- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Sources borrowed from other constitutions
Practise matching features of the Indian Constitution to the countries and Acts they were borrowed from, and avoid the usual mix-ups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Match-the-following questions on borrowed features appear regularly. The Constitution drew on many sources, but the main structure came from the Government of India Act 1935. This lesson gives you a reliable matching table and ways to remember it.
Matching table
| Feature | Source |
|---|---|
| Federal scheme, Governor, Public Service Commissions, emergency powers outline | Government of India Act 1935 |
| Parliamentary government, rule of law, single citizenship, bicameralism | United Kingdom |
| Fundamental Rights, judicial review, independent judiciary, removal of judges | United States |
| Directive Principles of State Policy | Ireland |
| Federation with a strong Centre, residuary powers with the Centre | Canada |
| Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce | Australia |
| Suspension of Fundamental Rights during Emergency | Germany (Weimar Constitution) |
| Ideals of liberty, equality, fraternity; republic | France |
| Procedure for amending the Constitution | South Africa |
Worked example 1: strong Centre
Question: The idea of residuary powers resting with the Union comes from which country? Working: In the United States, residuary powers rest with the states. India chose the opposite, as in Canada. Answer: Canada.
Worked example 2: a non-obvious source
Question: The Directive Principles were inspired by (a) the US Bill of Rights (b) the Irish Constitution. Working: Ireland's directives on social policy were the model, while the US Bill of Rights inspired the Fundamental Rights chapter. Answer: (b).
Rights from America, directives from Ireland, parliamentary system from Britain, strong federation from Canada, Concurrent List from Australia, structure from the 1935 Act.
Key takeaways: Memorise the table in pairs. When a feature sounds like freedom or courts, think America; when it sounds like Parliament, think Britain; when it sounds like a strong Union, think Canada.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Concurrent List was borrowed from
- Canada
- United States
- Australia
- Ireland
Show answer
Answer: C. The Concurrent List comes from Australia.
-
2. Residuary powers resting with the Union is modelled on which country?
- United States
- Australia
- Ireland
- Canada
Show answer
Answer: D. In the United States residuary powers rest with the states; India follows Canada, where they rest with the Centre.
-
3. Which source gave the Fundamental Rights chapter and judicial review?
- United States
- United Kingdom
- Ireland
- France
Show answer
Answer: A. Fundamental Rights and judicial review are American in inspiration.
-
4. Procedure for amending the Constitution is borrowed from
- Ireland
- South Africa
- Canada
- France
Show answer
Answer: B. The amendment procedure is listed under South Africa.
-
5. The ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity, and the republic, are linked to
- United Kingdom
- Australia
- France
- Canada
Show answer
Answer: C. These come from France.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.