- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Tenure, age and removal: a numerical drill for constitutional bodies
Work out when a member's term ends under the 'six years or the age limit, whichever is earlier' rules and identify who may remove each office-holder.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Numerical questions on constitutional bodies are quick marks once the rules are fixed: how long the term is, what age ends it, and who removes the office-holder. The calculation is always the same: add the term to the starting age, compare with the age limit, and choose the earlier ending.
The rules
| Office | Term and age limit | Removed by |
|---|---|---|
| Union Public Service Commission member | Six years or age 65, whichever is earlier | President, after an inquiry by the Supreme Court on misbehaviour |
| State Public Service Commission member | Six years or age 62, whichever is earlier | President (not the Governor), after Supreme Court inquiry |
| Comptroller and Auditor General | Six years or age 65, whichever is earlier | Like a Supreme Court judge |
| Chief Election Commissioner | Six years or age 65, whichever is earlier | Like a Supreme Court judge |
| State Election Commissioner | As decided by the Governor, subject to law | Like a High Court judge |
| Attorney General | No fixed term | Holds office during the President's pleasure |
| Advocate General | No fixed term | Holds office during the Governor's pleasure |
A member of a Public Service Commission may also be removed by the President on grounds such as being adjudged insolvent, engaging in paid employment outside the duties of office, or being unfit by infirmity of mind or body; no Supreme Court inquiry is needed for these. The member may be suspended while an inquiry is pending. The age limits, six years and 65 or 62, are set by the Constitution for the Public Service Commissions (Article 316) and by law for the CAG and the Election Commission.
Compute: age at appointment + 6 years. If that is above the age limit, the term ends at the age limit. Removal: Supreme Court judge (CAG, CEC), High Court judge (State Election Commissioner), pleasure (AG, Advocate General).
Worked example 1: a UPSC member
A member is appointed to the UPSC at age 58. When does the term end? Step 1: six years later the age would be 64. Step 2: the age limit is 65, which is higher than 64. Step 3: the earlier ending is after six years. The term ends at age 64, after six full years.
Worked example 2: a UPSC member appointed later
Another member is appointed at age 62. Six years would bring the age to 68. The age limit of 65 comes first, so the term ends after three years, at age 65.
Worked example 3: a State Public Service Commission member
A member of a State Commission is appointed at age 59. Six years would bring the age to 65, but the limit for a State Commission is 62. The limit comes first, after three years. The term ends at age 62. A common error is to use 65 for the State Commissions.
Worked example 4: CAG
A CAG is appointed at age 61. Six years would bring the age to 67; the age limit is 65. The term ends at age 65, after four years. Also, after ceasing to hold office the CAG is not eligible for any further office under the Government of India or of any state.
Worked example 5: who removes whom?
A State Public Service Commission member is found guilty of misbehaviour by the Supreme Court in an inquiry referred by the President. Who passes the order of removal? The President. The Governor appointed the member but cannot remove. For an Advocate General, in contrast, the Governor who appointed may remove at pleasure.
Key takeaways: UPSC and CAG, six years or 65; SPSC, six years or 62; fix the earlier of the two; the Governor appoints but the President removes SPSC members; Attorney General and Advocate General serve at pleasure.
Check your understanding
-
1. A UPSC member is appointed at age 60. The term ends at
- Age 65, after five years
- Age 66, after six years
- Age 64, after four years
- Age 62, after two years
Show answer
Answer: A. Six years would bring the age to 66, which is above 65. The age limit comes first, at age 65, after five years.
-
2. A State Public Service Commission member is appointed at age 57. The term ends at
- Age 63, after six years
- Age 62, after five years
- Age 65, after eight years
- Age 60, after three years
Show answer
Answer: B. Six years would reach 63, but the limit for a State Commission is 62, reached after five years.
-
3. A CAG appointed at age 58 completes the term at
- Age 65, after seven years
- Age 63, after five years
- Age 64, after six years
- Age 62, after four years
Show answer
Answer: C. Six years brings the age to 64, which is below 65. The term ends after six years.
-
4. A State Election Commissioner is removed in the same way as
- A Supreme Court judge
- A High Court judge
- The Attorney General
- A member of the UPSC
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 243K gives the Commissioner the protection of a High Court judge.
-
5. The Advocate General of a state holds office
- For five years
- Until age 65
- During the pleasure of the Chief Minister
- During the pleasure of the Governor
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 165 provides that the Advocate General holds office during the pleasure of the Governor.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.