- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Local government traps: 73rd and 74th, Gram Sabha and the State Election Commission
Avoid the usual mix-ups between the two amendments, the two Schedules, the Gram Sabha and the election bodies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Panchayati Raj questions repeat the same few facts in different dress. Which amendment? Which Schedule? Who conducts the election? This lesson lists the traps and a way to answer each quickly.
By the end of this lesson you can:
- Match 73rd and 74th with rural and urban bodies.
- Match the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules with the right bodies.
- Separate the State Election Commission from the Election Commission of India.
Rural and urban pairs
| Item | Rural (Panchayats) | Urban (Municipalities) |
|---|---|---|
| Amendment | 73rd | 74th |
| Part of the Constitution | Part IX | Part IXA |
| Schedule of subjects | Eleventh | Twelfth |
| Local body in Goa | Village Panchayat, Zilla Panchayat | Municipal bodies |
Memory method: 73 comes before 74, and rural comes before urban in the Constitution's order. Eleven goes with the village and twelve with the town in the same order.
Other traps
- Elections to panchayats and municipalities are conducted by the State Election Commission, not the Election Commission of India. The latter conducts elections to Parliament, the state Assemblies and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- The Gram Sabha is made up of all the registered voters of the village. It is not the elected Panchayat.
- The State Finance Commission is constituted to review the finances of local bodies, and a fresh one comes at the end of every fifth year.
- Goa has two tiers. The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee of 1957 recommended three tiers, and the Ashok Mehta Committee of 1977 recommended two, which is closer to the pattern in Goa.
Local bodies and their constitutional base
- Panchayats 73rd Amendment, Part IX, Eleventh Schedule
- Municipalities 74th Amendment, Part IXA, Twelfth Schedule
The word Zilla means district. The Zilla Panchayat is the district-level body in Goa and has elected members. It is a different body from the office of the Collector.
Here is how to answer a typical one-line question in about ten seconds. Read the key word. If it says village, Gram Sabha, Sarpanch or Panchayat, think of the 73rd Amendment, Part IX and the Eleventh Schedule. If it says town, municipality or municipal council, think of the 74th Amendment, Part IXA and the Twelfth Schedule. If it says election of a local body, think of the State Election Commission. If it says funds, think of the State Finance Commission. Then check the options for a swap of the two numbers.
Another point is the term. Both Panchayats and municipalities have a five-year term, and if one is dissolved early, a fresh election must be held within six months. A body elected after an early dissolution serves only for the remainder of the five-year term. Seats are also reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in proportion to their numbers in the area, and one-third of those reserved seats are for women of those groups. Reservation for women applies to the offices of chairperson as well, in a rotating way fixed by the state law.
Worked example 1: match
Question: which amendment deals with municipalities? Working: the 74th. The 73rd deals with Panchayats.
Worked example 2: who holds the election?
Question: who conducts a Village Panchayat election in Goa? Working: the State Election Commission, because local body elections are its job and not that of the Election Commission of India.
Worked example 3: reservation arithmetic
Question: a Zilla Panchayat has 18 seats. What is the minimum number reserved for women? Working: one-third of 18 is 6, so at least 6 seats.
73 = rural = Part IX = Eleventh Schedule. 74 = urban = Part IXA = Twelfth Schedule.
Key takeaways
- 73rd with Panchayats, 74th with municipalities.
- The State Election Commission runs local body elections.
- The Gram Sabha is all voters, not only the members.
- Goa has two tiers of Panchayati Raj.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Schedule lists the subjects for panchayats?
- The Eleventh Schedule
- The Eighth Schedule
- The Twelfth Schedule
- The Tenth Schedule
Show answer
Answer: A. The Eleventh Schedule is for panchayats; the Twelfth is for municipalities.
-
2. Who conducts elections to the Village Panchayats of Goa?
- The Election Commission of India
- The Governor
- The Collector
- The State Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: D. The Constitution gives this job to the State Election Commission.
-
3. A Zilla Panchayat has 12 seats. What is the minimum for women?
- 3
- 6
- 4
- 8
Show answer
Answer: C. One-third of 12 is 4.
-
4. Which part of the Constitution deals with municipalities?
- Part IX
- Part IXA
- Part XI
- Part XII
Show answer
Answer: B. Part IXA was added by the 74th Amendment; Part IX is for panchayats.
-
5. The Gram Sabha is
- The elected members of the Zilla Panchayat
- The body of all registered voters of the village
- The staff of the taluka office
- The Sarpanch and the Deputy Sarpanch
Show answer
Answer: B. All registered voters of the Panchayat area form the Gram Sabha.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.