- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Confucius, the social contract thinkers and John Rawls
Meet the thinkers of society and state: Confucius on humaneness and ritual, Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau on the social contract, and Rawls on justice as fairness.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The thinkers so far focused mainly on the individual: knowledge, character, duty and happiness. This lesson turns to ethics of relationships and the state. Confucius links personal virtue to good government; the social contract thinkers ask why we should obey a state at all; and John Rawls asks what makes a society's basic structure just. Each idea is a favourite in questions about governance.
Confucius: virtue in relationships
Confucius (551-479 BCE by traditional dating) was a Chinese teacher whose sayings were collected by his followers in the Analects. His key concepts are:
- Ren: humaneness or benevolence, genuine concern for others.
- Li: ritual propriety, the proper forms of conduct in family and society.
- Junzi: the exemplary or noble person, who cultivates ren and li; opposed to the petty person who seeks only profit.
- Xiao: filial piety, respect and care for parents, the root of other virtues.
- Rectification of names: titles must match conduct; a ruler should truly act as a ruler, a minister as a minister.
Confucius taught that a ruler who governs by virtue and example wins willing loyalty, whereas one who governs only by laws and punishments gets people who avoid punishment but feel no shame. He also expressed a negative form of the golden rule: do not impose on others what you would not want for yourself.
The social contract: Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau
| Thinker | Key work | State of nature | What the contract creates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) | Leviathan (1651) | A war of all against all; life insecure and short | A strong sovereign to keep peace |
| John Locke (1632-1704) | Two Treatises of Government (1689) | Governed by natural law; people have rights to life, liberty and property | A limited government by consent that protects rights; people may resist tyranny |
| Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778) | The Social Contract (1762) | Humans naturally free and fairly peaceful; corrupted by society | Rule by the general will, aimed at the common good |
The shared idea is that political authority is justified by the agreement, real or hypothetical, of the people it governs. For a public servant this means power is held in trust for citizens, not owned by the office.
John Rawls: justice as fairness
John Rawls (1921-2002), an American philosopher, revived the social contract in A Theory of Justice (1971). He asks us to imagine choosing principles of justice in an original position, behind a veil of ignorance: we do not know our class, caste, gender, talents or beliefs. Unable to tilt the rules in our own favour, rational people would choose fair principles. Rawls argued they would choose two:
- First principle: each person has an equal right to the most extensive basic liberties compatible with the same liberties for all.
- Second principle: social and economic inequalities are acceptable only if (a) they work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged (the difference principle) and (b) they are attached to positions open to all under fair equality of opportunity.
The first principle has priority over the second: basic liberties may not be traded for economic gains.
Worked example 1: designing a school admission rule
A committee must set rules for admission to a new government school. Step 1: apply the veil of ignorance: members imagine they do not know whether their own child is rich or poor, urban or rural, able-bodied or disabled. Step 2: they reject a rule favouring families who can pay donations, since they might be the family that cannot. Step 3: they choose open admission with support for disadvantaged children. Step 4: check the difference principle: extra support creates unequal treatment, but it benefits the least advantaged, so Rawls would accept it.
Worked example 2: a Confucian district head
A new district head, Rohan, finds staff arriving late. Option one: issue a circular threatening penalties. Option two: arrive early himself, greet staff, explain why punctuality serves citizens, and enforce rules fairly when needed. Step 1: identify Confucius' view that ruling by example creates a sense of shame and loyalty, whereas punishment alone creates mere avoidance. Step 2: identify rectification of names: a head must actually act as one. Conclusion: Confucius would favour the second option, with rules as support rather than the main tool.
Confucius: govern by virtue and example. Social contract: authority rests on the consent of the governed. Rawls: choose rules behind a veil of ignorance; inequalities must benefit the least advantaged.
- Confucius: ren, li, junzi, filial piety and rectification of names.
- Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau ground political authority in a social contract.
- Rawls: original position, veil of ignorance, two principles and the difference principle.
Check your understanding
-
1. In Confucian thought, 'ren' refers to:
- Ritual propriety
- Humaneness or benevolence
- Filial piety
- The exemplary person
Show answer
Answer: B. Ren is humaneness or benevolence. Li is ritual propriety, xiao is filial piety and junzi is the exemplary person.
-
2. Which thinker described the state of nature as a war of all against all and argued for a strong sovereign?
- Thomas Hobbes
- John Locke
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- John Rawls
Show answer
Answer: A. Hobbes in Leviathan pictured the state of nature as insecure and violent, justifying a strong sovereign. Locke saw natural rights and limited government.
-
3. Rawls's 'veil of ignorance' is a device to ensure that:
- People choose principles that favour the majority in society
- Judges are kept ignorant of the identity of parties in each case
- People choose principles without knowing their own position in society
- The state hides its decisions from citizens until they are final
Show answer
Answer: C. Behind the veil, people do not know their class, talents or beliefs, so they cannot bias the principles in their own favour.
-
4. According to Rawls's difference principle, economic inequalities are acceptable only if:
- They result from free and fair markets alone
- The majority votes for them in a fair election
- They reward the most talented and hardworking people
- They benefit the least advantaged members of society
Show answer
Answer: D. The difference principle permits inequalities only when they work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged.
-
5. The idea that government is legitimate only with the consent of the governed and must protect life, liberty and property is most associated with:
- Confucius
- John Locke
- Jeremy Bentham
- Plato
Show answer
Answer: B. Locke grounded government in consent and the protection of natural rights to life, liberty and property, and allowed resistance to tyranny.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.