• Practice
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why the revolt failed and how to judge its nature

Give the reasons for failure and the competing historical views on whether 1857 was a mutiny or a war of independence.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Two common essay-style questions are why the revolt failed and what it was. Both reward a balanced answer.

Reasons for failure

  • Lack of a single plan and of unified leadership.
  • Limited spread: it affected mainly north and central India; the south and most of the east were calm.
  • Several rulers such as Scindia, Holkar and the Nizam, and the Sikhs and Gurkhas, supported the British.
  • Superior British weapons, communications (telegraph) and resources.
  • Many leaders were fighting for local grievances.

How historians view it

ViewHeld by
Sepoy mutinyMany British writers
First war of independenceV. D. Savarkar
Neither first, nor national, nor a war of independenceR. C. Majumdar

In a good answer, state that the revolt had a mass element and a popular reach, but lacked the national unity and modern ideas of nationalism that later movements had.

Worked example 1

Question: Give two reasons for failure. Working: Absence of unified leadership, and the support given to the British by several princes and the Sikhs.

Worked example 2

Question: Who called 1857 the first war of independence? Working: V. D. Savarkar.

Failure: no central leadership, limited area, loyal princes, weaker weapons.

— Summary rule

Key takeaways

  • Several reasons for failure.
  • Three views on its nature.
  • Balanced answers score best.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which historian held that 1857 was neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence?

    1. V. D. Savarkar
    2. John Seeley
    3. R. C. Majumdar
    4. Lord Canning
    Show answer

    Answer: C. R. C. Majumdar held this view; Savarkar called it the First War of Independence. It remains a debated question.

  2. 2. Which group supported the British in 1857?

    1. The sepoys of Meerut
    2. The Sikhs and the Gurkhas
    3. The taluqdars of Awadh
    4. The followers of Nana Sahib
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Scindia, Holkar and the Nizam, and the Sikhs and Gurkhas, supported the British.

  3. 3. Which of these was NOT a reason for the failure of the revolt?

    1. It spread evenly across the whole of India
    2. Lack of a single plan and unified leadership
    3. Superior British weapons and the telegraph
    4. Many leaders fought for local grievances
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The revolt did not spread across India; it was mainly in the north and centre. The other three are reasons for failure.

  4. 4. Which region stayed largely calm in 1857?

    1. Awadh
    2. Rohilkhand
    3. Bundelkhand
    4. The south
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The revolt affected mainly north and central India; the south and most of the east were calm.

  5. 5. What does the lesson say a good answer on the nature of 1857 should do?

    1. State that it was only a sepoy mutiny
    2. State that every historian calls it a national war
    3. Avoid mentioning any historian's view
    4. Note its mass element and popular reach, but also its lack of national unity
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Views differ (mutiny, First War of Independence, Majumdar's view); a balanced answer weighs its popular reach against its lack of national unity and modern nationalism.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery