- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Industrial, FDI and disinvestment reforms: practice and traps
Classify industrial and investment reforms correctly, compute foreign equity shares after new issues, and work out government stakes and proceeds in disinvestment questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The 1991 Industrial Policy Statement rewrote the rules for private and foreign business. Exam questions here are of two kinds: statement questions full of near-miss wording, and small calculations about who owns what share of a company after shares are issued or sold. This lesson drills both.
What changed, stated precisely
- Industrial licensing was abolished for all but a short list of industries (strategic, hazardous or environmentally sensitive). Note: 'abolished for all industries' is false.
- The list of industries reserved for the public sector was cut sharply and has been narrowed further since.
- The MRTP Act's asset-size limits on large companies were removed; the Competition Act, 2002 later replaced the MRTP Act and shifted the focus from size to conduct.
- Foreign direct investment up to 51% was given automatic approval in a list of high-priority industries, and limits and routes were widened in later years.
- FERA (1973) was replaced by FEMA (1999): violations became civil matters rather than criminal offences.
Disinvestment versus privatisation
Disinvestment is the sale of part of the government's equity in a public sector enterprise. If the government keeps more than 50%, control and public sector status stay with it; this is minority disinvestment. A strategic sale transfers management control, often with a large block of shares, to a private buyer; this is true privatisation. So every strategic sale involves disinvestment, but not every disinvestment is privatisation. Disinvestment proceeds are non-debt capital receipts in the budget.
Worked example 1: foreign share after a new issue
An Indian company has 60 lakh shares, all held by Indians. A foreign investor subscribes to 40 lakh new shares. Step 1: total shares = 60 + 40 = 100 lakh. Step 2: foreign share = 40 ÷ 100 = 40%. Now, how many new shares would give the foreigner exactly 51%? Let x be new shares: x ÷ (60 + x) = 0.51, so x = 0.51 × 60 ÷ 0.49 = 62.45 lakh. Speed method: the Indian holders' 60 lakh must become 49% of the total, so total = 60 ÷ 0.49 = 122.45 lakh, and new shares = 122.45 − 60 = 62.45 lakh. The trap is to take 51% of 60 lakh (30.6 lakh), forgetting that new shares enlarge the total.
Worked example 2: stake and proceeds in disinvestment
The government owns 9 crore of a company's 10 crore shares (90%). It sells 2.5 crore shares at ₹80 each. Step 1: proceeds = 2.5 crore × 80 = ₹200 crore. Step 2: new holding = 6.5 crore shares = 65%. Step 3: how many more shares can it sell and still hold a majority? It must keep more than 5 crore shares; selling 1.5 crore more leaves exactly 5 crore (50%), which is not a majority. So the most it can sell while keeping a majority is just under 1.5 crore shares. Step 4: if it sells 1.4 crore more, it holds 5.1 crore = 51%. Note that selling existing government shares does not change the total number of shares, unlike a new issue.
Statement traps to recognise
- 'Licensing was abolished for all industries' - false; a short list remained.
- 'Disinvestment always means privatisation' - false; minority sales keep government control.
- 'FEMA made foreign exchange violations criminal offences' - false; it made them civil.
- 'The Competition Act regulates firms by their size' - false; it regulates anti-competitive conduct and abuse of dominance.
New issue: foreign share = new ÷ (old + new). Sale of existing shares: the total stays the same. A majority needs more than 50%.
Key takeaways. Read reform statements for absolute words: 'all', 'always', 'criminal', 'size'. In share questions, first decide whether shares are newly issued (total rises) or transferred (total unchanged). Distinguish minority disinvestment from strategic sale, and remember that proceeds are non-debt capital receipts.
Check your understanding
-
1. A company has 30 lakh shares held by Indians. A foreign investor subscribes 20 lakh new shares. What is the foreign share?
- 66.67%
- 40%
- 20%
- 50%
Show answer
Answer: B. Total = 30 + 20 = 50 lakh. Foreign share = 20 ÷ 50 = 40%.
-
2. A company has 49 lakh Indian-held shares. How many new shares must a foreign investor subscribe to hold exactly 51%?
- 25 lakh
- 49 lakh
- 51 lakh
- 24.99 lakh
Show answer
Answer: C. Indians' 49 lakh must be 49% of the total, so total = 100 lakh and new shares = 100 − 49 = 51 lakh.
-
3. Which statement is correct?
- Every disinvestment is a privatisation
- FEMA made foreign exchange violations civil matters
- The 1991 policy abolished licensing for all industries
- The Competition Act regulates firms by asset size
Show answer
Answer: B. FEMA treats violations as civil matters. The other statements are the standard traps: minority disinvestment is not privatisation, a short list still needed licences, and the Competition Act targets conduct, not size.
-
4. The government holds 80% of 5 crore shares and sells 1 crore shares at ₹150 each. What are its new stake and the proceeds?
- 60% and ₹150 crore
- 70% and ₹150 crore
- 60% and ₹1,500 crore
- 75% and ₹150 crore
Show answer
Answer: A. Holding = 4 crore shares; after selling 1 crore, 3 crore of 5 crore = 60%. Proceeds = 1 crore × 150 = ₹150 crore.
-
5. In the budget, disinvestment proceeds are classified as
- revenue receipts
- debt capital receipts
- non-debt capital receipts
- revenue expenditure
Show answer
Answer: C. Disinvestment proceeds are capital receipts that create no liability, so they are non-debt capital receipts and reduce the fiscal deficit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.