• Practice
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Industry and the environment: statement and assertion-reason practice

Practise judging statements about pollution, its causes and its control, and decide when a reason really explains an assertion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on industry and the environment are usually written as statements to judge. They look easy, but most of the marks are lost to absolute words and to reasons that sound right but do not explain the assertion. In this lesson you will meet the standard ideas once more as quick cards, then practise the judging method.

The cards

Pollution types, causes and controls
TypeTypical causeControl
AirSmoke and gases from chimneys, such as sulphur dioxideFilters, scrubbers, cleaner fuels
WaterUntreated factory waste and hot water into riversEffluent treatment plants, recycling
LandDumping of solid and chemical wasteSafe disposal, recycling
NoiseLoud machinesSilencers, ear protection, distance from homes
ThermalHot water released into riversCooling ponds before release

Acid rain forms when sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides from burning coal and oil dissolve in rain. A green belt of trees around a factory absorbs some dust and noise. Recycling and cleaner production reduce waste at the start.

Siting and planning

Harm can be reduced before a factory is built. Polluting industries are placed away from dense housing and from the sources of drinking water, and downwind of towns so that smoke blows away from people. An environmental impact assessment is a study carried out before a big project to predict its effects on air, water, land and people. The polluter pays idea says that the one who causes the pollution should bear the cost of controlling it. The 3 Rs, reduce, reuse and recycle, cut waste at its start.

The judging method

  1. Test each statement alone: true or false?
  2. Watch for absolute words: all, only, always, never.
  3. In assertion-reason items, check that R is the cause of A, not just a related fact.

Worked example 1: statements

Statements: (1) Acid rain is caused by sulphur dioxide from burning coal. (2) Thermal pollution is caused only by chemicals. (3) Green belts help to reduce dust and noise. Working: (1) true. (2) false: thermal pollution comes from hot water, and the word only is a warning. (3) true. Correct statements: 1 and 3.

Worked example 2: assertion-reason

First pair. A: Effluent treatment plants reduce river pollution. R: They remove harmful substances before the water enters the river. Working: A is true. R is true and describes how the plants work, so R explains A. Second pair. A: Cement works cause dust pollution. R: Aluminium smelting uses a great deal of electricity. Working: both statements are true, but the second says nothing about dust from cement works, so R does not explain A.

Worked example 3: a case

A town has a paper mill that releases coloured water into the river. Fish die downstream and villagers fall ill. Name the problem and two remedies. Working: this is water pollution. Remedies: build an effluent treatment plant at the mill, recycle water inside the mill, shift to cleaner processes, and have the mill's discharge checked by the authorities.

Worked example 4: a filter

A chimney would release 40 kg of dust a day. A filter removes 95 per cent. Dust released = 40 x (100 - 95) / 100 = 40 x 0.05 = 2 kg a day. The filter removes 40 - 2 = 38 kg a day. Over 30 days the dust kept out of the air is 38 x 30 = 1140 kg.

Traps

  • Mixing air and water pollution causes: sulphur dioxide is an air pollutant; hot water is thermal pollution.
  • Saying industry always harms the environment; modern controls reduce harm.
  • Assuming that a green belt removes all pollution; it only helps.

Test each statement alone. Beware only, always and never. R must explain A, not just be true.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Match each type of pollution to its cause and control.
  • Use the statement-by-statement method.
  • Look for cause and effect in assertion-reason questions.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Acid rain is caused mainly by:

    1. sulphur dioxide from burning coal
    2. hot water released into rivers
    3. noise from loud machines at work
    4. plastic waste dumped on land
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sulphur dioxide dissolves in rain to form a weak acid.

  2. 2. Which is a control measure for water pollution from a factory?

    1. Building taller chimneys only
    2. An effluent treatment plant
    3. Running louder machines
    4. Burning more coal and wood
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Treating effluent removes harmful substances before release.

  3. 3. Thermal pollution of a river is caused by:

    1. noise from loud machines in halls
    2. dust blown from cement works
    3. hot water released from industry
    4. plastic bags thrown in drains
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Hot water raises the temperature of the river and harms aquatic life.

  4. 4. Which statement is likely to be wrong because it uses an absolute word?

    1. Filters reduce air pollution
    2. Green belts reduce dust and noise
    3. Recycling reduces waste
    4. Pollution is caused only by chimneys
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Pollution has many sources (water, land, noise and so on), so the word only makes this statement wrong.

  5. 5. Silencers and distance from homes help to reduce:

    1. noise pollution
    2. acid rain
    3. thermal pollution
    4. land pollution
    Show answer

    Answer: A. They cut down the noise reaching people.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery