• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Applying the right to information: hard requests

Decide realistic RTI requests involving personal information, third parties, security and public interest, and explain the reasoning a Public Information Officer should follow.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Foundation course outlined how the Right to Information Act, 2005 works. In practice, the difficult part is deciding requests that touch on privacy, third parties or sensitive matters. Exam questions often place you in the chair of a Public Information Officer (PIO) and ask what you would do.

A decision path for the PIO

  1. Is the information held by my public authority? If held by another, transfer the request to it as the Act provides.
  2. Does an exemption apply? For example, harm to security or sovereignty, information whose disclosure would endanger someone's life or safety, or personal information that has no relation to any public activity or interest.
  3. Does it concern a third party who treated it as confidential? If so, give that party notice and a chance to object before deciding.
  4. Does the public interest outweigh the harm? The Act allows disclosure of some exempt information where the public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to protected interests.
  5. Can part be disclosed? Sever the exempt part and give the rest.
  6. Give reasons for any refusal and tell the applicant how to appeal.

Case 1: an officer's leave records

An applicant asks for the medical reasons behind a colleague's leave. Analysis: medical details are personal and usually unrelated to public activity, so disclosure would be an unwarranted invasion of privacy. But the dates of leave and whether it was sanctioned under the rules relate to public duty. Decision: refuse the medical details, give the leave dates and sanction orders, and state the reasons.

Case 2: a contractor's bid

A losing bidder asks for the winning bidder's technical and price bid. Analysis: after the contract is awarded, the price and the evaluation of bids relate directly to the use of public money. Some technical details may be commercially confidential, so the third party should be given notice. Decision: after hearing the winner, disclose the price, the evaluation sheet and the reasons for award; withhold genuine trade secrets if their disclosure would harm the firm's competitive position and no larger public interest requires them.

Case 3: an unsafe bridge report

A journalist asks for an engineering report that rates a busy bridge as unsafe. The department fears embarrassment. Analysis: embarrassment is not an exemption; public safety is a strong public interest. Decision: disclose. Withholding it would put lives at risk and violate both the letter and the spirit of the Act.

Case 4: a frivolous flood of requests

One person files dozens of requests each month to the same office, asking for vast amounts of old records. Analysis: the right belongs to every citizen, and the PIO cannot refuse simply because of the applicant's motive. However, the Act permits supplying information in a form that does not disproportionately divert the authority's resources; the PIO can offer inspection of files instead of copying everything. Decision: respond within time, offer inspection, and improve proactive disclosure so that common information is already public.

Disclose by default; refuse only under a stated exemption; hear third parties; weigh the public interest; sever and release what you can; always give reasons and the appeal route.

Key takeaways

  • Embarrassment is never a ground to refuse.
  • Personal information unrelated to public activity is protected, but official acts are not.
  • Third parties get notice before confidential information about them is released.
  • Partial disclosure and inspection are useful middle paths.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A department wants to withhold a report because it shows officials in a poor light. The PIO should:

    1. Withhold it to protect the department's image
    2. Disclose it, since embarrassment is not an exemption
    3. Destroy it
    4. Ask the applicant why he wants it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Embarrassment is not a ground for refusal; applicants also need not give reasons.

  2. 2. Before releasing information supplied in confidence by a private firm, the PIO should:

    1. Release it immediately, since the Act favours disclosure
    2. Refuse automatically, because it was supplied in confidence
    3. Give the firm notice and an opportunity to object, then decide
    4. Ask the minister whether the information should be given
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The third-party procedure requires notice and a chance to make a representation before deciding.

  3. 3. An applicant asks for a colleague's medical reasons for leave. The best response is to:

    1. Give the dates and sanction orders but withhold the medical details, with reasons
    2. Release everything, including the medical details and the medical certificates
    3. Refuse everything without reasons, since leave records are personal
    4. Forward the request to the colleague's family and let them decide
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Medical details are personal; leave dates and sanctions relate to public duty. Partial disclosure with reasons is correct.

  4. 4. Information that would otherwise be exempt may still be released when:

    1. The applicant agrees to pay a much higher fee for the information
    2. The PIO personally likes the applicant and trusts his purpose well
    3. The department is certain it will not be embarrassed by the release
    4. The public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to protected interests
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Act allows disclosure where public interest outweighs harm to protected interests, in the cases it specifies.

  5. 5. A person repeatedly files huge requests. A lawful, balanced response is to:

    1. Ban the applicant from filing any further requests for a full year
    2. Reply in time, offer inspection of files and improve proactive disclosure
    3. Ignore the requests because they are too large to be answered
    4. Charge a penalty fee for each page of such an oversized request
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The right cannot be denied for motive, but inspection and proactive disclosure reduce the burden lawfully.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery