- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Exam drill: probity questions and common traps
Practise elimination on probity MCQs, avoid the most frequent mistakes in short answers, and use a compact structure for case-based questions on transparency and corruption.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson turns the course into exam technique. It lists the traps examiners set in probity questions, shows how to eliminate options quickly, and gives a compact structure for case-based answers.
Seven traps
| Trap | Correct position |
|---|---|
| 'Legal, therefore ethical' | Probity asks for fairness of process, not just legality |
| 'Embarrassing, therefore secret' | Embarrassment is not an RTI exemption |
| 'Relative applied, so ask them to withdraw' | Declare and recuse; others judge fairly |
| 'Bribe refused, so reject the file' | Decide the file on merits |
| 'Go to the media first' | Use competent authorities; media is a last resort |
| 'Charter displayed, so service is good' | Charter needs grievance redress and capability |
| 'More punishment solves corruption' | Combine reduced discretion, transparency, enforcement and culture |
Worked example 1: elimination
Question: 'A PIO receives a request for an internal audit report that criticises his department's handling of funds. What should he do? (a) Refuse, citing damage to the department's reputation; (b) Forward it to the head of department for a decision on whether to reply; (c) Examine whether any exemption applies, disclose the report with any genuinely exempt part severed, and give reasons; (d) Ask the applicant to explain the purpose.' Remove (a): reputation is not an exemption. Remove (d): applicants need not give reasons. (b) passes responsibility away; the PIO must decide. Answer: (c).
Structure for a case-based probity answer
- Facts and stakeholders: one or two lines.
- Probity issues: name them precisely (conflict of interest, transparency, misuse of funds, coercive corruption).
- Options: two or three realistic options with their merits and demerits.
- Course of action: immediate steps and system fixes, in order.
- Conclusion: one line on the value protected.
Worked example 2: a short case answer
Case: 'As block officer, you learn that the list of beneficiaries for a housing scheme includes people who already own houses, added at the instance of a local leader.' Facts and stakeholders: genuine poor applicants, the ineligible beneficiaries, the local leader, the department, the public purse. Issues: misuse of public funds, favouritism, lack of transparency. Options: (i) ignore, which harms the eligible poor; (ii) remove names quietly, which corrects the list but leaves the cause; (iii) verify all names in an open gram sabha, remove ineligible ones with recorded reasons, inform the district authority of the pressure, and publish the final list. Course: option (iii), plus a rule that all future lists are verified publicly. Conclusion: probity requires that welfare reaches those it is meant for, through an open process.
Name the probity issue precisely, offer realistic options, and end with both an immediate step and a system fix.
Key takeaways
- Learn the seven traps; most wrong MCQ options use them.
- PIOs decide and give reasons; they do not pass requests upward or demand motives.
- Case answers should combine an immediate correction with a system fix.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is a valid reason for a PIO to refuse information?
- The information embarrasses the department or its officers
- The applicant will not say why he wants the information
- A specific exemption in the Act applies, with reasons given
- The head of department prefers secrecy on the subject
Show answer
Answer: C. Only a stated exemption, with reasons, justifies refusal; embarrassment and motive are not grounds.
-
2. The statement 'it was legal, so there is no probity issue' is:
- A trap, because probity also requires a fair and open process
- Always correct, because legality is the only test of probity
- Correct only for contracts and purchases, not for other decisions
- Correct only for RTI requests and not for other decisions
Show answer
Answer: A. Probity looks beyond legality to fairness, openness and absence of private interest.
-
3. In a housing case with ineligible beneficiaries added under pressure, the strongest course is to:
- Ignore it to keep peace with the local leaders who recommended the names, and move on
- Remove the names quietly, without any notice, reasons or report about the pressure
- Add more names to balance it, so that no eligible family feels left out of the list
- Verify publicly, remove ineligible names with reasons, report the pressure and publish the final list
Show answer
Answer: D. This corrects the list, addresses the cause and builds transparency for the future.
-
4. The weakest claim about controlling corruption is:
- Reducing discretion helps in practice
- More punishment alone will solve it
- Transparency helps to expose misuse
- Culture matters for lasting change
Show answer
Answer: B. Punishment alone is insufficient; discretion, transparency, enforcement and culture must work together.
-
5. A case-based probity answer should end with:
- A long quotation from a thinker or a committee report
- A list of all the laws in India that relate to the case
- An immediate step and a system fix, then a one-line conclusion
- An apology to the people affected by the lapse in the office
Show answer
Answer: C. Combining immediate correction with prevention shows practical judgement.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.