- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Diagnosing a department with Klitgaard's formula
Score an office on monopoly, discretion and accountability, predict where corruption will arise, and propose a matched set of reforms for each lever.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exam case studies often describe a corrupt office and ask what you would do as its new head. A strong answer diagnoses before it prescribes. Klitgaard's formula, corruption equals monopoly plus discretion minus accountability, turns diagnosis into a clear, repeatable exercise.
Step 1: score each lever
| Lever | High-risk signs | Low-risk signs |
|---|---|---|
| Monopoly | Only one counter or officer; no alternative; urgent need | Several offices or online channels; citizen can choose |
| Discretion | Vague criteria; no reasons recorded; officer controls timing and inspections | Published criteria; automatic or rule-based decisions; random allocation of files |
| Accountability | No time limits; no audit; no complaint system; no data published | Time limits; tracking; audit trails; appeals; public dashboards; social audit |
Step 2: match remedies to levers
- Reduce monopoly: multiple service points, online and common service centres, competition among providers where possible.
- Structure discretion: clear criteria, checklists, random allocation of files and inspections, recorded reasons, joint decisions for high-value matters.
- Raise accountability: time limits with automatic escalation, tracking numbers, audit trails, appeals, proactive disclosure, social audit, and visible penalties.
Worked example 1: the sub-registrar's office
Facts: property registration happens only at one office per area; the valuation of property for stamp duty is left to the sub-registrar's judgement; documents can be 'held' without reason; middlemen crowd the gate. Scores: monopoly high, discretion high, accountability low. Remedies: publish area-wise guidance values so valuation becomes rule-based; online appointment and document submission so middlemen lose their role; time limit for registration with automatic escalation; CCTV and a published list of documents required; random audits of valuations far from guidance values. Expected effect: the main lever, valuation discretion, is narrowed, and the gatekeepers lose their monopoly over access.
Worked example 2: the hospital store
Facts: medicines are bought by one store officer, stock records are on paper, patients are often told medicines are 'out of stock' and sent to a private chemist nearby. Scores: monopoly moderate, discretion high over stock and issue, accountability very low. Remedies: computerised stock with daily public display of availability, periodic physical verification by a different team, prescription audits, a toll-free number to report 'out of stock' refusals, and rotation of the store officer. Note that the chemist link suggests possible collusion; data comparing stock-outs with the chemist's sales could reveal it.
Worked example 3: a quick score sheet
For a building-plan approval office, write one line per lever. Monopoly: high, because only the municipal office can approve plans. Discretion: high, because site inspections are scheduled at the inspector's choice and objections can be raised in instalments. Accountability: low, because there is no deadline and no list of objections given at one time. Prescription in one line each: self-certification by licensed architects for small houses (monopoly), a single consolidated list of objections and randomly assigned inspections (discretion), a deemed-approval deadline with an online status page (accountability). Writing the score sheet first keeps your answer focused and saves time.
Step 3: check side effects
Every remedy can create new problems. Online systems can exclude people without internet access, so assisted counters are needed. Strict time limits can push officers to reject files to avoid delay penalties, so rejections must also be reasoned and appealable. Good answers name one likely side effect and how to manage it.
Diagnose each lever, match a remedy to it, and check the side effect before you finish.
Key takeaways
- Score monopoly, discretion and accountability before proposing reforms.
- Match remedies to levers instead of listing generic measures.
- Anticipate side effects such as digital exclusion or defensive rejections.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the sub-registrar case, which remedy most directly narrows discretion?
- Publishing area-wise guidance values for property valuation
- Painting the office and improving the visitors' area
- Hiring more middlemen to help citizens with the paperwork
- Removing CCTV from the registration hall of the office
Show answer
Answer: A. The officer's freedom to value property was the main lever for bribes. Published guidance values make valuation rule-based.
-
2. Random allocation of files among officers mainly reduces corruption by:
- increasing monopoly by letting one officer handle all files in a section
- removing accountability by hiding who is dealing with each file
- preventing applicants and officers from choosing each other in advance
- making files slower, so that applicants lose interest in the process
Show answer
Answer: C. If an applicant cannot pick the officer, prior arrangements and collusion become harder.
-
3. Which is a likely side effect of strict time limits with penalties for delay?
- Files will always be decided on merit and in good time
- Officers may reject files hastily to avoid delay penalties
- Monopoly will increase in every office that sets limits
- Corruption will rise in every case where time limits are set
Show answer
Answer: B. Penalties for delay can push officers to reject rather than decide properly. Requiring reasoned rejections and appeals manages this.
-
4. In the hospital store case, which measure raises accountability?
- Letting the store officer decide alone what to issue, without any record being kept
- Keeping stock records on paper only, in registers that only the store officer may see
- Sending patients to a private chemist whenever the medicine is not immediately in stock
- Daily public display of medicine availability and periodic physical verification by another team
Show answer
Answer: D. Public data and independent checks make the store officer's decisions visible and reviewable.
-
5. Why should online service reforms usually include assisted counters?
- To create a new monopoly for the agents who run the counters
- To avoid excluding people who lack internet access or digital skills
- Because online systems are illegal without a physical counter
- To increase discretion for the officers who process the forms
Show answer
Answer: B. Digital-only systems can exclude the poor and elderly. Assisted counters keep the reform inclusive.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.