- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Limits on Fundamental Rights: restrictions, the armed forces, martial law and Articles 33 to 35
Learn the four sources of limits on Fundamental Rights, including reasonable restrictions, Article 33 for the armed forces, Article 34 for martial law and Article 35 on who can legislate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Fundamental Rights are not unlimited. Even the right to free speech does not allow a person to cause riots. The Constitution allows limits, but it controls them. In this lesson you learn where limits come from and what the lesser-known Articles 33, 34 and 35 do.
Four sources of limits
- Reasonable restrictions written into the Articles, for example Articles 19(2) to 19(6). The restriction must be made by law and must be on a ground listed in the Article.
- Special rules for the armed forces and similar services (Article 33).
- Martial law (Article 34).
- Emergency (Articles 358 and 359), when Article 19 may be suspended and the enforcement of other rights restricted. Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended.
Article 33: armed forces and similar services
Article 33 lets Parliament, by law, restrict or take away the Fundamental Rights of members of the armed forces, of forces charged with maintaining public order, of intelligence bureaus and of similar services. The purpose is to make sure that they can discharge their duties properly and that discipline is maintained. For instance, a soldier's freedom to form a union or to hold a public meeting may be restricted.
Article 34: martial law
Article 34 deals with the restriction of rights while martial law is in force in any area. Martial law means that the military takes over government, in an area, in a severe breakdown of order. The Constitution does not define martial law. Article 34 allows Parliament to protect (indemnify) any person in the service of the Union or a state, or any other person, for acts done to maintain or restore order in the area, and to validate sentences passed or acts done under martial law. Martial law is different from a National Emergency under Article 352, which is declared for the whole country or a part of it on stated grounds.
Article 35: who can make the laws
Article 35 says that Parliament alone, and not the state legislatures, has the power to make laws on certain matters connected with Part III. These include laws under Article 16(3) (residence), Article 32(3) (giving other courts power to issue writs), Article 33 and Article 34, and laws punishing acts declared offences under Part III, such as untouchability and trafficking in human beings. This makes the law uniform across India.
| Source | Who is affected | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Reasonable restrictions | Citizens, under Article 19 | Parliament or state legislature, within listed grounds |
| Article 33 | Armed forces and similar services | Parliament only |
| Article 34 | Persons in an area under martial law | Parliament (indemnity and validation) |
| Articles 358 and 359 | Everyone, during an emergency | Constitutional rules and a Presidential order |
Worked example 1: a soldier's right
Question: A law prevents members of the armed forces from forming an association without permission. Is it valid? Working: freedom of association is in Article 19(1)(c). Article 33 empowers Parliament to restrict the rights of members of the armed forces to ensure discipline. If the law is made by Parliament, it is valid. A state legislature could not make it. Answer: valid if made by Parliament under Article 33.
Worked example 2: martial law or emergency?
Question: In a district the military has taken over administration after a complete breakdown of civil order, and a Parliament-made law protects officers for acts done to restore order. Is this a National Emergency? Working: the military takeover of an area and the protection of officers for acts done to restore order are matters under Article 34, martial law. A National Emergency under Article 352 is declared for reasons of war, external aggression or armed rebellion, and is not the same thing. Answer: martial law (Article 34), not a National Emergency.
Limits: reasonable restrictions; Article 33 forces; Article 34 martial law; Articles 358-359 emergency; Article 35 gives Parliament alone the lawmaking power on these matters.
Key takeaways
- Rights can be limited, but only through law and for stated reasons.
- Article 33 is for the armed forces; Article 34 is for martial law.
- Under Article 35 only Parliament can make laws on these matters.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article empowers Parliament to restrict the Fundamental Rights of members of the armed forces?
- Article 32
- Article 33
- Article 34
- Article 35
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 33 gives this power to Parliament.
-
2. Article 34 deals with:
- martial law
- financial emergency
- President's Rule
- preventive detention
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 34 deals with the restriction of rights while martial law is in force.
-
3. Which body alone can make laws under Article 33?
- The Governor
- A state legislature
- The High Court
- Parliament
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 35 gives the power to Parliament alone.
-
4. Which Articles cannot be suspended even during a National Emergency?
- Articles 19 and 25
- Articles 14 and 15
- Articles 20 and 21
- Articles 29 and 30
Show answer
Answer: C. Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended.
-
5. Martial law differs from a National Emergency because:
- it is declared under Article 352
- it means the military runs an area
- it covers the whole country always
- it needs a special majority
Show answer
Answer: B. Martial law is the military administration of an area; a National Emergency is declared under Article 352.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.