• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Case studies: the counter, the clinic and the police station

Work through three petty-corruption case studies end to end, identifying stakeholders, options and a justified course of action that combines immediate steps with system reform.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Petty corruption is where most citizens meet the state. Case studies here test whether you can act decisively but fairly, protect the vulnerable, and fix the system rather than just punish one person. Each case below follows the same structure: facts, stakeholders, options, chosen course, reform.

Case 1: the ration shop

You are a newly posted district supply officer. Card-holders complain that the fair-price shop dealer weighs grain short and claims stock is exhausted by the tenth of each month. Stakeholders: poor card-holders, the dealer, inspectors, the department. Options: (a) cancel the dealer's licence at once on the basis of complaints; (b) issue a warning; (c) verify quickly through a surprise inspection with weighing and stock check, record findings, then act according to rules. Chosen course: (c), followed by suspension of the licence if the shortfall is proved, with interim arrangements so card-holders still get grain. Reform: electronic weighing linked to point-of-sale devices, public display of stock, vigilance committees of beneficiaries, and a complaint number on every shop wall. Why not (a)? It skips proof and may leave beneficiaries without a shop.

Case 2: the primary health centre

A doctor at a primary health centre routinely tells patients that the free medicines are unavailable and that they should buy them from a particular chemist. Stakeholders: patients, especially the poor; the doctor; the chemist; the health department. Analysis: this is possibly collusive between doctor and chemist, but coercive towards patients. Chosen course as block medical officer: check stock records against what patients are told, take statements from patients, issue medicines from stock immediately, and refer the doctor for inquiry if the pattern is confirmed. Reform: daily display of available free medicines, prescription audits, an essential drugs list on the wall, and patient feedback by phone.

Case 3: the FIR that will not be registered

A woman labourer reports that her employer has withheld wages and threatened her. The station house officer refuses to register her complaint unless 'something is arranged'. You are the superintendent of police and learn of this. Analysis: refusal to register a complaint of a cognisable offence is a serious failure, and a demand for money compounds it. Chosen course: ensure her complaint is registered and acted on immediately, protect her from the employer, order an inquiry into the officer's conduct, and take disciplinary action if proved. Reform: online and women help-desk registration, CCTV in police stations, periodic checks of complaints against records, and a clear message that refusing to register complaints will be treated as misconduct.

What examiners look for

  • Immediate relief for the victim comes first.
  • Verification before punishment: due process for the accused.
  • Action proportionate to proven facts.
  • A system reform that would prevent a repeat.
  • Attention to the most vulnerable stakeholder.

Relieve the victim, verify the facts, act on proof, and reform the system so the next citizen never has to complain.

Key takeaways

  • Use the same structure for every case: facts, stakeholders, options, choice, reform.
  • Protect beneficiaries during action against a corrupt provider.
  • Combine individual accountability with system redesign.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the ration shop case, why is immediate cancellation of the licence on complaints alone rejected?

    1. Because dealers cannot be punished in any manner for such lapses
    2. Because it skips verification and may leave card-holders without a shop
    3. Because complaints are always false when a dealer is a local person
    4. Because the dealer is a voter and the area has local elections
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Action must rest on proved facts, and beneficiaries must not lose access to grain while the case is handled.

  2. 2. A doctor sends patients to one chemist while free medicines are in stock. Towards the patients, this corruption is mainly:

    1. coercive
    2. lawful
    3. a gift
    4. a trusteeship
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Patients are entitled to free medicines and are forced to pay. Between the doctor and the chemist there may be collusion, but towards patients it is coercive.

  3. 3. Which reform best prevents the ration shop problem from recurring?

    1. A strongly worded letter to all dealers warning them against misconduct
    2. Closing all the fair-price shops in the district for a full year
    3. Electronic weighing linked to point-of-sale devices and public display of stock
    4. Increasing the dealer's commission only, with no change in the system
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Electronic weighing and public stock data remove the dealer's room to short-weigh or fake shortages.

  4. 4. As superintendent of police, what is your first priority when a labourer's complaint has not been registered?

    1. Suspend all station staff without inquiry into their conduct
    2. Wait for her to complain again before taking any step
    3. Ask the employer for his side first before registering anything
    4. Ensure her complaint is registered and acted on, and protect her
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Immediate relief and protection for the victim come first; inquiry into the officer follows.

  5. 5. Which of these is NOT one of the things examiners look for in corruption case answers?

    1. Immediate relief for the victim of the extortion
    2. Verification of the facts before any punishment
    3. A system reform to prevent repeats of the lapse
    4. Punishment of the accused before any facts are verified
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Due process requires verification. Punishment before verification is unfair and may be overturned.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery