- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Rights and duties together: why a democracy needs both
See how rights and duties belong together, tell legal, moral and Fundamental Duties apart, and understand why a Fundamental Duty is not a condition for enjoying a right.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A citizen of India has many rights: to speak, to move freely, to be treated equally, to receive education. But a society cannot work if everybody only claims rights and nobody takes responsibility. This is why the Constitution, since 1976, also lists some duties of citizens. This lesson explains how rights and duties are connected and what kind of duty a Fundamental Duty is.
Two sides of one idea
Think of a village well. Every family has a right to draw water. But the well stays clean and full only if each family also does its part: it does not dirty the water and it helps to repair the well when needed. Rights and duties work in the same way. When I enjoy a right, I depend on others to respect it, and others depend on me to respect theirs. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) expresses this idea by saying that everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free development of personality is possible.
Mahatma Gandhi also stressed that rights and duties are linked. In his view, the right worth having is the one that comes from doing one's duty well. This is a paraphrase of his thinking, not a quotation.
Three kinds of duty
| Kind of duty | Where it comes from | Example | If not done |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal duty | An ordinary law made by Parliament or a state legislature | Paying income tax | The law may punish |
| Moral duty | Conscience, family, society | Respecting and caring for elders | Social disapproval, no court action |
| Fundamental Duty | Article 51A of the Constitution | Safeguarding public property | No direct punishment from the Constitution; Parliament may make a law |
Matching rights with duties
The table below pairs rights with the duties that seem to go with them. These pairs are illustrations to help you remember; the Constitution does not say that a right depends on a duty.
| Right | A related Fundamental Duty |
|---|---|
| Freedom of speech and expression | To abjure violence and to promote harmony |
| Right to education of children aged 6 to 14 | Duty of a parent or guardian to provide opportunities for education |
| Right to life, which includes a healthy environment | Duty to protect and improve the natural environment |
| Freedom of peaceful assembly | Duty to safeguard public property |
Worked example 1: which kind of duty?
Question: Classify each as a legal duty, a moral duty or a Fundamental Duty: (a) paying income tax, (b) helping a neighbour in trouble, (c) respecting the National Flag and the National Anthem. Working: (a) is a legal duty under the tax laws. (b) is a moral duty; no law or article requires it. (c) appears in Article 51A(a), so it is a Fundamental Duty. Answer: (a) legal, (b) moral, (c) Fundamental Duty.
Worked example 2: is a right lost?
Question: Arun does not take part in tree-planting drives in his town. A neighbour says he has therefore lost his right to free speech. Is the neighbour correct? Working: Step 1, the duty to protect and improve the natural environment is in Article 51A(g). Step 2, no Article says that a Fundamental Right is taken away because a duty is not performed. Step 3, the Constitution also gives no penalty for not performing a duty. Answer: the neighbour is wrong; Arun keeps his right, and he cannot be punished for this alone.
Rights say what a citizen may expect; duties say what a citizen owes. Fundamental Duties are in Article 51A, they bind citizens, and the Constitution itself does not punish their breach.
Key takeaways
- Rights and duties go together, but a right is not lost because a duty is not performed.
- A legal duty comes from an ordinary law; a Fundamental Duty comes from Article 51A.
- The Constitution does not itself provide a penalty for not following Fundamental Duties.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which Article are the Fundamental Duties listed?
- Article 51
- Article 21A
- Article 51A
- Article 48A
Show answer
Answer: C. The Fundamental Duties are listed in Article 51A in Part IVA.
-
2. Paying income tax is best described as a:
- legal duty under ordinary law
- Fundamental Duty in Article 51A
- Directive Principle
- Fundamental Right
Show answer
Answer: A. It is a legal duty created by tax laws. It is not listed in Article 51A.
-
3. Which statement is correct?
- A right is lost if a duty is not performed
- The Constitution punishes breach of a duty
- A person who breaches a duty loses citizenship
- A right does not depend on performing a duty
Show answer
Answer: D. The Constitution does not make rights depend on duties and does not prescribe penalties for breach.
-
4. The duty of a parent to educate a child of 6 to 14 years is linked with:
- freedom of speech
- the right to education
- the right to property
- freedom of religion
Show answer
Answer: B. It matches the right to education of children under Article 21A and is itself duty (k) of Article 51A.
-
5. Respecting elders is mostly a:
- Fundamental Duty
- legal duty
- moral duty
- constitutional right
Show answer
Answer: C. No law or Article requires it; it is a moral duty arising from family and society.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.