| Feature | Coercive | Collusive |
|---|---|---|
| Citizen's position | Victim, entitled to the service | Partner, gaining something not due |
| Who loses | The citizen who pays | The public, the state, honest competitors |
| Will the payer complain? | Often yes, if a safe channel exists | Rarely; both sides gain |
| Best remedies | Time limits, online services, grievance systems, protection for complainants | Audits, data analysis, surprise checks, rotation, harsh penalties for both parties |
Entitled payer, coercive: make the service certain. Unentitled payer, collusive: make detection certain.
- Coercive: the citizen is a victim; collusive: the citizen is a partner.
- Remedies differ: certainty of service for coercive, certainty of detection for collusive.
- Use the four-question routine, and test grey areas with the post test and the publication test.