- Practice
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
Federal finance: sharing taxes and transfers
Understand the logic of vertical and horizontal imbalance, the role of a finance commission and the types of transfer, without quoting any current formula.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In a federation the Centre and states have different revenue powers and spending duties. Questions focus on the settled constitutional logic, not any current percentage.
Why transfers are needed
- Vertical imbalance: the Centre holds the more productive tax sources, while states carry big spending responsibilities such as health and policing.
- Horizontal imbalance: states differ in income and capacity, so poorer states need more help to provide comparable services.
The Constitution provides for a Finance Commission appointed every five years by the President to recommend how shared taxes are divided between the Centre and states and among the states, and the principles for grants-in-aid (Article 280). Its recommendations are advisory, but are usually accepted.
Kinds of transfers
- Tax devolution: a share of central taxes passed to states.
- Grants-in-aid: specific transfers, often for particular needs.
- Conditional transfers for programmes with central design.
- Loans from the Centre or markets.
Worked example 1
Suppose the shareable pool of a tax is Rs 1,000 crore and the states' combined share is 40%. States receive Rs 400 crore. Suppose State A's share among states is 5%: State A gets 5% x 400 = Rs 20 crore.
Worked example 2
Suppose a formula gives weight 50 to income distance and 50 to population. A poorer, larger state scores higher on both and receives a larger share, which narrows horizontal imbalance. A rich, small state receives a smaller share per person.
Vertical imbalance: Centre versus states. Horizontal imbalance: richer versus poorer states. The Finance Commission addresses both.
Key takeaways: transfers fix vertical and horizontal gaps, and the Finance Commission advises how.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Finance Commission is constituted by
- the President, under Article 280
- the Prime Minister
- the Chief Justice
- the Speaker of the Lok Sabha
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 280 provides for a Finance Commission constituted by the President.
-
2. The Finance Commission's main role is to recommend
- the repo rate
- how shared taxes are divided between the Centre and states and among states, and the principles for grants-in-aid
- import duties
- the annual budget of each ministry
Show answer
Answer: B. It deals with tax devolution and grants. Its recommendations are advisory but usually accepted.
-
3. Shareable pool Rs 800 crore, states' share 40%, State C's share of that 5%. State C gets
- Rs 40 crore
- Rs 32 crore
- Rs 16 crore
- Rs 320 crore
Show answer
Answer: C. Pool to states = 0.40 x 800 = 320 crore; 5% of 320 = Rs 16 crore.
-
4. Horizontal fiscal imbalance refers to differences
- between the Centre and the states
- between direct and indirect taxes
- between banks
- among states in income and capacity
Show answer
Answer: D. Horizontal means across states; vertical means between the Centre and the states.
-
5. A devolution formula gives weight to income distance and population. A poorer, larger state receives a larger share. This narrows
- horizontal imbalance
- vertical imbalance only
- the trade deficit
- the inflation rate
Show answer
Answer: A. Giving poorer states more helps them provide services comparable to richer states, narrowing the gap among states.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.