- Foundation
- About 10 min
- 5 practice questions
Duties, rights and Directive Principles compared
Compare Fundamental Duties with Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles and know their legal weight.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Part III has rights, Part IV has directives for the State, and Part IVA has duties of citizens. A clear comparison helps you answer questions that ask about the difference.
Comparison
| Point | Fundamental Rights | Directive Principles | Fundamental Duties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part | III | IV | IVA |
| Directed at | State is restrained | State must follow | Citizens |
| Enforceable in court | Yes | No | No |
| Added in 1976? | No, original | No, original | Yes |
| Source idea | USA | Ireland | USSR |
Are duties a condition for rights?
No. A person does not lose a Fundamental Right just because they have not performed a duty. However, duties help courts to decide whether a restriction on a right is reasonable, and Parliament can pass laws to give effect to them.
Worked examples
Example 1. Can a court punish a person only for failing the duty to cherish the ideals of the freedom struggle? No. There is no penalty attached by the Constitution itself, and the duty is non-justiciable.
Example 2. Can Parliament make a law punishing insult to the National Flag? Yes. Parliament may legislate to give effect to the duty of respecting the Flag.
Rights bind the State, directives guide the State, duties guide the citizen.
- Rights are enforceable; directives and duties are not enforceable directly.
- Duties bind citizens; directives bind the State.
- Parliament can enact laws to give effect to duties.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Fundamental Duties apply to
- all persons
- the State only
- foreigners
- citizens
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 51A speaks of the duty of every citizen of India.
-
2. Of Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles and Fundamental Duties, which are enforceable in court?
- Directive Principles only
- Fundamental Rights only
- Fundamental Duties only
- All three
Show answer
Answer: B. Only Part III rights are enforceable; directives and duties are not enforceable directly.
-
3. Does a person lose a Fundamental Right for failing to perform a Fundamental Duty?
- No, but duties can help courts decide whether a restriction on a right is reasonable
- Yes, rights are conditional on duties
- Yes, but only for foreigners
- No, and courts may never refer to duties
Show answer
Answer: A. Duties are not a condition for rights, though they help courts judge reasonableness.
-
4. Can Parliament make a law punishing insult to the National Flag?
- No, because duties are non-justiciable
- Only with the consent of all States
- Yes, Parliament may legislate to give effect to the duty
- Only the Supreme Court can create such an offence
Show answer
Answer: C. Non-justiciable duties can still be given effect by ordinary laws passed by Parliament.
-
5. Which matching of Part to addressee is correct?
- Part III is for citizens only; Part IV restrains the State; Part IVA guides the State
- All three are addressed only to the State
- Part IVA restrains the State; Part III guides citizens
- Part III restrains the State; Part IV guides the State; Part IVA is for citizens
Show answer
Answer: D. Rights bind the State, directives guide the State and duties guide citizens.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.