• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The 1991 crisis in numbers: deficits and import cover

Calculate fiscal, revenue and primary deficits and the current account deficit from given data, judge import cover, and avoid the classic deficit traps.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on the background to the 1991 reforms often hide a calculation: a table of budget items, a set of balance-of-payments figures, or reserves and imports. The concepts are simple but the traps are many, especially in what counts as a receipt. This lesson trains you to compute each deficit in a fixed order and to read what the numbers say about a crisis. All figures here are illustrative.

The three budget deficits

  1. Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts. It shows borrowing used for day-to-day spending such as salaries, subsidies and interest.
  2. Fiscal deficit = total expenditure − (revenue receipts + non-debt capital receipts). It equals the government's total borrowing need for the year.
  3. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit − interest payments. It shows borrowing needed for reasons other than paying interest on past debt.

Non-debt capital receipts are capital receipts that do not create a liability: recoveries of loans given earlier and disinvestment proceeds. Borrowings are capital receipts too, but they are excluded because the fiscal deficit is meant to measure them. The commonest trap is to add borrowings to receipts, which makes the fiscal deficit disappear.

Worked example 1: three deficits from one table

Suppose: revenue receipts ₹700, revenue expenditure ₹950 (of which interest ₹200), capital expenditure ₹250, recovery of loans ₹20, disinvestment proceeds ₹30, borrowings ₹450 (all in thousand crore). Step 1: revenue deficit = 950 − 700 = 250. Step 2: total expenditure = 950 + 250 = 1,200; non-debt receipts = 20 + 30 = 50; fiscal deficit = 1,200 − (700 + 50) = 450. Check: it equals borrowings of 450. Step 3: primary deficit = 450 − 200 = 250. Reading: more than half of the borrowing (250 of 450) was used for current spending, a sign of poor fiscal health of the kind that preceded 1991.

The external side

On the external side, the warning signs are a large current account deficit relative to GDP, rising short-term external debt, and low import cover (foreign exchange reserves ÷ monthly imports). In 1991 India's reserves fell to a level that could finance only a few weeks of imports, while confidence collapsed. A current account deficit can be financed for a while by capital inflows, but if lenders stop and reserves are thin, a crisis follows quickly.

Worked example 2: ratios that signal danger

A country's GDP is $300 billion, exports $18 billion, imports $27 billion, net services and remittances +$1 billion and net interest paid $3 billion; reserves are $1.5 billion. Step 1: current account = 18 − 27 + 1 − 3 = −$11 billion. Step 2: as a share of GDP = 11 ÷ 300 = 3.67%. Step 3: monthly imports = 27 ÷ 12 = $2.25 billion. Step 4: import cover = 1.5 ÷ 2.25 = 0.67 months, about 20 days. Speed method: import cover in weeks ≈ reserves ÷ annual imports × 52 = 1.5 ÷ 27 × 52 ≈ 2.9 weeks. Three weeks of cover with a deficit near 4% of GDP is a crisis profile.

Traps to watch

  • Disinvestment proceeds reduce the fiscal deficit (they are non-debt receipts) but do not change the revenue deficit.
  • Interest payments are revenue expenditure, so they affect the revenue deficit and are subtracted only for the primary deficit.
  • The primary deficit can be zero or negative while the fiscal deficit is positive: this happens when interest payments are equal to or larger than the fiscal deficit.
  • Import cover uses monthly imports, not annual imports; dividing by annual imports gives the answer in years.

FD = total expenditure − revenue receipts − non-debt capital receipts = borrowing. PD = FD − interest. RD = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts.

Key takeaways. Compute revenue, fiscal and primary deficits in that order and check that the fiscal deficit equals borrowing. Treat loan recoveries and disinvestment as non-debt receipts. On the external side, convert to ratios: deficit to GDP and reserves to monthly imports. These were the numbers that made the 1991 reforms unavoidable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Revenue receipts 500, revenue expenditure 620, capital expenditure 180, non-debt capital receipts 40. What is the fiscal deficit?

    1. 260
    2. 120
    3. 300
    4. 220
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Total expenditure = 620 + 180 = 800. FD = 800 − (500 + 40) = 260.

  2. 2. Fiscal deficit is 260 and interest payments are 150. The primary deficit is

    1. 410
    2. 260
    3. 150
    4. 110
    Show answer

    Answer: D. PD = FD − interest = 260 − 150 = 110.

  3. 3. Which of the following, if increased, lowers the fiscal deficit but leaves the revenue deficit unchanged?

    1. Interest payments
    2. Disinvestment proceeds
    3. Subsidies
    4. Tax revenue
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Disinvestment proceeds are non-debt capital receipts: they reduce the fiscal deficit but do not enter the revenue account. Tax revenue would lower both deficits.

  4. 4. Reserves are $4.5 billion and annual imports are $36 billion. The import cover is

    1. 1.5 months
    2. 8 months
    3. 0.125 months
    4. 3 months
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Monthly imports = 36 ÷ 12 = $3 billion. Cover = 4.5 ÷ 3 = 1.5 months. Dividing by annual imports gives 0.125, which is in years.

  5. 5. GDP $500 billion, exports $40 billion, imports $55 billion, net services and remittances +$6 billion, net interest paid $4 billion. The current account deficit as a share of GDP is

    1. 3%
    2. 2.6%
    3. 1.8%
    4. 2.2%
    Show answer

    Answer: B. CA = 40 − 55 + 6 − 4 = −13. Share = 13 ÷ 500 = 2.6%.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery