- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Sources of the Constitution: reverse questions, exceptions and the 1935 Act
Answer source questions in both directions, from feature to country and from country to features, and handle the 'which is not borrowed from' type with a clear list.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier practice asked you to match a feature to its source. Examiners also reverse the question ('Which feature is NOT from Canada?') and use features that sound foreign but are not. This lesson gives a long reverse list so that you can check any option quickly.
Country to features
| Source | Features borrowed |
|---|---|
| Government of India Act 1935 | Federal scheme, office of Governor, Federal Court (the model for the Supreme Court), Public Service Commissions, emergency provisions, administrative details |
| United Kingdom | Parliamentary system, rule of law, single citizenship, Cabinet system, prerogative writs, law-making procedure, parliamentary privileges and bicameralism |
| United States | Fundamental Rights, judicial review, independence of the judiciary, removal of judges, Preamble's opening words, Vice-President as chairman of the Council of States |
| Ireland | Directive Principles of State Policy, nomination of members of the Rajya Sabha, method of electing the President |
| Canada | Federation with a strong Centre, residuary powers with the Centre, appointment of State Governors by the Centre, advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court |
| Australia | Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce, joint sitting of the two Houses |
| Weimar Germany | Suspension of Fundamental Rights during an Emergency |
| South Africa | Procedure for amending the Constitution; election of Rajya Sabha members |
| Japan | Procedure established by law |
| Soviet Union | Fundamental Duties (added later) and the ideal of justice in the Preamble |
| France | Republic; ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity |
How to use the list
- For a 'not borrowed from' question, find the option that is on another country's row.
- For features that sound foreign but are Indian, such as the Election Commission or the Panchayati Raj Articles, note that they come from the framers' own design or from later Amendments.
- Remember that Fundamental Duties were added in 1976 and drew on the USSR, so a question that places them in the original text is a trap.
Worked example 1: not from Canada
Question: Which is NOT a Canadian feature: residuary powers with the Centre, appointment of Governors by the Centre, Concurrent List? Working: The first two are Canadian. The Concurrent List is Australian. Answer: Concurrent List.
Worked example 2: Rajya Sabha
Question: From which countries do the nomination of Rajya Sabha members and the election of its members come? Working: Nomination of members is from Ireland. The system of election of Rajya Sabha members is from South Africa. Answer: Ireland and South Africa.
Worked example 3: the Federal Court
Question: The Supreme Court's structure follows the model of which earlier body? Working: The Federal Court set up under the 1935 Act. Answer: The Federal Court.
Worked example 4: count the rows
Question: In the table above, how many countries (not counting the 1935 Act) are listed as sources? Working: United Kingdom, United States, Ireland, Canada, Australia, Weimar Germany, South Africa, Japan, Soviet Union, France: 10. Answer: 10.
Rights and judges: USA. Cabinet and writs: UK. Directive Principles: Ireland. Strong Centre and residuary powers: Canada. Concurrent List: Australia. Emergency and rights: Germany. Amendment procedure: South Africa. Procedure established by law: Japan.
Key takeaways
- Use country-to-feature rows to check 'not borrowed' options.
- The 1935 Act supplied the structure; foreign sources supplied ideas.
- Fundamental Duties came in 1976.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Concurrent List is borrowed from
- United States
- Australia
- Germany
- Ireland
Show answer
Answer: B. The Concurrent List is Australian. Canada gave residuary powers to the Centre.
-
2. The procedure for amending the Constitution is borrowed from
- South Africa
- United States
- United Kingdom
- Soviet Union
Show answer
Answer: A. South Africa is the source of the amendment procedure.
-
3. The phrase 'procedure established by law' is from
- Britain
- United States
- Japan
- Canada
Show answer
Answer: C. The phrase in Article 21 is borrowed from Japan.
-
4. The method of electing the President is borrowed from
- United States
- United Kingdom
- Australia
- Ireland
Show answer
Answer: D. The method of election of the President comes from Ireland.
-
5. The Federal Court of the 1935 Act was the model for the
- Supreme Court
- High Court
- Election Commission
- Finance Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. The Supreme Court follows the model of the Federal Court.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.