- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Executive traps: who appoints, who advises, who answers
Avoid the usual errors about the Governor, the Chief Minister and the ministers, including oath, resignation, discretion and the pardoning power.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the state executive are rarely hard, but they are full of small switches: appoints or elects, advises or decides, President or Governor. This lesson collects the facts that examiners switch most often.
By the end of this lesson you can:
- Match each office with who appoints it and to whom it answers.
- Recall the Governor's oath, resignation and pardoning power.
- Reject wrong options that swap the Governor, the President and the Chief Minister.
The chain of appointments
| Question | Correct answer | Common trap |
|---|---|---|
| Who appoints the Governor? | The President | The Prime Minister or the Chief Minister |
| Who appoints the Chief Minister? | The Governor | The Assembly votes for the CM directly |
| Who appoints ministers? | The Governor, on the CM's advice | The Governor alone |
| Who administers the Governor's oath? | The Chief Justice of the High Court | The President |
| To whom does the Governor resign? | The President | The Chief Minister |
| Who is collectively responsible to the Assembly? | The Council of Ministers | The Governor |
Discretion and ordinances
The Governor generally acts on advice, but has some discretion, such as choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a majority, or reporting to the President that the government cannot be carried on under the Constitution. When the Assembly is not in session, the Governor can issue an ordinance (Article 213) if immediate action is needed. An ordinance must be placed before the Assembly when it meets, and it lapses six weeks after the Assembly reassembles, unless it is passed earlier.
The pardoning power
Under Article 161 the Governor can grant pardons, reprieves and similar relief for offences against state law. For a death sentence, the Governor can suspend, remit or commute it, but a pardon of a death sentence belongs to the President. This is a favourite trap.
Governor and Chief Minister
-
Governor
- Appointed by the President
- Holds office at the President's pleasure
- Nominal head
- Issues ordinances when the Assembly is not in session
-
Chief Minister
- Appointed by the Governor
- Needs a majority in the Assembly
- Real head of the government
- Leads the Council of Ministers
Memory method: A-A-A
Remember: the President Appoints the Governor, the Governor Appoints the Chief Minister, and the Chief Minister Advises the Governor on the other ministers. It is a chain of three As.
Worked example 1: pick the false statement
Statements: (a) The Governor is appointed by the President. (b) The Governor is elected by the Legislative Assembly. (c) The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor. Working: (b) is false. The Assembly does not elect the Governor.
Worked example 2: ordinance
Question: the Assembly reassembles on 10 March. By which date does an ordinance lapse if it is not passed? Working: six weeks after 10 March is 21 April, because six weeks is 42 days and 21 days of March (from 10 to 31 March) plus 21 days of April give 42 days. The ordinance lapses on 21 April unless the Assembly passes it earlier or disapproves it.
Worked example 3: the death sentence
Question: can the Governor pardon a death sentence? Working: no. The Governor can suspend, remit or commute it, but the power to pardon it rests with the President.
President appoints Governor; Governor appoints CM; CM advises on ministers.
Key takeaways
- Learn the chain: President, Governor, Chief Minister, ministers.
- The Governor resigns to the President and takes the oath before the High Court's Chief Justice.
- An ordinance lapses six weeks after the Assembly reassembles.
- The Governor cannot pardon a death sentence.
Check your understanding
-
1. To whom does a Governor address his or her resignation?
- The Chief Minister
- The President
- The Speaker
- The Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: B. The Governor holds office at the pleasure of the President and resigns to the President.
-
2. Who administers the oath of office to the Governor?
- The Chief Justice of the High Court
- The President
- The Speaker
- The Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: A. The oath is taken before the Chief Justice of the High Court (or a senior judge in his absence).
-
3. Which of these can a Governor not do?
- Commute a death sentence
- Suspend a sentence
- Issue an ordinance when the Assembly is not in session
- Pardon a death sentence
Show answer
Answer: D. The pardon of a death sentence is a power of the President; the Governor can only suspend, remit or commute it.
-
4. An ordinance is placed before the Assembly. After how long from the reassembly does it lapse if not passed?
- Six days
- Six months
- Six weeks
- One year
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 213 says six weeks from the reassembly of the legislature.
-
5. Which statement about the Chief Minister is true?
- Appointed by the President
- Elected directly by all voters of the state
- Appointed by the Governor and commanding a majority in the Assembly
- Appointed by the Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: C. The Governor appoints the leader who commands a majority.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.