- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Value of a vote in the Presidential election: the formula and rapid drills
Calculate the value of an MLA's vote and an MP's vote with the rounding rule, find the total value of the electoral college and the winning quota, using illustrative numbers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The Presidential election is the one election in which not every vote is worth the same. A member of the Legislative Assembly of a populous state casts a vote that counts for more than the vote of a member of a small state's Assembly. This is done so that the states are represented fairly and the total weight of the States equals the total weight of Parliament. Numerical questions on this are common, and the arithmetic is simple once the rules are written out.
The two formulae
Article 55 gives the method. The value of the vote of each elected member of a State Legislative Assembly is the population of the State divided by the total number of elected members of the Assembly, and that figure is divided by 1,000. The value of the vote of each elected member of Parliament is the total value of the votes of all elected MLAs of all the States (for this purpose 'State' includes Delhi and Puducherry) divided by the total number of elected members of both Houses of Parliament. The rounding rules differ: for an MLA's vote, a remainder of not less than 500 (after dividing the population by the MLAs) adds one, so exactly one-half rounds up (Article 55(2)(b)); for an MP's vote, only a fraction exceeding one-half counts as one (Article 55(2)(c)). The Constitution uses the census population fixed in the Article; the figures below are made up for practice.
| Step | What to do |
|---|---|
| 1 | MLA vote value = population ÷ (elected MLAs × 1,000), rounded by the rule |
| 2 | Total MLA value of a state = elected MLAs × value of one vote |
| 3 | Add the totals of all states |
| 4 | MP vote value = total MLA value ÷ elected MPs, rounded by the rule |
| 5 | Winning quota = (total value of valid votes ÷ 2), ignoring any fraction, plus 1 |
Worked example 1: three illustrative states
State A: population 48,00,000 and 80 elected MLAs. State B: population 73,00,000 and 120 elected MLAs. State C: population 25,00,000 and 60 elected MLAs. Parliament has 100 elected members in all (illustrative).
Working. State A: 4,800,000 ÷ 80 = 60,000; dividing by 1,000 gives 60. State B: 7,300,000 ÷ 120 = 60,833.33; dividing by 1,000 gives 60.83, and since the fraction 0.83 exceeds one-half the value is 61. State C: 2,500,000 ÷ 60 = 41,666.67; dividing by 1,000 gives 41.67, which becomes 42. Totals: A = 80 × 60 = 4,800; B = 120 × 61 = 7,320; C = 60 × 42 = 2,520. Total MLA value = 4,800 + 7,320 + 2,520 = 14,640. MP vote value = 14,640 ÷ 100 = 146.4. The fraction 0.4 does not exceed one-half, so it is ignored and each MP's vote is worth 146. Total MP value = 100 × 146 = 14,600. Electoral college = 14,640 + 14,600 = 29,240. Half is 14,620, and the quota is 14,620 + 1 = 14,621.
Worked example 2: the half-fraction trap
Question: A State has a population of 51,50,000 and 100 elected MLAs. What is the value of one MLA's vote? Working: 5,150,000 ÷ 100 = 51,500; dividing by 1,000 gives 51.5. The remainder after the thousands is 500, which is not less than 500, so the value goes up by one to 52. Answer: 52. Compare a State with 48,00,000 people and 80 MLAs, where the answer is exactly 60 with no rounding. If Parliament had 90 elected members instead of 100 in Example 1, each MP's vote would be 14,640 ÷ 90 = 162.67, and the fraction 0.67 exceeds one-half, so the value would be 163.
MLA vote = population ÷ (elected MLAs × 1,000). MP vote = total MLA value ÷ elected MPs. MLA vote: a remainder of 500 or more rounds up. MP vote: only a fraction above one-half rounds up.
Speed tips
- Do the division by the number of members first, then by 1,000; the last step is usually just moving the decimal point.
- Write the totals in a small table and check that the sum of the states equals the total MLA value.
- Use only elected members; nominated members and Legislative Council members have no vote.
Key takeaways
- The value of an MLA's vote depends on the State's population and the number of elected MLAs.
- The value of an MP's vote makes the total weight of Parliament about equal to that of all the MLAs.
- The rounding rules: for an MLA, one-half or more rounds up; for an MP, only more than one-half rounds up.
- The winning quota is half the total value, ignoring a fraction, plus one.
Check your understanding
-
1. A State has a population of 30,00,000 and 50 elected MLAs. What is the value of one MLA's vote?
- 30
- 40
- 50
- 60
Show answer
Answer: D. 3,000,000 ÷ 50 = 60,000; dividing by 1,000 gives 60.
-
2. A State has population 91,00,000 and 140 elected MLAs. The value of one MLA's vote is:
- 65
- 70
- 75
- 60
Show answer
Answer: A. 9,100,000 ÷ 140 = 65,000; dividing by 1,000 gives 65.
-
3. A State has population 51,50,000 and 100 elected MLAs. Under the rounding rule, one MLA's vote is worth:
- 50
- 52
- 51
- 51.5
Show answer
Answer: B. The result is 51.5. For an MLA's vote a remainder of not less than 500 adds one (Article 55(2)(b)), so the value is 52.
-
4. The total value of all MLA votes is 14,640 and Parliament has 90 elected members. The value of an MP's vote is:
- 162
- 163
- 160
- 164
Show answer
Answer: B. 14,640 ÷ 90 = 162.67. The fraction exceeds one-half, so the value is 163.
-
5. The total value of valid votes in an electoral college is 29,240. The winning quota is:
- 14,621
- 14,620
- 14,619
- 29,241
Show answer
Answer: A. 29,240 ÷ 2 = 14,620, and the quota is 14,620 + 1 = 14,621.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.