• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Public expenditure drills: classification, transfers and the best use of a budget

Classify spending, compute transfer shares, apply the benefit-cost ratio with simple discounting, and use the principle of maximum social advantage to allocate a budget.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on public expenditure test three skills: sorting items into the right class, doing short sums on shares and ratios, and judging between uses of limited funds. This lesson drills all three with made-up figures.

Skill 1: classification

Sorting examples
ItemRevenue or capitalDevelopmental or notTransfer or exchange
Teachers' salariesrevenuedevelopmentalexchange
Old-age pensionrevenuesocial welfaretransfer
A new bridgecapitaldevelopmentalexchange
Interest on debtrevenuenon-developmentaltransfer
Scholarshiprevenuedevelopmental (education)transfer

Different books classify some items differently. A scholarship may be called developmental because it builds human capital. Follow the definition in the question.

Worked example 1: shares

A government spends Rs 2,500 crore: salaries 900, interest 500, pensions 300, subsidies 200, capital works 600. Transfer payments (pensions, subsidies and interest in this classification) = 300 + 200 + 500 = 1,000, a share of 1,000 / 2,500 = 40 percent. Capital works are 600 / 2,500 = 24 percent. Revenue expenditure = 2,500 - 600 = 1,900, a share of 76 percent.

Skill 2: benefit-cost ratio with discounting

A project costs Rs 100 crore now and gives benefits of Rs 60 crore at the end of each of two years. At a discount rate of 10 percent, the present value of benefits = 60 / 1.1 + 60 / 1.21 = 54.55 + 49.59 = Rs 104.13 crore. Benefit-cost ratio = 104.13 / 100 = 1.04, just above 1. Without discounting, total benefits would be 120 and the ratio 1.2, which overstates the worth of the project.

Skill 3: maximum social advantage

Dalton's principle: allocate spending so that the benefit of the last rupee is the same in every use. The table shows the extra benefit from each additional Rs 100 crore.

Marginal benefit from each unit of spending
Unit of Rs 100 croreEducationHealth
First109
Second87
Third65
Fourth43
Fifth21

Worked example 2: allocating Rs 500 crore

Choose the five highest marginal benefits: 10, 9, 8, 7, 6. Education gets three units (10, 8, 6) and health gets two (9, 7). Total benefit = 10 + 8 + 6 + 9 + 7 = 40. An equal-looking split of two units for education and three for health gives 18 + 21 = 39, which is lower. Moving a unit between uses raises the total until the marginal benefit of the last unit is nearly the same in both uses (6 in education and 7 in health, with the next units 4 and 5 left out).

Worked example 3: developmental share

A government spends Rs 2,000 crore, of which developmental items (education, health, roads, irrigation) are Rs 1,200 crore and non-developmental items (defence, administration, interest) are Rs 800 crore. Developmental share = 1,200 / 2,000 = 60 percent. If non-developmental spending rises by Rs 100 crore and developmental spending is unchanged, the total is 2,100 and the share becomes 1,200 / 2,100 = 57.1 percent. A rise in one group lowers the other's share even if its own amount does not change.

Transfer payments buy no output. Discount future benefits before comparing them with costs. Maximum social advantage: equal marginal benefit of the last rupee in every use.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: sort items by the definition given; compute shares from totals; discount before comparing benefits and costs; and allocate funds to the highest marginal benefits.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following is a transfer payment?

    1. wages paid to road builders
    2. a scholarship paid to a student
    3. cost of buying computers
    4. salary of a doctor
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A scholarship is paid without any output being bought in return.

  2. 2. Total spending is Rs 400 crore and capital works are Rs 100 crore. The share of revenue expenditure is:

    1. 75 percent
    2. 25 percent
    3. 300 percent
    4. 20 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Revenue expenditure = 300. Share = 300 / 400 = 75 percent.

  3. 3. Total benefits (undiscounted) are Rs 150 crore for a cost of Rs 100 crore. The benefit-cost ratio is:

    1. 0.67
    2. 1.5
    3. 50
    4. 2.5
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 150 / 100 = 1.5.

  4. 4. A benefit of Rs 121 crore comes two years from now. At 10 percent its present value is:

    1. Rs 133 crore
    2. Rs 110 crore
    3. Rs 100 crore
    4. Rs 99 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 121 / 1.21 = 100.

  5. 5. Dalton's principle of maximum social advantage says that spending should be allocated so that:

    1. marginal benefit is equal in all uses
    2. every use gets exactly the same amount
    3. only the largest project is funded
    4. spending equals tax revenue each year
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The aim is to equalise the marginal benefit across uses, so that no shifting of funds could raise the total.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery