Revision notes

Integrity: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Spotting conflicts of interest in case studies: classify, then disclose, recuse or divest

Matching the remedy to the conflict
SituationUsual remedyWhy
One-off decision involving a relative or friendDisclose and recuse from that decisionSomeone else can take the decision
Continuing financial interest, such as shares in a firm the officer regulatesDisclose and divest, or move to a role without that linkRecusing from every decision would leave the officer unable to do the job
Minor interest shared with the general public, such as owning a house in a city whose property tax is being revisedDisclose; recusal usually not neededThe interest is general, not special to the officer
Perceived conflict onlyDisclose and explain; recuse if trust would otherwise sufferAppearances shape public confidence

Rule to remember: a declared interest is a managed risk; a hidden interest is misconduct. When in doubt, disclose in writing and let someone else decide.

Key takeaways: work through interest, duty, classification and remedy; disclosure is almost always the first action; recusal suits one-off decisions, divestment suits continuing interests; self-confidence, resignation and over-strictness are trap options.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Naming the value or principle at stake: exam-style questions on civil service values and the Nolan principles

Clue words
If the case is about…Think first of…
Favour to a person, relative, caste or localityImpartiality
Favour to a political party, or campaigningNon-partisanship
Deciding on data, evidence, meritObjectivity
Effort beyond what the rule demandsDedication to public service
Understanding someone's feelings or positionEmpathy
Acting to relieve sufferingCompassion
Respecting a different belief or way of lifeTolerance
Gifts, obligations, private gainIntegrity (Nolan's integrity principle)
Withholding or sharing informationOpenness
Answering for decisions, accepting scrutinyAccountability
Personal example that sets the standard for othersLeadership

Rule to remember: silence is an openness question; a falsehood is an honesty question. A favour to a person is impartiality, a favour to a party is non-partisanship, and ignoring evidence is objectivity.

Key takeaways: read the action, then ask who benefits and what kind of failing it is; persons point to impartiality, parties to non-partisanship, evidence to objectivity; silence is openness, falsehood is honesty; leadership means setting and enforcing the standard, not merely holding rank.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Classifying corruption and testing probity in procedures

Weak points and safeguards
Weak pointExampleProbity safeguard
MonopolyOnly one clerk can issue a certificateOnline application with a time limit and an appeal route
Wide discretionInspector decides what is a 'violation' without criteriaPublished checklist; reasons recorded in writing
No transparencyTender terms shared with one bidderPublic notice of tenders; the same information to all bidders
No scrutinyDecisions never reviewedRandom audit; disclosure under the Right to Information Act, 2005
Cash at the counterFees paid in cash face to faceDirect digital payment with receipts

Rule to remember: label every case twice, petty or grand and coercive or collusive, then fix the specific weak point: cut monopoly, narrow discretion, raise accountability.

Key takeaways: classify by scale and by who gains; collusive corruption hides because no party complains; monopoly, discretion and weak accountability create the opportunity; safeguards should target the specific weakness; transferring or blaming one person rarely fixes a problem in the system.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Whistle-blowing and codes in practice: when to speak, to whom and how

Rule to remember: verify, then climb the ladder one rung at a time (superior, internal channel, external authority, public), in writing, and only as far as the failure below requires.

Key takeaways: whistle-blowing concerns serious wrongdoing in the public interest; check the facts first; internal before external, statutory bodies before the media; write everything down; codes of conduct provide the duty and codes of ethics the reason; silence, an instant leak and resignation are common trap options.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Choosing the best course of action: evaluating options and avoiding the common traps

Trap options in case studies
Trap optionWhy it fails
ResignAbandons the duty and the people affected; disproportionate to most problems
Follow orders blindlyA clearly unlawful order does not remove personal responsibility
Refuse rudely or confront in publicDamages working relations and often the outcome; firmness can be polite
Pass the buck to someone elseAvoids responsibility; the problem continues
Act outside the law for a good endFails the legality filter and sets a dangerous precedent
Do nothing and waitLets harm continue; usually a breach of duty
Go to the media firstSkips lawful channels; may breach conduct rules

Rule to remember: first strike out every option that breaks the law; among the rest, choose the one that best serves the public with the least harm, fixes the cause and can be defended in writing.

Key takeaways: test options for legality, public interest, stakeholders, proportionality and sustainability; resigning, blind obedience, buck-passing, illegal shortcuts, waiting and running to the media are recurring traps; the strongest course often combines immediate relief, a lasting fix and a written record.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery