- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Disqualification of members and election disputes
Know who decides whether a legislator is disqualified, which law applies, and how and where an election result can be challenged.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on disqualification look confusing because three different authorities decide three different kinds of case. Once you sort the grounds into their routes, almost every question is answered by asking 'which ground is this?' This lesson also covers the election petition, the only way to challenge an election to Parliament or a state legislature.
Three routes to disqualification
| Ground | Source | Who decides (MP) | Who decides (MLA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Office of profit, unsound mind, insolvency, not a citizen, disqualified by a law of Parliament | Art. 102(1) / Art. 191(1) | President, acting according to the opinion of the Election Commission (Art. 103) | Governor, acting according to the opinion of the Election Commission (Art. 192) |
| Defection | Tenth Schedule (Art. 102(2) / 191(2)) | Speaker of Lok Sabha or Chairman of Rajya Sabha | Speaker or Chairman of that House |
| Conviction with sentence of 2 years or more, and other grounds in the Act | Representation of the People Act, 1951 (Section 8 and others) | Operates by law from the date of conviction | Operates by law from the date of conviction |
Note the binding opinion: under Articles 103 and 192 the President or Governor must act according to the Election Commission's opinion; they do not decide on their own judgment. And the Election Commission does not decide defection cases; those belong to the presiding officer of the House under the Tenth Schedule.
Corrupt practices
Section 123 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 lists corrupt practices, which can void an election and disqualify the guilty person. Important ones are bribery of voters; undue influence (interfering with the free exercise of the right to vote); appealing for votes, or against a candidate, on the ground of religion, race, caste, community or language; promoting enmity between classes of citizens for electoral gain; booth capturing; and spending beyond the prescribed limit. A person found guilty of a corrupt practice may be disqualified for a period decided under the Act.
The election petition
- Article 329(b): an election to Parliament or a state legislature can be called in question only by an election petition.
- Under the Representation of the People Act, 1951 the petition is tried by the High Court, and must be presented within 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate.
- An appeal from the High Court's order lies to the Supreme Court.
- A petition can be filed by any candidate at that election or any elector of that constituency.
- Elections of the President and Vice-President are different: disputes go straight to the Supreme Court (Article 71).
Worked example 1: which route?
Question: An MLA is alleged to have accepted a salaried post in a state government corporation that is not exempted by law. Who decides whether he is disqualified? Working: Step 1, the ground is an office of profit, which falls under Article 191(1). Step 2, Article 192 says the question is referred to the Governor, who obtains the Election Commission's opinion and acts according to it. Answer: the Governor, bound by the Election Commission's opinion. Had the allegation been that he left his party, the Speaker would decide under the Tenth Schedule.
Worked example 2: challenging a result
Question: A losing Lok Sabha candidate believes the winner bribed voters. Where and when must she go? Working: Step 1, Article 329(b) allows only an election petition. Step 2, it is tried by the High Court. Step 3, it must be filed within 45 days of the date of the winner's election. Step 4, bribery is a corrupt practice under Section 123, a valid ground for setting aside the election. Answer: an election petition in the High Court within 45 days; any appeal goes to the Supreme Court. She cannot, for example, file a writ petition in the middle of the election to stop the counting.
Office of profit and similar grounds: President or Governor, bound by the Election Commission's opinion. Defection: Speaker or Chairman. Election disputes: election petition in the High Court within 45 days; President and Vice-President disputes: Supreme Court.
Key takeaways
Key takeaways. First identify the ground, then the route. The Election Commission advises on Article 102(1) and 191(1) grounds, but it neither decides defection nor tries election petitions. Corrupt practices such as bribery, undue influence and appeals on religion or caste are listed in Section 123 of the 1951 Act. An election to a legislature is challenged by an election petition in the High Court, with appeal to the Supreme Court.
Check your understanding
-
1. Whether an MP has become disqualified for holding an office of profit is decided by:
- the Speaker of the Lok Sabha
- the President, acting according to the opinion of the Election Commission
- the Supreme Court
- the Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 103: questions on Article 102(1) disqualifications are decided by the President, who must act according to the Election Commission's opinion.
-
2. Who decides whether a member of a State Legislative Assembly is disqualified on the ground of defection?
- The Speaker of that Assembly
- The Governor
- The Election Commission
- The High Court
Show answer
Answer: A. Under the Tenth Schedule, defection questions are decided by the presiding officer of the House: here the Speaker of the Assembly.
-
3. Within how many days of the date of election of the returned candidate must an election petition be presented?
- 30 days
- 60 days
- 90 days
- 45 days
Show answer
Answer: D. The Representation of the People Act, 1951 requires presentation within 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate.
-
4. Which is NOT a corrupt practice under Section 123 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951?
- Bribing voters
- Appealing for votes on the ground of caste
- Explaining the party's economic policy at a public meeting
- Booth capturing
Show answer
Answer: C. Explaining policy is normal campaigning. Bribery, appeals on caste or religion and booth capturing are listed corrupt practices.
-
5. An election petition against the election of a member of the Lok Sabha is tried by:
- the Election Commission
- the Supreme Court in the first instance
- a special tribunal of the Lok Sabha
- the High Court
Show answer
Answer: D. Under the 1951 Act, election petitions for Parliament and state legislatures are tried by the High Court, with appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court tries disputes in the first instance only for the President and Vice-President.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.