- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Location puzzles: transport cost, weight loss and weight gain
Decide the best site for an industry by comparing transport costs when material loses weight or product gains weight.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Location questions look like theory, but the best ones come with numbers. You are told how many tonnes of raw material make one tonne of product, how far apart the source and the market are, and what carrying costs per tonne-km. The answer is the site with the least total cost for carrying. This lesson shows the exact method, which takes less than a minute once you have practised. All rates and weights are illustrative.
The method
- Draw a line with the raw material source at one end and the market at the other.
- Write the weight that must travel on each stretch: the raw material before processing, the product after it.
- Compute cost = weight x distance x rate for the sites in question (usually source, market and perhaps the midpoint).
- Choose the site with the lowest total cost.
A rule that saves time
Compare the weight of the raw material with the weight of the product. If the raw material is heavier (weight-losing process), the plant belongs at the source, as carrying the product is cheaper than carrying the raw material. If the product is heavier (weight-gaining, as when water is added), the plant belongs at the market. If the two weights are equal, transport cost is the same for any site on the line, so other factors decide.
Worked example 1: weight-losing
A metal plant needs 4 tonnes of ore to make 1 tonne of metal. The mine and the market are 400 km apart and freight costs 2 rupees per tonne-km. Compare the cost at the mine, at the market and at the midpoint. Working: at the mine, only the metal travels: 1 x 400 x 2 = 800 rupees. At the market, the ore travels: 4 x 400 x 2 = 3200 rupees. At the midpoint (200 km from each end), the ore travels 200 km and the metal 200 km: 4 x 200 x 2 + 1 x 200 x 2 = 1600 + 400 = 2000 rupees. The mine is cheapest, and the plant should be there.
Worked example 2: weight-gaining
A bottling plant makes 3 tonnes of drink from 1 tonne of syrup plus water that is available everywhere. The syrup factory and the market are 400 km apart; freight is 2 rupees per tonne-km. At the syrup factory, the finished 3 tonnes travel: 3 x 400 x 2 = 2400 rupees. At the market, only 1 tonne of syrup travels: 1 x 400 x 2 = 800 rupees. The plant should be at the market, because the process adds weight.
Worked example 3: another site
Return to the metal plant, but now consider a site 100 km from the mine and 300 km from the market. The ore travels 100 km: 4 x 100 x 2 = 800. The metal travels 300 km: 1 x 300 x 2 = 600. Total = 1400 rupees, which is more than the 800 at the mine. The cost rises steadily as the site moves away from the mine, which confirms the rule.
Common traps
- Using the same weight on both stretches; the weight changes at the plant.
- Forgetting that some factors outweigh transport, such as power for aluminium or skilled labour for software.
- Calling a product weight-gaining when only value is added; weight must actually increase.
Heavier input: plant at the source. Heavier product: plant at the market. Equal weights: other factors decide. Cost = weight x distance x rate.
Key takeaways
- Compare input weight with output weight before calculating.
- Total cost = cost of carrying the input to the plant + cost of carrying the output to the market.
- Check the answer against the rule.
Check your understanding
-
1. A plant needs 5 tonnes of raw material for 1 tonne of product. It is best placed at the:
- raw material source area
- consumer market town
- exact midpoint of the route
- nearest port, always
Show answer
Answer: A. The input is heavier than the output, so carry the lighter product and place the plant at the source.
-
2. 1 tonne of syrup plus water gives 4 tonnes of drink. The best site is the:
- syrup factory
- midpoint
- market
- nearest hill
Show answer
Answer: C. The product is heavier than the input, so the plant belongs at the market.
-
3. A metal plant uses 3 tonnes of ore per tonne of metal. Distance 200 km, rate 1 rupee per tonne-km. Carrying the ore to a plant at the market costs:
- 200 rupees
- 1200 rupees
- 300 rupees
- 600 rupees
Show answer
Answer: D. 3 x 200 x 1 = 600 rupees.
-
4. With the same figures as the last question, carrying the metal from a plant at the mine to the market costs:
- 200 rupees
- 600 rupees
- 100 rupees
- 1000 rupees
Show answer
Answer: A. 1 x 200 x 1 = 200 rupees, so the mine is the cheaper site.
-
5. If the input and output weigh the same, transport cost is:
- higher at sites near the market
- lower at sites near the source
- the same at all sites on the line
- zero at every possible site
Show answer
Answer: C. With equal weights, the total tonne-km is the same wherever the plant stands, so other factors decide the site.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.