• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Aristotle: character, flourishing and the golden mean

Understand Aristotle's virtue ethics: eudaimonia, virtue as a mean between excess and deficiency, habit, and practical wisdom, and apply them to simple cases.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Aristotle (384-322 BCE) studied at Plato's Academy and later taught Alexander of Macedon. Where many later thinkers ask 'what rule should I follow?', Aristotle asks 'what kind of person should I become?'. This approach, called virtue ethics, is central to discussions of character in public service, so it deserves careful study.

The goal: eudaimonia

In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle observes that everything we do aims at some good, and that the highest good, sought for its own sake, is eudaimonia, usually translated as flourishing or living well. It is not a passing feeling of pleasure but a whole life lived well. To find what living well means for humans, he uses the function argument: the special function of a human being is to live by reason, so a good human life is one of rational activity done excellently, that is, in accordance with virtue.

Two kinds of virtue

  • Intellectual virtues, such as wisdom and understanding, grow mainly through teaching and experience.
  • Moral virtues (virtues of character), such as courage, generosity and justice, grow through habit. We become just by doing just acts and brave by doing brave acts, just as we become builders by building.

This is why Aristotle stresses upbringing and practice. Character is not given by nature, nor is it against nature; we have the capacity, and habit completes it.

The golden mean

A moral virtue is a settled disposition to feel and act in the right way, at a mean between two vices: one of excess and one of deficiency. The mean is 'relative to us', not an arithmetic midpoint. It means feeling and acting at the right time, about the right things, towards the right people, for the right end and in the right way.

Examples of Aristotle's mean
Area of lifeVice of deficiencyVirtue (mean)Vice of excess
Facing dangerCowardiceCourageRashness
Giving moneyStinginess (meanness)Generosity (liberality)Wastefulness (prodigality)
Speaking about oneselfFalse modestyTruthfulnessBoastfulness
AngerLack of spiritGood temperIrascibility

Aristotle adds that some actions and feelings have no mean at all, because their names already imply they are bad: envy, spite, shamelessness, theft and murder are examples. There is no 'right amount' of theft.

Practical wisdom

Finding the mean in a real situation needs phronesis, or practical wisdom: the ability to see what matters in a particular case and judge well. Rules alone cannot do this, because situations differ. Aristotle also called the human being a political animal, meaning we flourish only in a community, which links his ethics to his Politics.

Worked example 1: courage in a flood

Tehsildar Kavita must decide whether to lead a rescue boat into a flooded village at night. Step 1: name the virtue at stake: courage. Step 2: name the extremes. Refusing to act when she has a trained crew and life-jackets would be cowardice; going alone into a fast current with no equipment would be rashness. Step 3: find the mean relative to her situation: go with the trained crew and safety gear, after informing the control room. Step 4: note the role of practical wisdom, which reads the current, the equipment and the urgency. The courageous act is neither the safest nor the most daring, but the right one.

Worked example 2: generosity with public money

A panchayat secretary wants to help a festival committee. Step 1: the virtue is generosity, but the money is public, so justice also applies. Step 2: refusing all help to a legitimate community event out of habit would lean towards meanness; giving whatever is asked without checking rules would be wastefulness, and with public money also injustice. Step 3: the mean is to give what the rules allow, to the right purpose, with accounts kept. Aristotle's point is that virtue means hitting the target, not just avoiding one error.

Aristotle: become good by practising good acts; a virtue is the mean between excess and deficiency, found by practical wisdom, and the goal is a flourishing life.

  • Eudaimonia, or flourishing, is the highest good for Aristotle.
  • Moral virtues come from habit; intellectual virtues mainly from teaching.
  • Virtue is a mean between two vices, relative to the person and situation.
  • Some acts, like theft and murder, have no mean.
  • Practical wisdom (phronesis) is needed to find the mean in real cases.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to Aristotle, moral virtues are acquired mainly through:

    1. Reading philosophy
    2. Divine grace
    3. Habit and practice
    4. Calculating pleasures
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Aristotle says we become just by doing just acts; moral virtues are formed by habituation, while intellectual virtues develop mainly through teaching.

  2. 2. In Aristotle's scheme, courage is the mean between:

    1. Cowardice and rashness
    2. Pride and humility
    3. Wastefulness and stinginess
    4. Anger and patience
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Cowardice is the deficiency of courage and rashness its excess. Wastefulness and stinginess are the extremes around generosity.

  3. 3. Which statement about Aristotle's golden mean is correct?

    1. It is always the exact arithmetic midpoint
    2. Every action, including theft, has a right amount
    3. It applies only to rulers
    4. It is relative to the person and the situation
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Aristotle says the mean is 'relative to us': the right feeling or action depends on time, people, purpose and manner. Some acts such as theft have no mean.

  4. 4. The Greek word for practical wisdom in Aristotle's ethics is:

    1. Eudaimonia
    2. Phronesis
    3. Elenchus
    4. Telos
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Phronesis is practical wisdom. Eudaimonia means flourishing, elenchus is Socratic questioning and telos means purpose or end.

  5. 5. An officer spends public money on a lavish function far beyond what the occasion needs. In Aristotle's terms this is closest to:

    1. Wastefulness, the excess around generosity
    2. Stinginess, the deficiency around generosity
    3. Courage
    4. Truthfulness
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Giving or spending beyond what is right is the vice of excess (prodigality or wastefulness). Stinginess would be spending too little.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery