• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Taking a rights problem to court: public interest litigation, who may petition and where

Understand how a person or a group can seek enforcement of a Fundamental Right, what public interest litigation is, and how to choose the court and the writ for a simple problem.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A right is only as strong as the remedy that goes with it. In earlier lessons you learnt Article 32 and the five writs. This lesson looks at the practical side: who may go to court, what public interest litigation is, and how to choose the court and the writ when you are given a problem.

Who may approach the court

Traditionally only the person whose right was violated could go to court. This is called the rule of locus standi, meaning the standing to sue. But many persons whose rights are violated are poor, illiterate or in prison, and cannot approach the court. From the late 1970s the Supreme Court, with judges such as Justice P.N. Bhagwati and Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, relaxed this rule. This gave rise to public interest litigation (PIL).

Public interest litigation

In a PIL, any public-spirited person or group can approach the court on behalf of those who cannot do so themselves, for example by filing a petition or even by writing a letter. The Hussainara Khatoon case (1979), about undertrial prisoners kept in jail for very long periods, is widely regarded as one of the first PILs and led to the recognition of speedy trial as part of Article 21. PIL is meant for matters of public concern. It is not meant for private disputes or for publicity, and courts may impose costs on petitioners who misuse it.

Choosing the court and the writ

Which court and which writ?
SituationCourtWrit
A person is held in custody without being produced before a magistrateSupreme Court (Article 32) or High Court (Article 226)Habeas corpus
An official refuses to perform a public duty required by lawSupreme Court or High CourtMandamus
A tribunal is about to decide a case outside its powersSupreme Court or High CourtProhibition
A tribunal has already passed an order beyond its powersSupreme Court or High CourtCertiorari
A person holds a public office without qualificationsSupreme Court or High CourtQuo warranto

Note that the Supreme Court under Article 32 can be approached only for the enforcement of a Fundamental Right, while a High Court under Article 226 can issue writs for Fundamental Rights and also for any other legal right.

Worked example 1: can a lawyer file?

Question: A newspaper reports that several poor prisoners remain in jail long after the maximum sentence for their offence has expired. A lawyer who does not know them files a petition in the High Court. Is it maintainable? Working: Step 1, the prisoners' right to personal liberty under Article 21 is involved. Step 2, they cannot approach the court on their own. Step 3, the relaxed rule of standing allows a public-spirited person to file a PIL. Step 4, the High Court may hear it under Article 226, and the Supreme Court under Article 32. Answer: yes, as a public interest petition.

Worked example 2: choose the writ

Question: A municipal officer refuses, without any reason, to issue a certificate that the law requires him to issue. Which writ? Working: the officer is not performing a public duty imposed by law. The writ that commands a public authority to do its duty is mandamus. Answer: mandamus, from the High Court under Article 226, or the Supreme Court if a Fundamental Right is involved.

PIL relaxes standing: any public-spirited person may petition for those who cannot. Article 32: Fundamental Rights, Supreme Court. Article 226: Fundamental Rights and other legal rights, High Courts.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Locus standi has been relaxed through public interest litigation.
  • PIL is for public causes, not private disputes.
  • Choose the court by the right (Article 32 or 226) and the writ by the wrong.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The rule that only the person whose right was violated may sue is called:

    1. locus standi
    2. res judicata
    3. stare decisis
    4. habeas corpus
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Locus standi means standing to sue; PIL has relaxed it.

  2. 2. A court can be approached by a public-spirited person for those who cannot do so. This is called:

    1. a Presidential reference
    2. an advisory opinion
    3. a judicial review
    4. public interest litigation
    Show answer

    Answer: D. This is public interest litigation.

  3. 3. Which writ would you seek against an official refusing to perform a legal public duty?

    1. Certiorari
    2. Prohibition
    3. Mandamus
    4. Quo warranto
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Mandamus commands a public authority to perform its duty.

  4. 4. Which Article lets the High Courts issue writs for other legal rights as well?

    1. Article 32
    2. Article 226
    3. Article 13
    4. Article 12
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 226 allows High Courts to issue writs for Fundamental Rights and for any other purpose.

  5. 5. Hussainara Khatoon (1979) is linked with:

    1. speedy trial of undertrial prisoners
    2. the right to hold property in land
    3. reservation in jobs and promotions
    4. freedom of the press and media
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The case, widely regarded as an early PIL, led to the recognition of speedy trial as part of Article 21.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery