- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Spotting the thinker behind a statement: clue words and common confusions
Identify which world thinker a statement or scenario reflects in seconds, using clue words, and avoid the confusions that cost marks: Bentham or Mill, Kant or rule utilitarian, Plato or Aristotle.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many objective questions on moral thinkers do not name the thinker. They give a statement or a short scenario and ask whose idea it reflects. The Foundation course explained each thinker; this lesson turns that knowledge into a fast, reliable identification method and drills the pairs that candidates most often mix up.
The clue-word method
Read the statement and underline the word that carries the moral weight: is the act right because of its results, because of a duty or principle, because of the character it expresses, or because of a fair agreement? That one decision narrows the field to a family of theories. Then use the clue words below to pick the individual thinker.
| Clue in the statement | Family | Most likely thinker |
|---|---|---|
| Greatest happiness, counting pleasures, intensity, duration, extent | Consequentialist | Bentham |
| Higher and lower pleasures, quality of happiness, harm to others | Consequentialist | Mill |
| Duty for duty's sake, universal law, never merely a means | Deontological | Kant |
| Habit, character, mean between extremes, flourishing | Virtue ethics | Aristotle |
| Knowledge of the Good, harmony of the soul, philosopher-ruler | Virtue and knowledge | Plato (or Socrates for 'virtue is knowledge') |
| Humaneness, ritual propriety, filial piety, ruling by example | Relational virtue | Confucius |
| Strong sovereign to escape a war of all against all | Social contract | Hobbes |
| Consent, natural rights to life, liberty and property | Social contract | Locke |
| General will, common good | Social contract | Rousseau |
| Veil of ignorance, least advantaged, fairness | Contractarian justice | Rawls |
Four confusions that cost marks
- Bentham or Mill? Both say 'greatest happiness'. If the statement talks about the quality of pleasures, or about liberty and harm to others, it is Mill. If it treats all pleasures as the same stuff to be measured, it is Bentham.
- Kant or rule utilitarianism? Both may say 'follow the rule even when breaking it seems to pay'. Ask why. If the reason is that the rule generally produces the best results, it is rule utilitarianism. If the reason is that the rule is a duty binding on every rational being regardless of results, it is Kant.
- Plato or Aristotle? Both are virtue thinkers. Plato stresses knowledge of an ideal Good, a three-part soul and rule by philosophers. Aristotle stresses habit, the mean relative to the situation and practical wisdom in particular cases.
- Locke or Hobbes? Both use a social contract. If the government's power is limited and people may resist a ruler who violates their rights, it is Locke. If the sovereign must be strong and nearly absolute to prevent chaos, it is Hobbes.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'A public servant should not keep a promise to a contractor merely because keeping promises usually leads to good outcomes; he should keep it because breaking promises cannot be made a rule for everyone.' Step 1: the moral weight is on a principle, not on outcomes; the first half explicitly rejects outcome-based reasoning. Step 2: 'cannot be made a rule for everyone' is the universalisability test. Step 3: so this is Kant, not rule utilitarianism, even though both would keep the promise. Answer: Kant.
Worked example 2
Statement: 'A good officer is not born; she becomes good by repeatedly acting fairly until fairness becomes second nature, and she learns to judge each case on its merits.' Step 1: the weight is on character, so this is virtue ethics. Step 2: 'repeatedly acting' points to habituation, and 'judge each case on its merits' points to practical wisdom. Step 3: these are Aristotle's ideas rather than Plato's, because nothing is said about an ideal Good or the soul's three parts. Answer: Aristotle.
First ask what makes the act right: results, duty, character or fair agreement. Then use the clue words to pick the thinker, and check the commonly confused pairs before you answer.
Key takeaways: classify the family first; use clue words; watch the Bentham-Mill, Kant-rule utilitarian, Plato-Aristotle and Hobbes-Locke pairs; the reason given for an act matters more than the act itself.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Poetry and a simple game are equally good if they give equal pleasure.' This view reflects:
- John Stuart Mill
- Jeremy Bentham
- Aristotle
- Confucius
Show answer
Answer: B. Treating all pleasures as differing only in amount is Bentham's quantitative hedonism. Mill would rank the intellectual pleasure of poetry higher in quality.
-
2. 'Rulers must be those who have grasped the true Good through long philosophical training.' This idea belongs to:
- Aristotle
- John Locke
- Plato
- Bentham
Show answer
Answer: C. Rule by those who know the Good, the philosopher-kings, is Plato's idea from the Republic.
-
3. An officer refuses to backdate a document. She says that if every officer backdated documents when convenient, official records would become meaningless. Her reasoning is closest to:
- Kant's universal law test
- Mill's harm principle
- Aristotle's golden mean
- Hobbes' state of nature
Show answer
Answer: A. Asking what would happen if the principle were followed by everyone, and finding that it defeats itself, is Kant's formula of universal law.
-
4. 'People may rightly resist a government that violates their natural rights, because its power rests on their consent.' This view belongs to:
- Thomas Hobbes
- Confucius
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- John Locke
Show answer
Answer: D. Locke grounded government in consent and the protection of natural rights and accepted a right to resist tyranny. Hobbes favoured a strong, nearly absolute sovereign.
-
5. A planner says: 'We follow the rule of open tendering even when a direct award would be faster this time, because the open-tender rule produces the best results overall.' This reasoning is:
- Kantian, because it follows a rule regardless of results
- Rule utilitarian, because the rule is justified by its overall results
- Aristotelian, because it finds a mean between two vices
- Hobbesian, because it relies on an absolute sovereign
Show answer
Answer: B. The rule is justified by its general consequences, which is rule utilitarianism. Kant would justify a rule by duty and universalisability, not by results.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.