- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Writers, historians and sources on 1857
Learn the main writers and works on the Revolt, and how to use them in questions on how 1857 is described.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the nature of the Revolt ask who held which view and which book or source is linked with whom. This lesson gives a table of works, the approach of each writer and a method for answering questions on interpretations.
Works and writers
| Work or writer | Nature | Main idea |
|---|---|---|
| Savarkar, The Indian War of Independence, 1857 (1909) | Book by a nationalist | Presented the Revolt as a national war for freedom |
| R. C. Majumdar, The Sepoy Mutiny and the Revolt of 1857 (1957) | Historian's study | Argued that it was not the first, nor national, nor a war of independence |
| S. N. Sen, Eighteen Fifty-Seven (1957) | Historian's study | Held that what began as a fight for religion became, in places, a war of independence |
| Sir Syed Ahmad Khan, Asbab-e-Baghawat-e-Hind (1859) | Pamphlet | Examined the causes of the Revolt and put the blame on policy errors |
| Kaye and Malleson | British histories | Described the Revolt largely as a mutiny and gave the British view |
| Vishnu Bhatt Godse, Majha Pravas | Eyewitness account in Marathi | A traveller's account of the journey through the affected areas |
| Mirza Ghalib, Dastanbuy | Diary in Persian | A Delhi poet's account of the siege and fall of the city |
The three broad views
- Sepoy Mutiny: a revolt of soldiers, limited in aim. This was the British view of the time.
- National rising / First War of Independence: a struggle against foreign rule with wide support. This was Savarkar's view.
- Mixed or limited view: it had mass support in places but lacked unity, a shared aim or leadership; Majumdar and others hold versions of this.
Historians separate primary sources from secondary ones. A primary source was produced at the time by someone who saw events, such as Ghalib's diary or Godse's account. A secondary source is a later study that uses such evidence, such as the books of Majumdar and Sen. Each type has uses and limits: an eyewitness may see only a small part of events and may have a point of view, while a later historian can compare many accounts but did not see the events.
How to answer a question on interpretation
- State the question: how can the Revolt be described?
- Give each view with its holder.
- Give evidence for and against: for example, civilians joined (for) but whole regions stayed away (against).
- Conclude with a balanced judgement.
Worked examples
Example 1. Who wrote 'The Indian War of Independence, 1857' and in which year? Working: Savarkar, in 1909.
Example 2. How many years after the Revolt was the Majumdar study published? Working: the Revolt was in 1857 and the study appeared in 1957, so 100 years later.
Example 3. Which source would you use to learn about everyday life in Delhi during the siege? Working: Ghalib's Dastanbuy, since the poet lived there and wrote a diary. Savarkar's book is a later interpretation, not an eyewitness account.
Example 4. A question says that Sir Syed Ahmad Khan was an official British historian. Working: this is wrong. He was an Indian reformer and writer who analysed the causes and argued that British policy had caused discontent.
Savarkar 1909: national war. Majumdar 1957: neither first, national nor a war of independence. Sen 1957: from religion to independence in places. Sir Syed 1859: causes. Ghalib: Dastanbuy.
Key takeaways. Match each view with its holder. Separate eyewitness sources from later interpretations. In essays, use a balanced conclusion.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Indian War of Independence, 1857 was written by
- Mirza Ghalib
- R. C. Majumdar
- Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
- V. D. Savarkar
Show answer
Answer: D. Savarkar wrote it in 1909.
-
2. The Dastanbuy is a diary by
- Mirza Ghalib
- Vishnu Bhatt Godse
- S. N. Sen
- J. W. Kaye
Show answer
Answer: A. Ghalib wrote the Dastanbuy about Delhi in 1857 and 1858.
-
3. Who wrote on the causes in Asbab-e-Baghawat-e-Hind?
- Ramesh C. Majumdar
- Vinayak D. Savarkar
- George B. Malleson
- Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
Show answer
Answer: D. Sir Syed wrote it in 1859.
-
4. Which view did R. C. Majumdar hold?
- It was fully national and planned
- It was a purely religious event
- It was neither first nor national
- It was a plot by foreign powers
Show answer
Answer: C. This was Majumdar's view.
-
5. An eyewitness account in Marathi of the journey through the affected areas is
- Majha Pravas
- Dastanbuy
- Asbab-e-Baghawat
- Eighteen Fifty-Seven
Show answer
Answer: A. Majha Pravas is Vishnu Bhatt Godse's account.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.