• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Outside the labour force: discouraged workers and why the unemployment rate can mislead

See who is outside the labour force, what a discouraged worker is, and how the unemployment rate can fall without a single new job.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The unemployment rate is a popular number, but it can be misleading. If jobless people give up looking for work, the rate can fall even though nothing has improved. To read the figures well, we must know who is in the labour force, who is not, and why. This lesson builds on the definitions you already know.

A quick reminder

The labour force is the employed plus the unemployed. The unemployment rate is the unemployed divided by the labour force. People who are neither working nor looking for work are outside the labour force.

Who is outside the labour force?

  • Students in full-time education.
  • Homemakers who do only unpaid household work. Their work is valuable but is not counted as employment in these statistics.
  • Retired persons and those too old or ill to work.
  • Discouraged workers: people who want work but have stopped looking because they believe none is available.

Worked example 1: a table of 1,000 adults

Adults in a town
GroupNumber
Employed560
Unemployed (looking for work)40
Students200
Homemakers150
Retired30
Discouraged workers20
Total1,000

Check the total: 560 + 40 + 200 + 150 + 30 + 20 = 1,000. Labour force = 560 + 40 = 600. Unemployment rate = 40 / 600 x 100 = 6.7 percent. LFPR = 600 / 1,000 = 60 percent. WPR = 560 / 1,000 = 56 percent.

Worked example 2: the rate falls without new jobs

Suppose 20 of the 40 unemployed people give up looking and become discouraged. Now the unemployed number 20 and the labour force is 560 + 20 = 580. The new unemployment rate = 20 / 580 x 100 = 3.4 percent, nearly half the old rate. Yet the number of employed people is unchanged at 560. The LFPR has fallen to 580 / 1,000 = 58 percent, while the WPR is still 56 percent. A fall in the rate with a falling LFPR and an unchanged WPR is a warning sign: the improvement may be only an exit from the labour force.

Worked example 3: counting discouraged workers

Some measures count people who say they are available for work, even if they are not searching actively. Suppose the 20 discouraged workers are counted as unemployed. Unemployed = 40 + 20 = 60 and the labour force = 620. The rate is 60 / 620 x 100 = 9.7 percent, higher than the 6.7 percent of the narrower definition. The choice of definition changes the answer, so compare rates only if the definitions match.

A falling unemployment rate is good news only if employment is rising or steady. Check the worker population ratio (WPR) and the labour force participation rate (LFPR) as well.

— Rule to remember

Why participation matters

A low LFPR for a group, such as women, may reflect household duties, social norms, safety concerns or lack of suitable jobs, not only choice. The WPR is less affected by people leaving the labour force, since it counts only those working, so it is a steadier measure of how many people have jobs.

Key takeaways: the labour force excludes students, homemakers, the retired and discouraged workers; the unemployment rate can fall if people stop looking; the WPR is steadier; and definitions must match when you compare rates.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A person who wants a job but has stopped looking is called:

    1. a discouraged worker
    2. a student
    3. an employer
    4. a casual labourer
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A discouraged worker has given up the search because no job seems to be available.

  2. 2. 500 employed, 50 unemployed and 450 outside the labour force. The unemployment rate is:

    1. 5 percent
    2. 9.1 percent
    3. 10 percent
    4. 11 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Labour force = 550. Rate = 50 / 550 x 100 = 9.1 percent. Dividing by the whole population (1,000) would give 5 percent, which is wrong.

  3. 3. Which group is outside the labour force?

    1. a farmer working on a family farm
    2. a person looking for work
    3. a full-time student not seeking work
    4. a teacher with a regular job
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Students who are not seeking work are outside the labour force.

  4. 4. Unemployed people give up looking for work, but employment stays the same. The unemployment rate:

    1. falls, while the participation rate also falls
    2. rises, as the labour force falls
    3. stays exactly the same
    4. falls, while the participation rate rises
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both the unemployed and the labour force shrink. The rate falls, and so does the LFPR.

  5. 5. Which measure is least affected by people leaving the labour force?

    1. the headcount ratio
    2. the unemployment rate
    3. the labour force participation rate
    4. the worker population ratio
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The WPR counts employed people in the population, so it does not change when jobless people stop searching.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery