• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Right to Information Act: how to ask, how to appeal, what is exempt

Follow an RTI request from application to appeal, learn the time limits and exemptions, and see why the Information Commission matters.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Right to Information Act, 2005 turns a simple idea into law: the government works for citizens, so citizens may ask what it is doing. Exams ask about the time limits, the two appeals and the kinds of information that can be refused. This lesson follows one request from start to finish so that every rule has a place in the story.

Step 1: the application

A citizen writes to the Public Information Officer (PIO) of the public authority that holds the information. Every public authority has to appoint PIOs. The citizen does not have to explain why the information is wanted. The PIO must give a reply within 30 days. If the request concerns the life or liberty of a person, the reply is due within 48 hours. A PIO who gives no reply in time is treated as having refused, and this is called a deemed refusal.

Step 2: the two appeals

If the citizen is refused, or is unhappy with the reply, there are two steps, one after the other.

  1. First appeal: to a senior officer in the same public authority, called the First Appellate Authority, normally within 30 days of the decision or of the day the reply was due.
  2. Second appeal: to the Information Commission (the Central Information Commission for central bodies, a State Information Commission for state bodies), normally within 90 days of the first appeal decision.

The Commission can order the information to be given, and it can impose a penalty on an officer who delayed or refused without reasonable cause. This is why its orders are described as binding, unlike the recommendations of the NHRC.

Step 3: what can be refused

The right is wide but not unlimited. The Act lists exemptions, mainly in Section 8. Information can be refused when giving it would harm the sovereignty and integrity of India, national security or relations with a foreign state; when a court has forbidden its publication; when it would breach the privileges of Parliament or a State Legislature; when it is a trade secret; or when it is personal information (an exemption widened by the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023). There is also a public interest test: even exempt information may be given if the public interest in disclosure is greater than the harm. Some security and intelligence organisations are kept outside the Act, but information about corruption and human-rights violations in them must still be given.

The RTI path at a glance
StageTo whomNormal time
ApplicationPublic Information OfficerReply in 30 days (48 hours for life or liberty)
First appealSenior officer in the same authorityWithin 30 days
Second appealInformation CommissionWithin 90 days

Worked example 1: counting the days

Rohan applies to a department on 10 June (any year) for the repair records of a village road and gets no reply. Step 1: the reply was due 30 days later, that is on 10 July. Step 2: the silence is a deemed refusal, so Rohan can make the first appeal. Step 3: he has 30 days from 10 July, so until 9 August. If he is then refused again on 5 March of a later year, the second appeal is due within 90 days: 26 days remain in March, 30 in April and 31 in May, which makes 87 days, so the last date is 3 June. The dates here are only an illustration of the counting method.

Worked example 2: can it be refused?

Three requests reach a PIO. (a) A copy of the minutes of a road-safety committee: no exemption applies, so it should be given. (b) The private medical history of a named officer, unrelated to any public work: this is personal information with no public link, so it can be refused. (c) Details of the sanction of a public contract where bribery is alleged: the public interest test may favour disclosure. The skill is to ask two questions in order: does an exemption apply, and if so, does the public interest outweigh it?

RTI: 30 days to reply (48 hours for life or liberty); first appeal inside the department; second appeal to the Information Commission, whose orders bind.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

The RTI Act, 2005 lets citizens ask public authorities for information. Learn the three time limits (30 days, 48 hours, 30 and 90 days for appeals), the order of the two appeals and the idea of exemptions with a public interest test. The Information Commission is a statutory body and its decisions are binding.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A person writes to a public authority and gets no reply at all within the normal time. In law this is treated as:

    1. a deemed refusal
    2. a deemed approval
    3. a court order
    4. a transfer of the request
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Silence beyond the time limit is a deemed refusal, which opens the way to the first appeal. It is never treated as approval.

  2. 2. The first appeal under the RTI Act is made to:

    1. the Information Commission itself
    2. a senior officer in the same authority
    3. the High Court of the state
    4. the Parliament of India
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The first appeal goes to a senior officer in the same authority (the First Appellate Authority). Only the second appeal goes to the Information Commission.

  3. 3. An application on 1 April concerns the liberty of a detained person. The reply is due within:

    1. 30 days
    2. 15 days
    3. 48 hours
    4. 7 days
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Information concerning the life or liberty of a person must be given within 48 hours, so the reply is due about 3 April.

  4. 4. The second appeal under the RTI Act normally lies within how many days of the first appeal decision?

    1. 15 days
    2. 30 days
    3. 60 days
    4. 90 days
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The second appeal to the Information Commission is normally allowed within 90 days of the first appeal decision.

  5. 5. Which information can be refused under the exemptions of the RTI Act?

    1. Minutes of a village road-repair meeting
    2. Information that would harm the security of the State
    3. The result of a public tender after it is awarded
    4. The attendance register of a government office
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Security of the State is a listed ground for refusal. Routine records such as meeting minutes or attendance are ordinary public information.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery