• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Constitutional, statutory or executive? Classification drill with traps

Classify bodies by their source, handle the bodies that changed status, and spot the wording traps in 'which is constitutional' questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The same question appears in many forms: 'Which of the following is a constitutional body?', 'Which is not statutory?', 'Which was made constitutional by an Amendment?'. A fast drill is to sort every body you meet into three boxes and to learn the few bodies that moved from one box to another.

The three boxes

Quick sort
ConstitutionalStatutoryExecutive
Election Commission, UPSC, State PSC, Finance Commission, CAG, Attorney General, GST Council, National Commissions for SC, ST and BCNHRC, Central Information Commission, Lokpal, SEBI, UGC, Competition Commission, National Green Tribunal, Reserve Bank of IndiaLaw Commission, NITI Aayog, National Development Council, Inter-State Council (set up by order)

The movers

  • Central Vigilance Commission: executive in 1964, statutory in 2003.
  • National Commission for Backward Classes: statutory in 1993, constitutional in 2018 (Article 338B).
  • Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes commissions: a single commission by the 65th Amendment in 1990, split into two by the 89th Amendment in 2003.
  • GST Council: brought in by the 101st Amendment, Article 279A.

A useful check on the box is the repeal test. If Parliament could remove the body by repealing an Act, it is statutory. If the government could close it by an order, it is executive. If only an amendment of the Constitution could remove it, it is constitutional.

Trap words

  • 'Statutory and constitutional': a body is one or the other at a given date, not both.
  • 'Always': a body that moved was not always in its present box.
  • 'Important': the importance of a body never decides its kind.
  • 'Provided for': the Inter-State Council is provided for in Article 263 but was created by an order.

Source decides: Constitution, Act or order. Check the date if the question speaks about a body that changed.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: pick the constitutional body

Which of these is constitutional: SEBI, the Lokpal, the Finance Commission, the NITI Aayog? SEBI is statutory (1992 Act), the Lokpal is statutory (2013 Act), the NITI Aayog is executive. The Finance Commission is created by Article 280. Answer: the Finance Commission.

Worked example 2: a statement with a date

'In 2000 the National Commission for Backward Classes was a constitutional body.' False: in 2000 it was statutory, under the Act of 1993; it became constitutional only in 2018. 'In 2010 the Central Vigilance Commission was a statutory body.' True, since the Act of 2003 was already in force.

Worked example 3: odd one out

Which does not belong with the others: Election Commission, UPSC, Law Commission, CAG? Three are created by the Constitution. The Law Commission is an executive body formed by a resolution. Odd one out: the Law Commission. A different list: NHRC, CIC, SEBI, UPSC. The first three are statutory; the UPSC is constitutional and is the odd one out.

Worked example 4: count them

From the list Election Commission, NHRC, CAG, Competition Commission, GST Council, Lokpal, how many are constitutional? The Election Commission, CAG and GST Council are constitutional (Articles 324, 148, 279A). The NHRC, Competition Commission and Lokpal are statutory. The count is three.

Key takeaways: sort by source; remember the movers and their dates; treat 'always' and 'important' as warning words; the Inter-State Council is the classic case of a body provided for in the Constitution but created by an order.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is a statutory body?

    1. Finance Commission
    2. Competition Commission of India
    3. Comptroller and Auditor General
    4. Union Public Service Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Competition Commission of India was created by the Competition Act, 2002.

  2. 2. Which of these is an executive body?

    1. Law Commission of India
    2. Central Information Commission
    3. Election Commission of India
    4. National Human Rights Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Law Commission is constituted by a government resolution.

  3. 3. The National Commission for Backward Classes became a constitutional body through Article

    1. 338
    2. 338A
    3. 338B
    4. 340
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 338B was inserted by the 102nd Amendment in 2018.

  4. 4. How many are constitutional: Election Commission, SEBI, UPSC, Lokpal, CAG?

    1. Two
    2. Four
    3. Three
    4. One
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Election Commission, UPSC and CAG are constitutional. SEBI and the Lokpal are statutory.

  5. 5. The GST Council was added to the Constitution as

    1. Article 280
    2. Article 263
    3. Article 148
    4. Article 279A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 101st Amendment inserted Article 279A, which provides for the GST Council.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery