- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Why the revolt failed and how to judge its nature
Give the reasons for failure and the competing historical views on whether 1857 was a mutiny or a war of independence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Two common essay-style questions are why the revolt failed and what it was. Both reward a balanced answer.
Reasons for failure
- Lack of a single plan and of unified leadership.
- Limited spread: it affected mainly north and central India; the south and most of the east were calm.
- Several rulers such as Scindia, Holkar and the Nizam, and the Sikhs and Gurkhas, supported the British.
- Superior British weapons, communications (telegraph) and resources.
- Many leaders were fighting for local grievances.
How historians view it
| View | Held by |
|---|---|
| Sepoy mutiny | Many British writers |
| First war of independence | V. D. Savarkar |
| Neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence | R. C. Majumdar |
In a good answer, state that the revolt had a mass element and a popular reach, but lacked the national unity and modern ideas of nationalism that later movements had.
Worked example 1
Question: Give two reasons for failure. Working: Absence of unified leadership, and the support given to the British by several princes and the Sikhs.
Worked example 2
Question: Who called 1857 the first war of independence? Working: V. D. Savarkar.
Failure: no central leadership, limited area, loyal princes, weaker weapons.
Key takeaways
- Several reasons for failure.
- Three views on its nature.
- Balanced answers score best.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which historian held that 1857 was neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence?
- V. D. Savarkar
- John Seeley
- R. C. Majumdar
- Lord Canning
Show answer
Answer: C. R. C. Majumdar held this view; Savarkar called it the First War of Independence. It remains a debated question.
-
2. Which group supported the British in 1857?
- The sepoys of Meerut
- The Sikhs and the Gurkhas
- The taluqdars of Awadh
- The followers of Nana Sahib
Show answer
Answer: B. Scindia, Holkar and the Nizam, and the Sikhs and Gurkhas, supported the British.
-
3. Which of these was NOT a reason for the failure of the revolt?
- It spread evenly across the whole of India
- Lack of a single plan and unified leadership
- Superior British weapons and the telegraph
- Many leaders fought for local grievances
Show answer
Answer: A. The revolt did not spread across India; it was mainly in the north and centre. The other three are reasons for failure.
-
4. Which region stayed largely calm in 1857?
- Awadh
- Rohilkhand
- Bundelkhand
- The south
Show answer
Answer: D. The revolt affected mainly north and central India; the south and most of the east were calm.
-
5. What does the lesson say a good answer on the nature of 1857 should do?
- State that it was only a sepoy mutiny
- State that every historian calls it a national war
- Avoid mentioning any historian's view
- Note its mass element and popular reach, but also its lack of national unity
Show answer
Answer: D. Views differ (mutiny, First War of Independence, Majumdar's view); a balanced answer weighs its popular reach against its lack of national unity and modern nationalism.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.