Revision notes

Probity in Governance: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Applying the right to information: hard requests

Disclose by default; refuse only under a stated exemption; hear third parties; weigh the public interest; sever and release what you can; always give reasons and the appeal route.

  • Embarrassment is never a ground to refuse.
  • Personal information unrelated to public activity is protected, but official acts are not.
  • Third parties get notice before confidential information about them is released.
  • Partial disclosure and inspection are useful middle paths.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Service delivery cases: charters and grievance redress

QuestionIf the answer is no
Are standards specific (for example, days to issue)?Rewrite vague promises into measurable ones
Were users and staff consulted when setting them?Reset standards to realistic levels
Is there a named officer and time limit for complaints?Create one and publicise it
Is performance measured and published?Track and display monthly compliance
Do staff, space and systems match the promise?Fix capacity before raising standards

A charter is a promise; grievance redress is the guarantee; capability is the means. Sevottam needs all three.

  • Sevottam's three components: charter, grievance redress, service delivery capability.
  • Agents flourish where capacity is short and discretion over access is high.
  • Grievance channels need registration, acknowledgement, time limits and review.
  • Honest, achievable standards build more trust than impressive ones.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Public funds, gifts and conflicts of interest

TypeMeaningExample
ActualA private interest is in fact influencing a decisionApproving a bill from a firm in which one holds shares
Apparent (perceived)A reasonable person could think it mightJudging a contest in which a close friend competes
PotentialA private interest could conflict in futureA spouse taking a job with a firm that often deals with one's department

Would it survive the front page, would a fair observer doubt my judgement, and is it the best use of public money? If in doubt, declare and step aside.

  • Apparent conflicts damage trust as much as actual ones.
  • Declare and recuse; do not deny relatives' firms a fair chance judged by others.
  • Year-end spending of unneeded items fails the value-for-money test.
  • Never accept gifts from those whose matters are pending.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Corruption cases: speed money, pressure and whistleblowing

Question before blowing the whistleWhy it matters
Is the wrongdoing serious and is my evidence reliable?Unfounded allegations harm innocent people and your credibility
Have internal channels been tried or are they compromised?Internal correction is faster when it works
Which competent authority can act?Disclose to those empowered to investigate, not first to the public
Am I acting in good faith, for the public interest?Motive affects credibility and legal protection
Have I protected the evidence and recorded everything?Records support the case and protect you

Refuse clearly, record carefully, report to the competent authority, and keep treating the file on merits. Fix the system as well as the person.

  • Entrenched corruption needs system fixes plus credible enforcement.
  • Refusing a bribe should be explicit, recorded and reported.
  • Refusal must not turn into victimisation of the person's file.
  • Whistleblowing should go to a competent authority with reliable evidence, in good faith.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Exam drill: probity questions and common traps

TrapCorrect position
'Legal, therefore ethical'Probity asks for fairness of process, not just legality
'Embarrassing, therefore secret'Embarrassment is not an RTI exemption
'Relative applied, so ask them to withdraw'Declare and recuse; others judge fairly
'Bribe refused, so reject the file'Decide the file on merits
'Go to the media first'Use competent authorities; media is a last resort
'Charter displayed, so service is good'Charter needs grievance redress and capability
'More punishment solves corruption'Combine reduced discretion, transparency, enforcement and culture

Name the probity issue precisely, offer realistic options, and end with both an immediate step and a system fix.

  • Learn the seven traps; most wrong MCQ options use them.
  • PIOs decide and give reasons; they do not pass requests upward or demand motives.
  • Case answers should combine an immediate correction with a system fix.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery