Revision notes

Moral Thinkers of the World: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Spotting the thinker behind a statement: clue words and common confusions

Clue words and the thinkers they point to
Clue in the statementFamilyMost likely thinker
Greatest happiness, counting pleasures, intensity, duration, extentConsequentialistBentham
Higher and lower pleasures, quality of happiness, harm to othersConsequentialistMill
Duty for duty's sake, universal law, never merely a meansDeontologicalKant
Habit, character, mean between extremes, flourishingVirtue ethicsAristotle
Knowledge of the Good, harmony of the soul, philosopher-rulerVirtue and knowledgePlato (or Socrates for 'virtue is knowledge')
Humaneness, ritual propriety, filial piety, ruling by exampleRelational virtueConfucius
Strong sovereign to escape a war of all against allSocial contractHobbes
Consent, natural rights to life, liberty and propertySocial contractLocke
General will, common goodSocial contractRousseau
Veil of ignorance, least advantaged, fairnessContractarian justiceRawls

First ask what makes the act right: results, duty, character or fair agreement. Then use the clue words to pick the thinker, and check the commonly confused pairs before you answer.

Key takeaways: classify the family first; use clue words; watch the Bentham-Mill, Kant-rule utilitarian, Plato-Aristotle and Hobbes-Locke pairs; the reason given for an act matters more than the act itself.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Kant versus the utilitarians in administrative case studies

Run both lenses. Count all consequences, including long-term trust. Test the principle for universality and for using people merely as means. Agreement makes an answer strong; disagreement must be named and justified.

Key takeaways: a careful utilitarian counts hidden, long-term harms; Kant tests principles, not just acts; the two often agree on honesty and fair rules; they part ways when a larger total needs an individual to be wronged.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Aristotle's mean and practical wisdom in a public servant's decisions

Applying the mean to public service (an illustrative extension of Aristotle's method)
AreaDeficiencyMeanExcess
Enforcing rulesLaxity: letting everything passFirmness with fairnessHarshness: punishing without regard to circumstances
Sharing informationSecrecy beyond what law requiresTransparency with due care for privacy and securityCareless disclosure of sensitive personal data
Self-assuranceTimidity: avoiding all decisionsConfidenceArrogance: refusing advice
Responding to grievancesIndifferenceEmpathy with objectivityPartiality: helping whoever moves you most

To find the mean: name the virtue, name both extremes, choose the response that is right for this situation. The mean is not halfway, and some acts have no mean at all.

Key takeaways: exam options are often two vices and a virtue; the mean depends on circumstances and may lie near one end; bribery and falsification have no mean; practical wisdom chooses timing and method; institutions build virtue through habit.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Liberty, consent and fairness: Mill, the social contract and Rawls in policy cases

Matching the question to the thinker
Question in the caseBest toolWhat to ask
May the state restrict this person's conduct?Mill's harm principleDoes the conduct harm others, or mainly the person themselves?
Why must citizens obey, and when may the state's power be questioned?Social contract (Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau)Does the action keep the terms on which authority was granted?
Is this distribution of benefits or burdens fair?RawlsWould people behind a veil of ignorance accept it? Does any inequality help the least advantaged?

Restricting a person? Ask Mill: harm to others or only to self. Questioning state power? Ask the social contract: is power used for the purpose it was granted, within limits? Dividing resources? Ask Rawls: would you accept it not knowing your place, and does it help the worst off?

Key takeaways: match the question type to the thinker; Mill allows warning about self-regarding risks but coercion only for harm to others; Hobbes stresses order and Locke stresses limits; Rawls favours arrangements that help the least advantaged.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Leading by example and telling hard truths: Confucius and Plato applied to office

Confucius: make conduct match the title, and lead by your own example before you lead by circulars. Plato: the one who sees more must return and explain, persuading honestly rather than imposing.

Key takeaways: rectification of names diagnoses gaps between role and conduct; rule by example changes office culture; the cave allegory supports patient truth-telling; philosopher-ruler ideas support expertise but need accountability; reject the noble lie in modern administration.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery