- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Equality in depth: Articles 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 question types
Practise the finer points of the equality articles: reasonable classification, the grounds in Articles 15 and 16, the clauses that allow special provisions, and untouchability and titles.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Equality questions look easy until the options differ by one word: 'only', 'citizen', 'descent', 'residence'. This lesson trains you to read those words. Every item below is a distinction that examiners have used to build a wrong option.
Article 14: two ideas, one test
Article 14 says that the State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws. 'Equality before law' is a negative idea taken from British law: nobody is above the ordinary law. 'Equal protection of the laws' is a positive idea taken from the American Constitution: people in like circumstances must be treated alike. Because the article says 'any person', it protects foreigners as well as citizens.
Article 14 does not forbid all classification. A law may treat groups differently if the classification passes a two-part test: there must be an intelligible differentia that separates those grouped together from those left out, and that differentia must have a rational nexus (a sensible link) with the object of the law.
Article 15 and Article 16 compared
| Point | Article 15 | Article 16 |
|---|---|---|
| Protects | Citizens | Citizens |
| Area | Discrimination by the State generally, and access to public places | Equality of opportunity in public employment |
| Grounds named | Religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth | The same five, plus descent and residence |
| Key word | 'Only' (discrimination on grounds only of these) | 'Only' (ineligible or discriminated against on grounds only of these) |
| Special provisions | 15(3) women and children; 15(4) socially and educationally backward classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes | 16(4) reservation for backward classes not adequately represented in State services |
Article 15(2) is special: it says no citizen shall be subject to any disability regarding access to shops, public restaurants, hotels and places of public entertainment, or the use of wells, tanks, bathing ghats, roads and places of public resort kept up wholly or partly from State funds. Unlike most Fundamental Rights, this clause operates against private persons too. Article 16(3) lets Parliament, not a State legislature, prescribe a residence requirement for certain jobs, and Article 16(5) allows the office of a religious institution to be reserved for a person of that religion.
Articles 17 and 18
Article 17 abolishes untouchability and makes its practice in any form an offence punishable by law; Parliament's Protection of Civil Rights Act gives effect to it. Article 17 can be enforced against private individuals. Article 18 abolishes titles: the State may not confer any title except a military or academic distinction, a citizen may not accept a title from a foreign State, and a non-citizen holding an office of profit or trust under the State may not accept one without the President's consent. The Supreme Court has held that national civilian awards are not 'titles' in the sense of Article 18.
Worked example 1: reasonable classification
Question: A law charges a higher licence fee from large factories than from small workshops. Does it violate Article 14? Working: Step 1: is there a classification? Yes, by size of business. Step 2: is there an intelligible differentia? Yes, size can be measured. Step 3: is there a rational nexus with the object? If the object is to raise revenue fairly, larger units can pay more. Answer: No violation; the classification is reasonable.
Worked example 2: who is bound
Question: The owner of a private restaurant refuses a customer a table because of the customer's caste. Which article is relevant? Working: The refusal concerns access to a restaurant on the ground of caste. Article 15(2) covers shops and restaurants and binds private persons as well as the State. Answer: Article 15(2).
Worked example 3: spot the ground
Question: Which of these grounds appears in Article 16(2) but not in Article 15(1): caste, sex, descent, place of birth? Working: Caste, sex and place of birth are in both. Descent and residence are added only in Article 16(2). Answer: Descent.
Article 14 protects any person; Articles 15 and 16 protect citizens. Residence and descent appear only in Article 16. Classification is valid if it has an intelligible differentia and a rational nexus.
Key takeaways
- Article 14 covers foreigners; Articles 15 and 16 are for citizens.
- Valid classification needs an intelligible differentia and a rational nexus with the law's object.
- Article 15(3) and 15(4) allow special provisions for women, children and backward classes; Article 16(4) allows reservation in services.
- Article 15(2) and Article 17 reach private conduct.
- Titles: military and academic distinctions are allowed by Article 18; foreign titles are not.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Equal protection of the laws' in Article 14 is an idea taken from the constitution of which country?
- United Kingdom
- Ireland
- United States
- Canada
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Equality before law' is the British idea; 'equal protection of the laws' comes from the American Constitution.
-
2. Which ground is found in Article 16(2) but NOT in Article 15(1)?
- Religion
- Residence
- Race
- Caste
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 16(2) adds descent and residence to the five grounds of Article 15(1).
-
3. A classification under Article 14 is valid if it has an intelligible differentia and
- a rational nexus with the object of the law
- the approval of the President
- the support of two-thirds of the legislature
- a time limit of five years
Show answer
Answer: A. The two-part test is: intelligible differentia plus rational nexus with the object. Nothing in the test needs the President, a special majority or a time limit.
-
4. Which Fundamental Right against discrimination applies even against private owners of shops and restaurants?
- Article 15(1)
- Article 16(1)
- Article 15(2)
- Article 14
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 15(2) forbids disabilities in access to shops, restaurants, hotels and places of entertainment, whoever runs them.
-
5. Who may prescribe a residence requirement for employment under a State, according to Article 16(3)?
- The State Legislature
- The Governor
- The High Court
- Parliament
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 16(3) gives this power to Parliament. A State Legislature cannot do so on its own.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.