- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Direct support against poverty and unemployment: five kinds of help
Group the main kinds of government help into work, self-employment, food, social security and human development, and judge each with simple cost and benefit calculations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Lesson 3 told you that growth with jobs and direct support are the two broad ways to reduce poverty. This lesson looks at direct support in more detail. Governments use many programmes, but nearly all of them fall into a few groups. If you know the groups, you can place any programme, and you can judge it with simple questions about cost and benefit. The numbers here are illustrative only.
Five kinds of help
| Kind of help | Purpose | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Wage employment | gives work in the lean season | public works such as roads, ponds and canals, paying a wage |
| Self-employment | helps poor families start a business | small loans, training and equipment |
| Food support | makes sure families have enough to eat | subsidised grain, school meals |
| Social security | protects those who cannot work | pensions for the old, widows and the disabled |
| Human development | raises skills and health for the future | free schooling, health care, skill training |
Worked example 1: public works and the poverty gap
A family is Rs 1,500 a month short of the poverty line, a gap of 1,500 x 12 = Rs 18,000 a year. A public works scheme offers 100 days of work a year at Rs 200 a day. Income from the scheme = 100 x 200 = Rs 20,000 a year. That is more than the annual gap of Rs 18,000, so the scheme can lift the family above the line, by Rs 2,000 a year. If the wage were Rs 150, the income would be only Rs 15,000, which would cover 15,000 / 18,000 = about 83 percent of the gap.
Worked example 2: a small loan
A woman borrows Rs 20,000 for a sewing machine at 12 percent interest a year. Interest = 20,000 x 12 / 100 = Rs 2,400 a year. The machine brings extra earnings of Rs 6,000 a year. Net gain = 6,000 - 2,400 = Rs 3,600 a year. The benefit is real but modest, and it needs a market for her work. Credit alone, without skills and customers, may not work.
Worked example 3: food support
A family of four receives 5 kg of grain per person a month at Rs 2 per kg, whereas the market price is Rs 30. Total grain = 4 x 5 = 20 kg. Market cost = 20 x 30 = Rs 600; subsidised cost = 20 x 2 = Rs 40. The family saves 600 - 40 = Rs 560 a month. That is a large saving for a family near the poverty line, but the state must bear the cost, and care is needed so that grain reaches the right families.
How to judge a programme
- Targeting: does it reach the poor, or do many non-poor families also gain?
- Cost: how much does it cost to give Rs 1 to a poor family, after administration?
- Lasting effect: does it give only temporary relief, or build skills and assets?
- Dignity and choice: does it treat families with respect?
Five kinds of help: work, self-employment, food, social security, human development. Judge by targeting, cost, lasting effect and dignity.
Key takeaways: place each programme in one of the five groups; compare the benefit with the poverty gap; check costs including interest; and remember that no single programme solves poverty, so growth and support must work together.
Check your understanding
-
1. A scheme that pays wages for building village roads in the lean season is an example of:
- food support
- wage employment
- a pension
- human development only
Show answer
Answer: B. It gives work and a wage during a season when other work is scarce.
-
2. A pension for elderly people who cannot work is a form of:
- a progressive tax
- wage employment
- self-employment
- social security
Show answer
Answer: D. Pensions protect people who cannot earn, which is the purpose of social security.
-
3. A family's yearly poverty gap is Rs 12,000. A scheme gives 80 days of work at Rs 150 a day. The income from the scheme is:
- Rs 24,000, double the gap
- Rs 1,200, a tenth of the gap
- Rs 12,000, exactly the gap
- Rs 230, from adding 80 and 150
Show answer
Answer: C. 80 x 150 = 12,000, which equals the yearly gap.
-
4. A loan of Rs 10,000 at 10 percent interest a year brings extra earnings of Rs 3,000 a year. The net gain is:
- Rs 2,000
- Rs 3,000
- Rs 1,000
- Rs 4,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Interest = 10,000 x 10 / 100 = 1,000. Net gain = 3,000 - 1,000 = 2,000.
-
5. A good way of judging a poverty programme is to ask whether it:
- is the most costly of all
- has the longest official name
- reaches the poor and lasts
- began in the oldest plan
Show answer
Answer: C. Targeting and lasting effect are central tests. Cost matters too, but a higher cost is not by itself better.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.