• Practice
  • About 11 min
  • 5 practice questions

Federal finance: sharing taxes and transfers

Understand the logic of vertical and horizontal imbalance, the role of a finance commission and the types of transfer, without quoting any current formula.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In a federation the Centre and states have different revenue powers and spending duties. Questions focus on the settled constitutional logic, not any current percentage.

Why transfers are needed

  • Vertical imbalance: the Centre holds the more productive tax sources, while states carry big spending responsibilities such as health and policing.
  • Horizontal imbalance: states differ in income and capacity, so poorer states need more help to provide comparable services.

The Constitution provides for a Finance Commission appointed every five years by the President to recommend how shared taxes are divided between the Centre and states and among the states, and the principles for grants-in-aid (Article 280). Its recommendations are advisory, but are usually accepted.

Kinds of transfers

  • Tax devolution: a share of central taxes passed to states.
  • Grants-in-aid: specific transfers, often for particular needs.
  • Conditional transfers for programmes with central design.
  • Loans from the Centre or markets.

Worked example 1

Suppose the shareable pool of a tax is Rs 1,000 crore and the states' combined share is 40%. States receive Rs 400 crore. Suppose State A's share among states is 5%: State A gets 5% x 400 = Rs 20 crore.

Worked example 2

Suppose a formula gives weight 50 to income distance and 50 to population. A poorer, larger state scores higher on both and receives a larger share, which narrows horizontal imbalance. A rich, small state receives a smaller share per person.

Vertical imbalance: Centre versus states. Horizontal imbalance: richer versus poorer states. The Finance Commission addresses both.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: transfers fix vertical and horizontal gaps, and the Finance Commission advises how.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Finance Commission is constituted by

    1. the President, under Article 280
    2. the Prime Minister
    3. the Chief Justice
    4. the Speaker of the Lok Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 280 provides for a Finance Commission constituted by the President.

  2. 2. The Finance Commission's main role is to recommend

    1. the repo rate
    2. how shared taxes are divided between the Centre and states and among states, and the principles for grants-in-aid
    3. import duties
    4. the annual budget of each ministry
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It deals with tax devolution and grants. Its recommendations are advisory but usually accepted.

  3. 3. Shareable pool Rs 800 crore, states' share 40%, State C's share of that 5%. State C gets

    1. Rs 40 crore
    2. Rs 32 crore
    3. Rs 16 crore
    4. Rs 320 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Pool to states = 0.40 x 800 = 320 crore; 5% of 320 = Rs 16 crore.

  4. 4. Horizontal fiscal imbalance refers to differences

    1. between the Centre and the states
    2. between direct and indirect taxes
    3. between banks
    4. among states in income and capacity
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Horizontal means across states; vertical means between the Centre and the states.

  5. 5. A devolution formula gives weight to income distance and population. A poorer, larger state receives a larger share. This narrows

    1. horizontal imbalance
    2. vertical imbalance only
    3. the trade deficit
    4. the inflation rate
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Giving poorer states more helps them provide services comparable to richer states, narrowing the gap among states.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery