• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Scope and limits: Article 12, Article 13 doctrines and Articles 31A to 35

Practise questions on who counts as the State, the doctrines of eclipse and severability, the Ninth Schedule, and how rights can be restricted or suspended in special situations.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The hardest Fundamental Rights questions are not about a right but about its edges: who is bound by it, what happens to a law that clashes with it, and when it can be limited. This lesson collects the edges.

Article 12: the State

Fundamental Rights are generally claimed against the State. Article 12 says the State includes the Government and Parliament of India, the Government and Legislature of each State, and all local or other authorities within India or under the control of the Government of India. A municipality or a statutory corporation can therefore be bound by Part III, while a purely private club generally is not, with exceptions such as Articles 15(2), 17, 23 and 24.

Article 13: key ideas

  • Void to the extent of inconsistency: laws in force before the Constitution (13(1)) and laws made after it (13(2)) are void only so far as they conflict with a Fundamental Right.
  • Doctrine of severability: if the bad part can be separated, only that part is void and the rest survives.
  • Doctrine of eclipse: a pre-Constitution law that conflicts with a right is not dead but overshadowed; if the obstruction is removed, the law revives.
  • Meaning of 'law': Article 13(3) includes an ordinance, order, bye-law, rule, regulation, notification, custom or usage having the force of law.
  • No waiver: a citizen cannot give up a Fundamental Right by agreement.

Article 13(4), inserted by the 24th Amendment, says Article 13 does not apply to a constitutional amendment under Article 368. The Supreme Court's basic structure doctrine later set a limit on what an amendment may do.

Special protections and special restrictions

Provisions at the edges of Part III
ProvisionWhat it does
Article 31AProtects certain laws, such as those on acquiring estates, from challenge under Articles 14 and 19
Article 31B and the Ninth ScheduleLaws placed in the Ninth Schedule were shielded from challenge; the Supreme Court has held that such laws can still be tested against the basic structure
Article 33Parliament may restrict the rights of the armed forces, the police and similar forces to ensure discipline
Article 34Rights may be restricted in an area where martial law is in force
Article 35Only Parliament, not State Legislatures, may make laws on certain matters in Part III, such as penalties for offences under it
Article 358Article 19 is suspended automatically while an Emergency declared on grounds of war or external aggression is in force
Article 359The President may suspend the right to move courts for specified rights, but never for Articles 20 and 21

Worked example 1: severability

Question: A statute has five sections. Section 4 violates Article 19, and the other four can stand on their own. What happens? Working: Under the doctrine of severability only the offending part is void to the extent of the inconsistency. Answer: Section 4 is void; sections 1 to 3 and 5 continue.

Worked example 2: who makes the law

Question: Can a State Legislature make a law prescribing punishment for practising untouchability? Working: Article 35 gives Parliament the power to make laws for offences under certain articles including Article 17. Answer: No; only Parliament.

Worked example 3: during an Emergency

Question: An Emergency is proclaimed because of external aggression. Which of Article 19, Article 20 and Article 21 can be suspended? Working: Article 358 suspends Article 19 automatically. Article 359 orders cannot suspend enforcement of Articles 20 and 21. Answer: Only Article 19.

Void to the extent of inconsistency; severable parts survive; eclipse revives a pre-Constitution law; Parliament alone makes laws under Article 35; Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended under Article 359.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Article 12 includes local and other authorities.
  • Doctrines: severability, eclipse, no waiver.
  • Articles 33, 34 and 35 are about restricting and legislating on rights.
  • Articles 358 and 359 differ in what they suspend.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under Article 12, the term 'State' includes

    1. only the Union Government
    2. only Parliament and the Supreme Court
    3. local and other authorities
    4. only private companies
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 12 includes the Union and State governments and legislatures and local or other authorities.

  2. 2. If only one section of an Act violates a Fundamental Right and the rest can stand, the doctrine applied is

    1. the doctrine of eclipse
    2. the doctrine of severability
    3. the doctrine of waiver
    4. the doctrine of necessity
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Severability: only the part that is inconsistent is void.

  3. 3. Which authority alone may make laws to give effect to the provisions listed in Article 35?

    1. The President
    2. Each State Legislature
    3. The Supreme Court
    4. Parliament
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 35 gives that power to Parliament.

  4. 4. Which Fundamental Rights cannot be suspended by a Presidential order under Article 359?

    1. Articles 14 and 15
    2. Articles 20 and 21
    3. Articles 25 and 26
    4. Articles 29 and 30
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Articles 20 and 21 are protected from suspension under Article 359.

  5. 5. The Ninth Schedule was added to the Constitution along with

    1. Article 31B
    2. Article 32
    3. Article 33
    4. Article 34
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule were added by the First Amendment.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery