- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Liberty, consent and fairness: Mill, the social contract and Rawls in policy cases
Apply Mill's harm principle, social contract ideas and Rawls's veil of ignorance and difference principle to policy decisions on bans, emergencies and distribution of public resources.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on public policy often ask whether a restriction on citizens is justified, or whether a distribution of resources is fair. Three tools from the world thinkers do most of the work: Mill's harm principle for limits on liberty, the social contract for the basis and limits of state power, and Rawls's theory for fairness in distribution. This lesson applies each to cases, and shows how to choose the right tool.
Choosing the tool
| Question in the case | Best tool | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| May the state restrict this person's conduct? | Mill's harm principle | Does the conduct harm others, or mainly the person themselves? |
| Why must citizens obey, and when may the state's power be questioned? | Social contract (Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau) | Does the action keep the terms on which authority was granted? |
| Is this distribution of benefits or burdens fair? | Rawls | Would people behind a veil of ignorance accept it? Does any inequality help the least advantaged? |
Mill's harm principle: finer points
Mill accepted interference to prevent harm to others, and he did not object to advising, persuading or warning a person about risks to themselves. In On Liberty he gives the example of someone about to step onto a bridge known to be unsafe: if there is no time to warn him, he may be held back, because he does not actually want to fall into the river; but where there is only a risk, he should be warned, not forced. Mill also held that the principle applies to adults in full possession of their faculties, not to children.
Worked example 1: a ban on a self-harming habit versus a public nuisance
A municipal body proposes two rules: banning adults from consuming a legal but unhealthy snack, and banning the burning of garbage in residential lanes. Step 1: classify the conduct. The snack mainly affects the eater; burning garbage spreads smoke that harms neighbours. Step 2: apply the harm principle. Coercion is justified for burning garbage; it is not justified merely to protect adults from their own diet. Step 3: identify what Mill would allow for the snack: health warnings, information campaigns and advice. Step 4: in an exam answer, add that a utilitarian might weigh public health costs, but Mill's specific principle limits coercion to harm to others.
Worked example 2: allocating a new health centre
A district can build one primary health centre: in a well-off town that already has two private hospitals, or in a cluster of tribal villages two hours from any clinic. Step 1: choose the tool: this is a distribution question, so use Rawls. Step 2: apply the veil of ignorance: not knowing whether you will be a town resident or a tribal villager, you would choose to secure basic health access for whoever is worst off. Step 3: apply the difference principle: an unequal investment in the villages is justified because it benefits the least advantaged. Step 4: note that a utilitarian count of lives saved per rupee might well agree, giving the answer extra strength.
Worked example 3: a curfew during riots
After communal violence, the administration imposes a 48-hour curfew. Step 1: the question is about the basis and limits of state power, so use social contract ideas. Step 2: Hobbes would see protecting life and order as the core reason the state exists, supporting the curfew. Step 3: Locke would agree that protecting life is the state's purpose, but would insist that power remain limited, temporary and answerable: once the danger passes, the curfew must be lifted, and abuses must be checked. Step 4: a balanced answer supports the curfew while stressing proportionality and time limits.
Restricting a person? Ask Mill: harm to others or only to self. Questioning state power? Ask the social contract: is power used for the purpose it was granted, within limits? Dividing resources? Ask Rawls: would you accept it not knowing your place, and does it help the worst off?
Key takeaways: match the question type to the thinker; Mill allows warning about self-regarding risks but coercion only for harm to others; Hobbes stresses order and Locke stresses limits; Rawls favours arrangements that help the least advantaged.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under Mill's harm principle, which rule is most clearly justified?
- Fining adults who do not read newspapers every day
- Banning adults from eating spicy food at public places
- Requiring adults to sleep for eight hours each night
- Prohibiting the dumping of chemical waste into a village pond
Show answer
Answer: D. Dumping waste harms others' health and water, so coercion is justified. The other rules restrict self-regarding conduct.
-
2. In Mill's unsafe-bridge example, why may a person be held back when there is no time to warn him?
- Because the state owns the bridge and may stop anyone who uses it, whatever he intends
- Because he does not actually want to fall into the river, so stopping him does not violate his liberty
- Because the majority wishes it and the person's own liberty must give way to their view
- Because his life belongs to the community and so may be saved without regard to his wishes
Show answer
Answer: B. Mill argues that liberty means doing what one wants; the person does not want to fall, so holding him back briefly respects rather than violates his liberty. Where there is only risk, he should be warned.
-
3. A district must choose between upgrading a stadium used by an affluent club and building a school in a slum. Which thinker's reasoning most directly favours the school because it benefits the least advantaged?
- John Rawls
- Thomas Hobbes
- Jeremy Bentham's hedonic calculus only
- Confucius
Show answer
Answer: A. Rawls's difference principle permits unequal treatment that works to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged.
-
4. A thinker who would support an emergency curfew but insist it be limited, temporary and accountable is best represented by:
- Hobbes alone, who favoured near-absolute power
- Confucius, who rejected laws
- John Locke
- Bentham's Panopticon
Show answer
Answer: C. Locke accepts that the state exists to protect life and rights but insists its power be limited and answerable to the people.
-
5. Which question signals that Rawls is the most suitable tool?
- May the state stop this person harming only himself?
- Is this division of public benefits fair to the worst off?
- Should this officer act from habit?
- Is this act a categorical imperative?
Show answer
Answer: B. Rawls's theory is designed for questions about the fair distribution of social goods, especially towards the least advantaged.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.