely withholding information but asserting something untrue. Step 3, options openness and honesty: declining to comment without a lawful reason would breach openness; saying something false breaches honesty. Answer: honesty, with openness also affected. The difference between staying silent and lying is the key.
Rule to remember: silence is an openness question; a falsehood is an honesty question. A favour to a person is impartiality, a favour to a party is non-partisanship, and ignoring evidence is objectivity.
Leadership and selflessness in practice
Leadership in Nolan's sense is not about being a strong boss. It means displaying the principles in one's own behaviour, promoting them and challenging poor conduct in others. A senior officer who quietly tolerates subordinates taking 'speed money' breaches leadership even if she takes nothing herself. Selflessness is breached whenever a decision is shaped by the official's own interest instead of the public interest, for example choosing the site of a new office because it is near one's own home.
Key takeaways: read the action, then ask who benefits and what kind of failing it is; persons point to impartiality, parties to non-partisanship, evidence to objectivity; silence is openness, falsehood is honesty; leadership means setting and enforcing the standard, not merely holding rank.
Check your understanding
-
1. An officer chooses the site for a new office because it is near his own house, though a more central site was available. The Nolan principle chiefly breached is:
- Openness
- Leadership
- Selflessness
- Accountability
Show answer
Answer: C. The decision was shaped by his own convenience rather than the public interest, which is a breach of selflessness.
-
2. A district head knows her staff take small payments to speed up files and does nothing, though she takes nothing herself. Which principle does she breach?
- Openness
- Objectivity
- Selflessness
- Leadership
Show answer
Answer: D. Leadership requires promoting the principles and challenging poor conduct in others. Tolerating her staff's corruption breaches it even though she is personally clean.
-
3. Refusing, without any lawful reason, to tell a citizen the criteria used to select beneficiaries breaches mainly:
- Honesty
- Selflessness
- Non-partisanship
- Openness
Show answer
Answer: D. Withholding information without a clear and lawful reason is an openness failure. No false statement was made, so honesty is not the main issue.
-
4. A panel scores every candidate on 'overall impression' without looking at the written test results. The value mainly missing is:
- Impartiality, because it favours one group
- Non-partisanship
- Compassion
- Objectivity
Show answer
Answer: D. Everyone is treated alike, so no group is favoured, but the decision ignores the available evidence. That is a failure of objectivity.
-
5. During an election, an officer posts on social media praising one party's manifesto. This mainly breaches:
- Non-partisanship
- Empathy with the voters
- Objectivity in analysis
- Compassion for citizens
Show answer
Answer: A. Publicly taking a political side while in service breaches non-partisanship, which requires civil servants to stay politically neutral in their official role.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.